College basketball picks, schedule: Predictions for Duke vs. Illinois and other Top 25 games Tuesday

Thirteen of the teams ranked in this week’s AP Top 25 poll will be in action Tuesday. The slate includes two marquee matchups ranked by ranking between No. 5 Duke and No. 10 Illinois and No. 2 Michigan State facing No. 14 Tennessee on the road. The opening day of the Players Era 8 tournament also begins in Las Vegas.

Duke and Illinois suffered their first losses against Michigan State and Texas Tech, respectively, last week. Now, they will face off in one of the best non-conference games of the 2026-27 season. The Fighting Illini are still without preseason All-American David Mirkovic, while the Blue Devils are expected to be at full strength at home.

Michigan State’s wire-to-wire victory over the Blue Devils in last week’s Champions Classic was the most impressive result of the young season. Now, Tom Izzo’s Spartans will be tested in a hostile environment at the Food City Center in Knoxville. Tennessee got off to a 3-0 start but failed to live up to its preseason top 10 finish.

College basketball rankings: Michigan State jumps into AP Top 25 after win over Duke; Kentucky withdraws from the vote

Cameron Salerno

College basketball rankings: Michigan State jumps into AP Top 25 after win over Duke; Kentucky withdraws from the vote

Another game on the schedule to watch will see No. 20 Arkansas take on Indiana at Madison Square Garden. Indiana enters this game 4-0 after wins over Syracuse and Tennessee Tech last week, while the Razorbacks have won back-to-back games since suffering their first loss of the season to Virginia earlier this month.

Let’s dive into the picks, predictions and expert analysis for this loaded Tuesday college basketball slate.

All times ET

No. 1 Florida vs. Notre Dame

4:30 p.m., Players Era 8 in Las Vegas on ESPN, fuboTV (try for free): Florida has already been tested twice this season against Miami (neutral site) and Florida State (true road game). Now the Gators hit the road again for a very intriguing matchup against Notre Dame – a team that’s off to a surprising 4-0 start. Florida ranks in the top 10 in offensive and defensive efficiency, according to KenPom. The tape tells the same story. Florida can beat teams with its size and physicality. Florida grabs a ton of offensive rebounds and doesn’t allow second chance buckets.

How Notre Dame can spring a surprise – and where the Fighting Irish have the advantage – is 3-point shooting. As a team, Notre Dame shoots a blistering 47.8% from beyond the arc. I think this game has the potential to be closer than people think, but I’m still taking Florida to cover the double-digit spread. Pick: Florida -14 – Cameron Salerno

No. 10 Illinois at No. 5 Duke

7 p.m. on ESPN, fuboTV (try for free): Illinois may have the No. 10 label, but it’s not the 10th best team in America. Starting wing Jake Davis, a 40% shooting guard, is out with a long-term shoulder injury. American forward David Mirkovic (broken foot and appendectomy) will also miss this one. Illinois now has to enter Cameron with three freshmen in the starting lineup, including two (Ethan Brown and Lincoln Williams) no one knew about a month ago. This is a young team that has had a lot of trouble getting stops and rebounds. Now he must face oversized Duke without Davis and Mirkovic, two of the team’s best rebounders. The Blue Devils should be licking their chops after small but mighty Texas Tech pulled down 18 offensive rebounds against the Illini.

Illinois’ formidable offense will need to put up a big number against Duke to stay in the game. This is easier said than done because Duke doesn’t have many individual defenders to lean on. Dame Sarr, John Blackwell and Cayden Boozer are all good (or great) defenders on the perimeter. Duke is also huge up front with Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje and Pat Ngongba. Illinois will look to kill Duke’s bigs and use elite spacing to give lottery pick Quentin Coleman and wing Andrej Stojakovic room to shred. They’ll force Boumtje Boumtje to defend in space, but without splashing more than 10 3-pointers, it’s hard to imagine Illinois winning this one. Duke is currently healthier, deeper and more talented. I think Duke actually bounces back from the Michigan State debacle and starts playing the right way again. Pick: Duke -7.5 – Isaac Trotter

No. 19 Arkansas vs. Indiana

7:30 p.m. on Peacock: Arkansas entered this season with a very talented but inexperienced team. The returns over the first four games support this statement. The Razorbacks have yet to play an “A” game. That’s when it could happen against a very good Indiana team.

Arkansas five-star guard Jordan Smith Jr. has yet to play a game who is shaping up to be one of the elite players in this class. Arkansas coach John Calipari pretty much called his team out after an ugly win over Central Arkansas last week. How will his team react? How about beating one of the best non-conference opponents on their schedule? I’ll take Arkansas to win. Pick: Arkansas -2.5 – CS

No. 2 Michigan State at No. 14 Tennessee

9 p.m. on ESPN, fuboTV (try for free): If you like spots, this is a spot entirely in volumes. Tennessee is coming off an uninspiring five-point win over Tennessee State. Things couldn’t be better for Michigan State after plastering Duke last week. And yet the line revolves around a possession. X’s and O’s count too. To beat Michigan State’s powerful gap assist program, you need a lot of shooting. Tennessee has exactly that with Terrence Hill, Tyler Lundblade, Dai Dai Ames and Juke Harris, who are each capable of drilling three or four triples a night. Michigan State could also retain sophomore forward Jordan Scott, who is dealing with a shoulder injury. Tennessee’s biggest problem so far has been a pretty iffy frontcourt, but Michigan State’s front line isn’t the most imposing unit to really rub salt into that wound. I’m not optimistic about Tennessee’s long-term prospects, but this is a game they find a way to win at home as long as they stop Jeremy Fears Jr. from making 16 free throws. Pick: Tennessee +3.5 – IT

Auburn vs. West Virginia

Midnight, Wednesday on ESPN, fuboTV (try for free): These two teams are built very similarly. Both have speedy guards who can really score. Both have reliable actors. Both have a stable of bigs capable of playing. Auburn lost to Arizona by 11, but it was pretty impressive for large stretches of this game. Auburn’s size posed real problems for Arizona. I think he can do the same thing in this one against a West Virginia frontcourt that is solid but not quite at that level. WVU freshman guard Miles Sadler will be a heckuva player, but it’s the first test that really matters for West Virginia. Having a fight against Arizona under their belt should help Auburn in this one. Since everything is almost equal, I will rely on the team with better bigs. It’s Auburn by the narrowest of margins. Pick: Auburn -1.5 — IT

Gn sports

Logo