Germany, EU states move ahead with plan to expel Rwanda

A group of five EU member states, including Germany, agreed on Monday on a new program to deport rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda.

A plan to create return centers in a third country was announced by the group – which also includes Austria, the Netherlands, Greece and Denmark – in September.

Monday’s announcement comes after the EU introduced new regulations to speed up deportations and allow the establishment of hubs outside the bloc.

EU policymakers have shifted their focus to improving their failing repatriation system, which currently sees fewer than 30 percent of people ordered to leave the bloc returned to their home countries.

Speaking after Monday’s meeting in Vienna, Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker, who called the move a “truly historic paradigm shift in migration policy”, summed up the plan by saying: “If returning (migrants) to their country of origin is not possible, then in the future people without the right of residence will be sent back to a third country like Rwanda.”

Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen hailed the plan as an “important step” that will send a “signal… that you can no longer enter the European Union illegally and think you can just stay there.”

How do both sides present the expulsion plan?

The group of five countries hopes to have the operation operational in 2027, with sources calling it a pilot program that will house around 20 people from each of the countries during Monday’s meeting.

Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta, who appeared alongside Stocker after the talks, put a positive spin on the project, saying it would provide “a second chance for people who no longer have the right to stay in the partner country.”

Biruta said the site will not be a detention center but rather a “reception center” housing migrants who can live and work in the country.

He also called harsh criticism of Rwanda’s human rights record “cliché.”

These criticisms multiplied since the announcement of this project, with some 45 NGOs from 15 countries calling it “a new phase of harmful outsourcing policies” and the group Human Rights Watch highlighting “Rwanda’s well-established record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention and ill-treatment in detention”.

Africa faces new migration shifts under US deportation deals

To view this video, please enable JavaScript and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video.

What do we know about the EU deportation center system?

Rwanda had not been officially named as the chosen country until Monday, but the central African country had acknowledged being in “preliminary discussions” with the group of states.

Rwanda had also been the intended destination of a similar plan set up under the UK’s former Conservative government, which later collapsed in the British courts.

However, the new EU system differs from the UK system in that it only applies to migrants who have exhausted all other legal avenues within the European Union.

Despite the failure of the British agreement, Rwanda remains one of the many countries that welcome migrants this president Donald TrumpThe US administration expelled the United States.

Despite falling numbers of asylum arrivals due to deals with countries of origin in Africa and the Middle East, European governments view migration centers as a way to visibly show they are taking action on migration amid rising anti-migrant sentiment and growing support for the far right.

“Migration paradox”: how borders and aid determine human movements

To view this video, please enable JavaScript and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video.

What are the criticisms made of the deportation center projects?

European leaders have said the plan would comply with European and national laws, but that has not shielded them from criticism, particularly over the plan to send migrants to a country with which they have no connection.

“These policies move people, and responsibility for their safety and rights, out of public view and out of control,” the NGO’s press release read on Monday.

The Council of Europe, a pan-European human rights and rule of law body, said in July that return centers posed “considerable human rights risks.”

Claims that the plan would aim to deter migrants from traveling to Europe have been dismissed by researchers, saying there is no evidence that the deterrent is effective.

“Crackdowns change the way people travel, not their ability to travel. Some stop or change routes, and smugglers adapt and raise their prices,” said Roberto Forin of the Mixed Migration Center, a research institute that collects data along migration routes.

The choice of Rwanda has also been controversial, with President Paul Kagame’s government notably accused of suppressing dissent and supporting the M23 rebel group in neighboring Democratic Republic of Congo.

“Paying Kigali, Rwanda, to host an eviction program would not only cause suffering and harm to those expelled, but it would finance and provide political leverage to a government responsible for serious human rights violations at home and abroad,” said Clémentine de Montjoye, senior Africa researcher at Human Rights Watch.

Rwanda unscathed by the failure of the British migration agreement

To view this video, please enable JavaScript and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video.

Gn world

Logo