1 long walk or several short walks? New research points to a winner for blood sugar

Walking is known to support blood sugar levels, but new research suggests that how you spread out your walks can make a difference. The study found that taking shorter walks throughout the day was better for blood sugar than one long walk.

In the new study, published in ObesityThe researchers recruited 30 obese or overweight people who were sedentary for more than six hours a day.

For six weeks, all participants walked 45 minutes a day, five days a week. But 15 of them completed the 45 minutes at once, while the other 15 took a five-minute walk every hour or so.

Data from continuous glucose monitors showed that people who took short walks throughout the day saw better regulation of their blood sugar levels, spent more time in a healthy range, and experienced fewer fluctuations.

Specifically, the short walk group increased the time spent in the target blood glucose range (70 to 140 mg/dL) from 82% to 94%, while the long walk group decreased from 89% to 80%. These improvements were largely due to a reduction in the number of hypoglycemic episodes, rather than a reduction in hyperglycemia.

“Rather than relying solely on a single bout of exercise, regularly breaking up prolonged sitting with short walks may provide additional benefits for blood sugar regulation,” said study author Audrey Bergouignan, PhD, associate professor at the University of Colorado Anschutz.

Although the study is modest, it is an “encouraging preliminary signal,” said Britni R. Belcher, PhD, an associate professor at the Keck School of Medicine at the University of Southern California, who was not involved in the research.

“How you move throughout the day can matter as much as how much you move,” she tells HEALTH.

Researchers aren’t sure why shorter walks may be more effective, but they suspect that muscle activation throughout the day plays a role.

When you exercise, your muscles pull glucose from your bloodstream to use for energy. Spreading walking throughout the day can repeatedly stimulate glucose uptake and carbohydrate burning, rather than concentrating these effects in a single workout.

A previous study from the same research team supports this theory, finding that frequent walking breaks increased the amount of carbohydrates burned over 24 hours, compared to a long walk.

“This is what makes our study particularly important,” Bergouignan told HEALTH. “This suggests that the pattern of physical activity matters independently of the total amount of exercise performed.”

Experts agreed that not sitting throughout the day can support blood sugar levels.

“For an inactive person, getting up and taking short breaks to walk may seem much more doable,” Belcher said.

But that doesn’t mean you should give up on your longer workouts. Both can help maintain healthy blood sugar levels.

Additionally, the study could not demonstrate that shorter walking breaks could prevent diabetes or reduce cardiovascular risk, Bergouignan noted. The data also did not show that walking improved insulin sensitivity in either group, she added.

“Ultimately, the message is not to exercise less,” Bergouignan said, “but to sit less continuously and move more frequently.”

Gn Health

Logo