
Two trunks for storing theater props share the stage at the start of the new production of The Fantasticopening for the first time on Broadway tonight. One is “Hayes Theater” and the other “Sullivan Street Playhouse,” as clear a mission statement as any fan of this ’60s fantasy stalwart could wish for.
With a fresh approach that reimagines the musical’s mixed-boys-meets-girls plot for a world of boys and girls, this Christopher Gattelli-directed revival arrives in the 21st century with both a new attitude and a devotion to the spirit of a work that virtually defined Off Broadway charm nearly 70 years ago.
Certainly, it’s a charm that may well be lost for some audiences today, as is Pippin apple And Divine spell This might seem incredibly ridiculous on a Broadway where Northern State has just opened and a dance club revisiting Shakespeare has New Yorkers lining up in front of the Winter Garden. But it is also a Broadway where the very gentle Two strangers (take a cake across New York)) lasted longer than anyone imagined.
Gattelli and his band of newcomers and veterans know exactly what they’re doing – and what they’re fighting against, remaining true to the seduction that has kept The Fantastic run Off Broadway for a total of 42 years (!). They know that abandoning the winsome friendliness and theater-kid appeal of this Tom Jones-Harvey Schmidt musical that gave early breaks to Jerry Orbach and many generations of future stars would be like cutting “Try To Remember” from the score.
Much of the pleasure of this revival lies in bringing together newcomers – Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy as the two boys, Fire IslandZane Phillips makes an impressive Broadway debut as El Gallo – along with beloved stage figures Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles (as the mothers). They’re all terrific singers with crowd-pleasing comedic talents — Kritzer and Miles perform a splendid song-and-dance number, “Never Say No,” early in the show — and they’re joined by a supporting cast that includes David Patrick Kelly, Kevin del Aguila and Ahmad Simmons.

Ruthie Ann Miles, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer
Jeanne Marcus
The musical’s beautiful score, including the standout “Try To Remember” as well as once-familiar songs like “Much More,” “Soon It’s Gonna Rain” and “I Can See It” that reached a wider audience when Barbra Streisand and others covered them when the stage was a usual conduit to the pop charts, retains its appeal (although purists might sniff at Sam Davis’ attractive new orchestrations that add strings, woodwinds and some brass to the famous minimalist the piano and harp sound of the original production and its cast 1960 album.
So the plot – and keep in mind it falls somewhere between allegory and fairy tale, with a touch of the madness and disguised motivations of Shakespearean comedy, and never quite reaches its intended heights, much less its source material. The two young people – Matt and Luisa in the original, Matt and Lewis here – are next-door neighbors, in love and pining but secretly, afraid that their feuding parents – fathers in the original, mothers here – will demand a ceasefire.
Unbeknownst to the boys, the parents are actually great friends and simply made up the fake feud to bring the sons together. As moms sing in the ode to reverse psychology “Never Say No,” “A dog must bark, a mule must bray/Soldiers must fight and preachers must pray/And children, I suppose, must go their own way/The minute you say no.” »
The parents further conspire to recruit the famous magician El Gallo and two traveling actors to fake Lewis’ kidnapping so that Matt can play the hero and seal the lovers’ happy ending. Everything goes according to plan, until the moonlit happiness of Act I gives way to the buyer’s remorse of Act II. The boys yearn for freedom – from each other – and the mothers descend into arguments and frayed nerves.
Another happy ending, older and wiser, finally arrives, and here, as always, the musical’s increasingly cloying second act drags and strains beneath its own contrivances. Gattelli, with the same know-how that he brought to Schmigadoon! And Death suits himalmost makes us forget the musical’s weaknesses, and it’s helped by its genuinely playful casting (Chlumecky, as Matt, the most adventurous of the boys, steals just about every scene he’s in).

The cast of “Fantastics”
Jeanne Marcus
Gattelli’s restrained choreography, including a few full-length dance numbers but just as often simpler moves and joyful leaps, works well with the show’s minimalist traditions, which extend to Jason Sherwood’s set design (the usual brick theater setting, a cut-out crescent moon, occasional roller window frames, a gentle bloom of greenery and well-timed starlight) and Linda Cho’s costumes that mix the boys’ normcore with El Gallo’s sexy, flashy bandit flash.
As is usual in this series, the wall erected by the parents to separate the children is played by a mute actor (Ahmad Simmons, in concrete gray evening wear and stove top hat) who stands between the two households (each side represented by a small patch of vegetation, flowers on one side, vegetables on the other).
In this production, this character retains the traditional appellation of “The Mute”, a dated term which survives here, in contrast to the original’s use of the word “rape” which, even in 1960, was an archaic synonym for “kidnapping” (as in Alexander Pope’s 1712 poem “The Rape of the Lock”). Here, as in most musical productions, they make the wise decision to simply talk about kidnapping.
Even without making a word-for-word comparison of the original Tom Jones (no, not that Tom Jones) and those he revised for this version shortly before his death in 2023, the musical supports the genre shift with remarkable ease. Levy portrays Lewis (née Luisa) with a disarming celebration of naivety and an ingénue’s “I feel pretty” self-infatuation. The casting is on point, with Levy, short and dark-haired, providing a nice visual counterpoint to Chlumecky’s more athletic build and blonde halo of curls. They and everything else in this production work together to bring a theatrical warhorse galloping into 21st century Broadway, surprising us with how much courage he can still carry.
Title: The Fantastic
Place: Hayes Broadway Theater
Director and choreographer: Christophe Gattelli
Book: Tom Jones
Music: Harvey Schmidt
Cast: Maxim Chlumecky, Kevin del Aguila, David Patrick Kelly, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, Nathan Levy, Ruthie Ann Miles, Zane Phillips, Ahmad Simmons
Operating time: 2 h 5 min (including intermission)
Gn entert
