In many ways, Icahn Stadium, nestled on Randall’s Island in the Harlem River, is a fantastic place to watch football.
The 5,000-seat facility was built in the early 2000s to replace Downing Stadium, an aging relic that hosted Pele’s first game with the New York Cosmos 51 years ago. It sits in the shadow of the Triborough Bridge, and in the late afternoon, fans enjoy one of the most spectacular backdrops in American football: the silhouette of the Manhattan skyline framed by the warm orange and red hues of the sunset. The playing surface, replaced in 2024 by Major League Soccer’s NYC FC, is immaculate.
So yes, the stadium has its charms. But this is no place to host an NWSL game, much less a playoff game.
Gotham FC was forced to host its semifinal against the Kansas City Current in Icahn on Sunday because the club deemed its usual home field — Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey — unsafe. The playing surface was widely and rightly ridiculed following the club’s quarter-final victory over Seattle last weekend, with players from both teams calling it “atrocious” and “so bad”. Reign coach Laura Harvey put it even more bluntly, saying there was “no way we’re playing a playoff game on this shit.”
Just up I-95 in Washington, D.C., the Washington Spirit faced its own problems as it hosted the other NWSL semifinal on Saturday. For a while, it looked like they were going to have to play in cavernous Northwest Stadium, home of the NFL’s Washington Commanders, a venue almost universally despised. The Spirit share Audi Field with MLS’s DC United, who are effectively their owners; United had already planned to host a Division III college football game there on Saturday — only last-minute negotiations allowed the Spirit to use the stadium.
The two matches – one in a stadium suitable for lower-division soccer and the other played on a field emblazoned with American soccer markings – painted a bleak picture of the NWSL’s position, despite its explosive growth in recent years, in the pecking order of professional sports in the United States.
On Sunday, it may have cost Gotham dearly, as it was defeated by the Current. Gotham was well supported at Icahn, where a near-capacity partisan crowd filled the venue with noise throughout the evening. But that didn’t help much: For the second game in a row, Gotham didn’t register a single shot on goal.
Midfielder Midge Purce, whose second-half cross created the home side’s only goal of the evening – an own goal – was in no hurry to assess the club’s performance at the change of venue, saying such things are “never an excuse” for poor performances. However, the situation seemed undeniably serious for a club that was almost unplayable at home this year.
“I would say it’s inexcusable,” Purce said. “That’s not what you want in a professional league. For women coming up in the United States, we’re supposed to be one of the best leagues in the entire world. I think it’s a bad image for everyone involved. We always want to be at the Sports Illustrated (Stadium) in front of our fans and we’ve earned it all season long.”
Purce then absolved Gotham’s owners of any responsibility, saying they had done “absolutely everything they could to create the best situation for us.” She added: “If I knew who to blame, I would ‘attack’ them. I don’t have the names.”
Purce wasn’t arguing, of course, that the game should have been played on a playing surface inferior to Sports Illustrated, and neither was his head coach, Juan Carlos Amorós, who said prioritizing player safety was the “right decision.” The Spaniard nevertheless lamented the decision, speaking wistfully of how it could have affected the result.
“I think that’s part of the sadness,” Amorós told the media. “I think we’ll never know what would have happened if we had played (at Sports Illustrated Stadium) on a good field… It was a sad weekend. I also think about the situation in Washington yesterday. You know, this league deserves better. The two best teams, arguably the most consistent, have to deal with these situations. And then yesterday, you know, you sit down to watch this game all over the world and you see these American football lines… we couldn’t play on our own field where we could have had more people, where we are undefeated for 13 games.
The Current generally doesn’t address this issue, as they are one of the few NWSL teams that own and operate their own stadium. The club’s head coach, Chris Armas, was quick to point out that he wasn’t entirely familiar with the intricacies of what led up to Sunday’s game at Icahn.
“There seemed to be some noise around,” Armas said. “And rightly so, but look, it was a change for them and a change for us. Where the league is and how we’re progressing, our league is changing rapidly. The expansion, the quality of play, the players, the coaches. Things can’t be perfect yet. Those kinds of things will come. Stadiums will come, facilities will be built. But everything has to catch up – and we’re not there. We can be critical, that’s for sure. But the future is bright for our league.”
Gotham won’t have to play their games in New Jersey much longer as they have long planned to move to Etihad Park, the future home of NYC FC, in 2028. Yet even then, they will be playing in a facility that does not belong to them. And while the future of the NWSL as a whole appears bright, last weekend’s semifinals provide a necessary — but unwelcome — reality check.
Gn headline
