Theater review
LOW STATUS
Two hours and 30 minutes, with an intermission. At the Booth Theater, 222 West 45th St.
At first, it’s almost calming. Most of the images on the Booth Theater stage as the audience takes their seats before “Downstate” are familiar images found in many American plays: a couch, a kitchen, a dining table. You know the principle.
But look up from your Playbill and you’ll notice a strange and disturbing detail lurking in the corner: a television broadcasting an episode of the animated children’s show “The Smurfs.” Eh?
These little blue gnomes, sweet and innocent, are chased, as always, by the evil, bald and single Gargamel.
Initially random, this strange video ends up serving as an overture for provocative playwright Bruce Norris, who knows full well that the majority of the audience – let alone the world – here regards his main characters as repulsive, real-life Gargamels.
They are, if you can believe it, convicted sex offenders and pedophiles – representatives of the ultimate taboo, and usually not the kind you find in Broadway shows.
For this reason alone, many people will be reluctant to hear about “Downstate,” which debuted Sunday night. The play sparked enormous controversy four years ago when it ran off-Broadway at Playwrights Horizons, largely fanned by people who hadn’t actually watched it. Big shock.
But his palpable danger, utter fearlessness and willingness to rip audiences out of their comfort zone with relentless shocks are what make Norris’s drama far more explosive than anything that’s happened on Broadway in a long time. Easily one of the finest works of the decade, “Downstate” is the best new play I’ve seen since, well, “Downstate.”
The story takes place somewhere in the vast expanse of Illinois, south of Chicago, which is colloquially called “upstate” in the same lazy way that Manhattanites say “upstate” — as if Albany and Buffalo were the same place.
Like these carelessly grouped New York towns, four very different men are confined to this cramped, gray apartment after serving prison time for their crimes. With its carpets and stained ceiling tiles, it’s the kind of abused abode best suited to college students and beer pong.
Resident wrongdoing varies in severity. There are even legal classifications for them, from level one (low risk) to level three (high risk).
Norris, who wrote the Tony Award-winning “Clybourne Park,” doesn’t decide how you should feel about any of these outcasts. He’s smarter than that. What a nice change from theater’s recent tendency toward lecturing, coddling, and affirmation. At recent performances, including my own, spontaneous applause has erupted for arguments from all sides on this difficult issue.
But what the playwright does so effectively is surprise us by letting our guard down. It will make guys seem friendly and repentant for a moment, then reveal them as pathological liars or sick people who would do it again the next moment.
The two older ones are allies: Fred (Francis Guinan), an elderly man confined to a scooter, and Dee (K. Todd Freeman), an outspoken realist who is the group’s de facto spokesperson.
Given their age and personality, our instinct is to love them. That’s what makes them scary.
Fred evokes a mall Santa – nice and jolly, but makes you think. Meanwhile, Dee is the one who mixes up viewers’ feelings the most during “Downstate,” because you can’t believe you’re laughing at her biting jokes.
Gio (Al’Jaleel McGhee), a loner in his thirties, is the only level 1 offender. He met a 17-year-old who was using a fake ID. Gio now works in an office supply store and dreams of starting his own business. But we all know that will never happen.
He’s a charismatic guy and a smooth talker, all the more so played hilariously by the charming McGhee. Yet we question his judgment. Why is he hanging out after hours with his 20-year-old co-worker Effie (Ivy Wolk)? Is he really the budding entrepreneur he imagines he is?
The other solo traveler is Felix (Adrian Martinez), unsmiling and soft-spoken, who confines himself to his room where he spends all day praying.
Ivy (Liza Colón-Zayas), the quartet’s pragmatic parole officer, initially proves harsh. But, during a breathtaking scene with a lying Felix, played breathtakingly by Martinez as the man fumbles in shame, we realize that she is the only rational person in the room.
That day, one of Fred’s victims, Andy (Thomas Sadoski), who is now an adult in his 40s, goes home with his wife (Cassie Beck) to confront Fred and put an end to his situation. His reasons for being there turn out to be much more complicated than that, and the situation escalates in frightening ways.
As the psychological damage inflicted on him becomes evident, Sadoski breaks down in such a shattering way that even the seasoned viewer will be alarmed that the actor has to do this eight times a week.
The apartment’s longest residents are also, fittingly, the longest in the series. Guinan and Freeman have been playing these complex and delicate roles for a while, and it makes sense that Norris made two of the most blatant predators the longest-running characters. Actors need experience to play them.
Lately, in our star-dominated theater landscape, I’ve noticed a lack of listening or paying attention on stage. The artists used to being filmed come out of their lines and point. But the excellent Freeman never lowers his level for a second, glaring intently at everyone as if the hunter And the hunted.
And Guinan, from the original cast of “August: Osage County,” has long known how to use his amiable appearance as a bait and switch. His secret Fred too.
The entire acting, especially that of Freeman and Sadoski, is as muscular and vigorous as Norris’s brilliant writing. And Joe Mantello, fresh off “Death of a Salesman,” directs every scene like a cage match without a single second wasted. It’s a real gasp.
“Downstate” is the kind of play that Broadway doesn’t see much of anymore. It’s rude not to “take your vitamins.” He’s not afraid to piss people off – and he will. It’s funny and chilling and generates passionate conversations.
In short, it’s what everyone wants in a room, people no one wants in their community.
Gn entert
