Transcription
DAVE DAVIES, HOST:
It’s FRESH AIR. My name is Dave Davies. You may remember the controversy surrounding Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s plan to livestream the execution of the man convicted of a mass shooting at Fort Hood, Texas. The live-streaming project was canceled, but during the colonial era, executions of criminals were among the largest public gatherings. Eight thousand people converged on Boston in 1773 to witness the hanging of Levi Ames, convicted of multiple acts of burglary. This story is one of the revelations in a remarkable documentary series on crime and punishment in America that will air this week on PBS and directed by our guest today, Lynn Novick.
The four-part series takes us to a time when prisons were largely unheard of in today’s America, where nearly 2 million people are behind bars, a rate far higher than in other industrialized countries. There are stories of the accused, innocent and guilty, as well as victims, police officers, prosecutors, judges and countless politicians who have staked their fortunes in the fight against crime. It raises critical questions and explores multiple perspectives on how to answer them.
Lynn Novick is an award-winning documentary filmmaker who has collaborated with Ken Burns on several of his acclaimed series. His most recent series, “College Behind Bars,” focused on men and women earning college degrees while incarcerated. His series “Crime And Punishment In America” will air for four consecutive nights on PBS starting tonight.
Lynn Novick, welcome to FRESH AIR.
LYNN NOVICK: Thanks so much for having me, Dave. It’s a pleasure to be here.
DAVIES: You know, you could do a long documentary series about crime in post-war America, or crime since the ’90s, or crime in urban areas, or – I mean, in that case, you really touch on a lot of things, going back to the early Republic. How did you decide to tackle such a broad subject?
NOVICK: Yes, it’s a sprawling subject. For me, it felt like an opportunity to revisit the last 250 years of American history, which we’ve explored in other projects I’ve worked on with Ken Burns – jazz history, baseball history in particular – where we take a subject, an idea, and look at all of American history through that lens. And it was like no one had done this before, and the way we approach crime and the way we punish and how we – why we have prisons and why we incarcerate at the rate that we do, all of these things didn’t come out of nowhere. And I wanted to understand how we got here, and the only way to do that was to kind of go back to the beginning and follow the breadcrumbs, so to speak, wherever it led.
DAVIES: You know, since colonial times, punishment for crimes was usually physical and quite public. So how likely was it that an ordinary citizen would witness an execution in their lifetime?
NOVICK: Yeah. I was stunned to learn from a number of our scholars and experts that executions were common in colonial America for a range of crimes. Not just what we think today about very serious and violent crimes – murder, rape, etc. – but you could be put to death for burglary, adultery, blasphemy, you know, theft – just a wide range of crimes. And from what we understand, most people in colonial America would have witnessed an execution at some point in their lives. This amazes me.
DAVIES: Was it – I mean, was it because they – it was thought that it would deter crime, or was there just such interest in these public executions?
NOVICK: I think the answer is really both: We’ve always been fascinated by those who transgress, who don’t play by the rules and who get caught and have to pay the price. So that – and it doesn’t just concern Americans. Human beings have always been interested in, you know, who are the outlaws, the criminals, and, you know, why did they do what they did? And we want to see them punished.
And the reason the punishment was administered publicly was, I believe, partly to deter – that was the idea – shaming, just to send a message to everyone about the power of the state. So there’s – it serves to – sort of weave the social structure, you know, build community, I guess – and that’s what we, as a community, do to those who, you know, disobey our rules. But it turns out it could also have an undermining effect on all of those things. A huge crowd might gather at an execution and they might sort of start to rile up the mob, and you might even have a riot, and people might get hurt or robbed in the process of getting excited about the execution. They might identify with the person who was being put to death and think it was unfair.
So at the time of the revolution, some of our founding fathers who were actually studying the Enlightenment and thinking about what citizens deserve in a republic and what kind of rights we should have began to put forward the idea that this public punishment and its barbaric nature was actually bad for society as a whole and that we should find a better way to do it.
DAVIES: That’s right. Well, an alternative to corporal punishment is confinement, and that leads us to prisons. What were the first prisons like?
NOVICK: Yeah. Well, the first prisons were… I think it was an experiment. We were trying different ideas. And people who were investing in this idea of a structure – a penitentiary or a prison – where you would go for a period of time, where you would be expected to repent, learn useful skills, and come back into society a better person – what we would call rehabilitation today. Some prisons were built on this idea. Some prisons, like the Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia, which is one of the most monumental structures in Jacksonian America – it opened in 1829 – have been…
DAVIES: And he’s still there (laughter).
NOVICK: And he’s still there. And I certainly encourage anyone within earshot to visit. It’s an incredible place. It’s a museum, and you can really understand in a palpable, physical way what this place was like. It was built to achieve one goal: perfect insulation. You were in your cell 24 hours a day, seven days a week. There was a small courtyard. You had your own private outdoor space that you could enter for an hour a day, but you weren’t supposed to talk to anyone. The staff would come and check on you, but that was basically it. And it was such extreme isolation. As we can understand today, outright isolation was extremely harmful to the people confined there, and they eventually changed the system. But it was a model of incarceration.
And another model was sort of a modification of that, where people were isolated at night, but during the day they were put to work. And they were put to work for two reasons. Firstly, to help finance the cost of running this type of huge institution, which is not cheap, and secondly, to teach them, in theory, good habits. So rehabilitation as an idea was somehow merged with forced labor and solitary confinement. And if we think about these three things going together, I would say that’s really not the case. So we’ve always had some sort of conflict about what we’re actually trying to accomplish with prisons and penitentiaries.
DAVIES: Well, among the older prisons, they found that they could finance the prison by having private employers use the inmates for work. I mean, factories, you know, ironing clothes, whatever. And they have to be big, right? There was a guy named Elam Lynds – am I saying that right?
NOVICK: Yes, that’s correct. Yeah.
DAVIES: Who designed a prison in Auburn. And then there was the one who became known as Sing Sing – I guess he’s from Ossining, New York, right?
NOVICK: Yeah.
DAVIES: Where many prisoners were managed by relatively few guards. And you’re right, or it appears in the documentary that it attracted visits from Europe. Some French aristocrats wanted to see how it worked. What did they discover? How did they react?
NOVICK: Yes, it was difficult for me to imagine a world where there weren’t prisons before. And so when America created this prison system and people started hearing about it, they wanted to come here and see, oh, wow, maybe we should bring this back to France or England or Germany or, you know, another country.
And in the 1830s, two young French aristocrats, Alexis de Tocqueville and Gustave de Beaumont, arrived in America. They were commissioned by the French government to study our system and write a report to see if, you know, France should do the same thing. And what they found was a paradox, in a way, because the prison they visited, Sing Sing and Eastern State, as well as a few other prisons, were run with such extraordinary discipline that it was not necessary to have so many guards or officers or, as they were then called, wardens to maintain control, because anyone who broke the rules was brutally punished. So we… they interviewed Elam Lynds, who was the head warden of Sing Sing, and he said, “I don’t think it’s possible to rule a prison without a whip.” And anyone who says otherwise doesn’t understand human nature. And a whip isn’t so bad. It doesn’t do much harm to people, but you know, the fear of being whipped is the only way to stay in control.
And so what we see there – the prison system is quite new at this point – is that we had tried to create a system where we wouldn’t brutalize people and we wouldn’t torture them. Instead, we would put them in a place where they could reform. But once they’re in that place behind the walls, we torture them again.
DAVIES: That’s right, that’s true. And I think some of these foreign visitors were quite dismayed by what they saw, but saw that it was effective and it kind of caught on, right?
NOVICK: Yes, exactly….
Gn entert
