SNL ‘Sister’ Sketch Barely Scratches the Surface of Women Caregivers

A dark SNL sketch from this weekend about the gender gap in elder care struck a chord — and there’s a strong element of truth behind the joke.

Comedian and host John Mulaney was featured in the “Sister” segment, intended as a parody commercial. The ad positions actress Jane Wickline as a “24/7, completely free elderly care provider, as well as your sister.” Other men in the ad talk about the benefits of letting their sisters take care of their aging parents.

“My dad means everything to me. So when I noticed he was starting to slow down, I knew I had to give him the best care possible,” Mulaney said in the commercial. “I didn’t want to put him in a nursing home, but a private caregiver could cost thousands of dollars a week. I didn’t know where to turn. That’s when I heard about Sister.”

The parody ad resonated strongly with viewers, garnering more than 2 million views on YouTube since its broadcast. Commenters largely agreed that this arrangement was “too real,” “so real,” and “triggering.”

Business Insider has covered the challenges facing long-term caregivers over the past year and how the burden of care often falls on women.

The SNL sketch exploits this trend. Waterlily, an AI-powered financial planning platform, found that “America’s child care system runs on girls,” based on its own data and data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. They are about twice as likely to provide practical care, such as helping with dressing and bathing. Among those providing care, daughters generally spend more hours per week providing care than sons.

Bar graph showing the amount of care given by daughters and sons

In interviews, more than a dozen female caregivers told Business Insider that they wish their siblings, often male, would do more to care for their loved one. Many said their parents expected their daughters to take care of them so their sons could focus more on their careers or families. It was up to them to manage their loved ones’ finances, accompany them to appointments and, in some cases, quit their jobs to become live-in caregivers.

However, most refused to speak officially about their siblings. They feared retaliation from their siblings and didn’t want to make it seem like caring for their loved ones was a burden, even if they said so in private.

The burden of caring for the elderly often falls on women

Women made up 55% of the 38 million unpaid elder care providers in the United States, based on 2023 and 2024 data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Unpaid caregivers tend to be older, with more than 11 million female caregivers aged 55 and older. Although the majority of providers are women, many men are the primary caregivers for their aging parents.

Split bar graph of men and women providing unpaid care to older people, by age

Dina Mabry’s grandmother lived alone in her mobile home until she poured boiling water on herself, after which she moved into a skilled care facility. Mabry’s mother became his primary caregiver, as his two brothers said they could not take him in or help pay for his care. This caused a rift between the siblings, which took years to resolve. Mabry’s parents had thousands of dollars saved for retirement and travel, but $6,000 to $8,000 a month was earmarked for her mother’s six years in care. This pushed back their retirement by several years.

Mabry, 58, works in the long-term care and disability insurance fields and has used that experience to educate clients on the benefits of thinking ahead. She advises her clients to discuss their care preferences with their loved ones years before a crisis, to ensure they have enough money to hire in-home nurses or move into an assisted living facility. One of the worst scenarios, according to Mabry, would be if a daughter was suddenly responsible for full-time caregiving.

Prices for nursing homes and adult day services have risen faster than overall consumer prices since the 1990s and can end up costing families six figures. AARP found that caregivers spend on average more than $11,000 a year out of pocket. Much of this is due to household expenses like food and housing.

Sana Sheraz is the youngest of five siblings, but she bears the primary responsibility for caring for her aging parents. She suspects it’s because of her income and financial stability rather than the free time she has to care for her parents and children.

“When it comes to medical expenses or big decisions, the weight tends to tip toward me,” Sheraz said. “Sometimes it’s a direct request. Sometimes it’s just the expectation in the air, the pause after a cost is mentioned, the assumption that I’ll handle it – because I can.”

Caregiving can be like taking a second job

Angelina Grigoryeva, an associate professor of sociology at the University of Toronto, has studied the division of labor between siblings caring for elderly parents. She said this comes at a cost – financial and emotional, with women often having to adjust their relationship with the job market.

Grigoryeva said women provide more care and are also the ones who receive the most care, probably because they feel more comfortable dressing, bathing or performing similar activities with the help of their daughter.

“When working caregivers reduce their work hours or have to leave their jobs altogether, they lose not only their current wages and benefits, but also the opportunity to save for retirement and build future Social Security benefits,” Debra Whitman, AARP’s executive vice president and director of public policy, said in a press release.

Carla Romagnano, who is in her sixties, asked her mother, who is in her eighties and suffers from dementia, to move in with her. Romagnano said caregiving is the hardest job she has ever had.

“When I get home from work, I sit in the driveway to decompress and then I head back into the house because my second job is starting,” Romagnano previously told Business Insider in an essay. “I take care of my mom’s needs, whatever I need to do, take care of my two border collies, and then figure out what’s going to happen for the rest of the day. They’re two full-time jobs, and I wouldn’t wish that on anyone.”

Grigoryeva said that while caregiving tasks may involve activities of daily living, they may also involve arranging paid care, such as bringing in caregivers their parents feel happy with and paying for it.

Paid care also often falls to women; 86% of home health aides and 87% of nursing assistants in 2025 were women. Careb Bien-Aime worked as a home health aide for a few years while she was a student because she wanted flexible employment. She said she would help with daily living needs, such as walking clients or transferring them from their beds. She found the work both challenging and rewarding.

“My first client, who I helped with for about a year, passed away,” she said in an essay for Business Insider. “When you have a permanent record, you start to build a relationship with that person, and then one day, they’re not there anymore.”

Gn entert

Logo