Lindsay Clancy to face second trial over deaths of her 3 children

PLYMOUTH, Mass. —

Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother accused of strangling her three children in 2023, will face a second trial next year.

Prosecutors announced their decision at a hearing Monday, and the court set a date of March 29, 2027, for jury selection to begin.

Clancy, whose first trial ended with a hung jury in September, had already been denied attempts to block a second trial on grounds of double jeopardy and alleged misconduct involving a holdout juror from the first case.

“She’s very scared. She’s nervous. She’s a human being. She’s very, very sensitive right now. It’s a very difficult day for her,” defense attorney Kevin Reddington said after the hearing.

Video below: a retired judge analyzes the hearing

Monday’s hearing follows last week’s rulings in which Judge William Sullivan denied a series of motions from both sides, as well as prosecutor Tim Cruz’s earlier statement that he would “talk more” at Monday’s hearing.

Judge Jim Barretto, WCVB legal analyst, said a second trial on the same charge would allow prosecutors to change their approach.

“The prosecutor really has the opportunity to reshuffle the cards,” Barretto said. “This decision was undoubtedly made after very careful review of the trial, where they could have been wrong because it was an 11-to-1 situation.”

Clancy, 36, went on trial this summer for the deaths of Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, at their Duxbury home on Jan. 24, 2023. Her defense argued she was not criminally responsible for the killing because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings.

The jury ultimately deadlocked, with an 11-1 split in favor of acquittal after seven days of deliberations. A mistrial was declared.

Last week, Sullivan denied three important motions in the case:

  • Sullivan denied without prejudice the prosecution’s motion for a gag order, which would have prevented attorneys from speaking to the press about the case. He allowed the prosecution to renew the request “if circumstances change and it can demonstrate that a prior restraint is necessary.”
  • Sullivan rejected a defense motion to dismiss the case on the grounds that retrying Clancy would constitute double jeopardy. He rejected the defense’s argument that the jury’s lone holdout should have been replaced before a mistrial was declared.
  • Sullivan also rejected the defense’s request to open an investigation into the holdout juror, including allegations that he lied on his questionnaire and used a cell phone in the jury room. “Because Clancy has failed to demonstrate that the requested evidence is relevant and material to his defense at a retrial on the murder indictment, the Court declines to exercise its discretion to order production,” Sullivan wrote. “The Court also sees no valid justification for questioning Juror Doe under oath at this stage of the proceedings.”

Clancy appeals to the SJC, saying a new trial would amount to double punishment. This appeal could impact the date and schedule of the new trial.

Gn usa

Logo