Judge issues order blocking Indiana Senate GOP leader Chris Garten from starting new term – Indiana Capital Chronicle

A judge on Monday issued an order preventing Republican Sen. Chris Garten from being sworn in for another term before the expected recount of his tight re-election race.

Democrats sought a temporary restraining order against Garten before the Legislature’s organizational day Tuesday, when the Senate’s Republican majority was considering installing him in the chamber’s top post of speaker pro tempore.

The order issued by Scott County Circuit Court Judge Jason Mount states that “Chris Garten cannot appear to be sworn in as Senator for District 45 or to serve as Senator for District 45.”

A court hearing on Democrats’ request for a preliminary injunction is scheduled for Wednesday afternoon in Jeffersonville.

Garten did not immediately respond to questions about the lawsuit sent to her Senate and campaign offices. Garten said last week he was confident his re-election would stand and called Democrats’ claims “political theater.”

The restraining order sought by the Clark County Democratic chairman argued that problems with voting equipment on Election Day in Jeffersonville left questions about the accuracy of reported election results.

Counts for Senate District 45 — which includes all of Clark County and part of Floyd County — show Garten ahead of Democratic challenger Nick Marshall by 297 votes, or about two-thirds of a percentage point, with 21,817 votes to Marshall’s 21,520.

Democrats are seeking a recount in Senate Republican leader Chris Garten’s tight re-election race.

The court filing argues that Garten should not be allowed to be sworn in for another four-year term before the Indiana Recount Commission can reexamine the race.

Democrats argue that the Clark County Board of Elections — controlled 2-1 by Republicans — failed to adequately examine issues involving four precincts that voted at Jeffersonville High School, where a ballot scanner malfunction was reported on Election Day.

The court filing says it takes time to “resolve discrepancies in ballot records or determine whether all votes cast at Jeffersonville High School were counted in the transition from one machine to another: the machine’s results tape reports 1,640 ballots; 474 ballots were cast before the machine was replaced, but only 333 voters had registered as of 11:08 a.m.; and ballot records show more than 100 voters registered after 7 p.m., an hour after polls closed.

Republican Clark County Clerk Ryan Lynch, a member of the county elections board, did not immediately respond Monday to an email seeking comment on the court filing.

Mount, a Democrat, was appointed as a special judge after the recusal of a Clark County judge, according to court records. Mount is the brother of Republican U.S. Rep. Erin Houchin, who served in the state Senate with Garten.

The judge’s order also blocks the Clark County Board of Elections from certifying the election results until it decides whether to grant an injunction.

Democrats have said they intend to request a recount of the results of the Senate race. Candidates have until Tuesday to file recount petitions, with county party chairs having until Friday to do so.

Clark County Democratic Chair Miguel Hampton, state Democratic Chair Karen Tallian and Ninth Congressional District Party Chairman Adam Dickey said in a joint statement that “the Clark County Board of Elections has left us with no choice but to resolve this issue in court.”

“Voters deserve to have their ballots counted fairly and accurately, and we cannot simply look the other way and not worry about what happened or the legitimacy of the results,” they said. “The fact that this election affects one of the most powerful Republicans in state government makes this situation unique. »

Gn headline

Logo