The officials’ extensive adjustments worked, but were they necessary?

Friday’s nationwide shutdown did not affect any of the NFL teams that had to travel from location to location for games in Week 10. It significantly affected referees’ duties.

But it’s not because the officials assigned to the different games couldn’t get where they needed to be. The league has decided to reshuffle the cards in order to avoid the simple possibility that officials will not be able to attend the games assigned to them.

This was a proactive approach by the notoriously reactive NFL. But this may still be an overreaction. And that introduced the risk of something unusual happening.

For the twelve matches played on Sunday, the the designated referee only worked two of the matches. One of those matches took place Sunday morning (New York time) in Germany, where travel likely took place before the airline system shut down on Friday.

Sunday night’s game was to be worked by Clete Blakeman as referee, along with referee Scott Walker, lower judge Andy Warner, linesman Kent Payne, field judge Karina Tovar, side judge James Coleman, back judge Jonah Monroe, replay official Chad Adams and replay assistant Adam Choate.

Instead, according to the official playbook, it was the crew: referee Don Willard, referee Terry Killens, stop judge Dana McKenzie, linesman Jay Bilbo, field judge Jabir Walker, side judge Justin Larrew and back judge Dino Paganelli.

Chad Adams was still the replay manager; however, all replay officials reportedly went to the league office and not their gaming sites.

Willard was not scheduled to work in week 10; he ultimately served as referee for two matches. Killens was scheduled to work the Jaguars-Titans game as a member of referee Alex Moore’s crew; like Willard, Killens worked with the Dolphins-Colts and Steelers-Bengals. McKenzie, like Killens, is a member of Moore’s crew, which was to go to Nashville.

Bilbo is a member of referee Shawn Smith’s team, who was supposed to work with the Panthers-Saints. Walker, who also worked two games, is a member of Land Clark’s crew, which was scheduled to work the Chargers-Ravens game Monday night.

Larrew, the fourth official to play two games in one day, was assigned to referee Shawn Hochuli’s crew, which was scheduled to work the Chiefs-Falcons game. Paganelli is also a member of referee Shawn Smith’s team, which was scheduled to work with the Panthers-Saints.

By the way, Monday night’s game will be officiated by referee Adrian Hill. Hill’s team was scheduled to work the Rams-Cardinals game on Sunday.

While we don’t have the time, patience or frankly inclination to prepare a complete list of which teams were supposed to handle Sunday’s 11 domestic games and which teams actually did so, the fact that 10 of the 11 referees ended up elsewhere speaks volumes.

The changes have been dramatic.

Here’s the real question. Were they necessary? Instead of performing major surgery on the officials’ roster for 11 Sunday games (and, apparently, Monday night’s), the NFL could have committed to getting every official where they needed to be, for the games they were scheduled to work.

Everyone else got to where they needed to be. The teams, the broadcasters, everyone. This probably could have been done if the NFL had decided to commit all the resources to making this happen.

Which brings us to an unavoidable conclusion. To avoid the hassle – and expense – of making sure officiating crews get to their assigned spots before Sunday’s kickoff, the league had no qualms about making massive changes to assignments at the eleventh hour. This included the unprecedented step of requiring four officials to work one game, travel two hours to another city and work another game.

For more details on how to work on two games in one day, check out Kalyn Kahler’s story on the unprecedented doubleheader for four officials.

“It’s exhausting because you’re looking for something every play,” ESPN rules analyst and former NFL vice president of replay Russell Yurk told Kahler of the difficulty of working two games a day. “You analyze every play. You watch your players. You watch your keys, you make your judgment, and it doesn’t really slow down the game as a whole.”

Dean Blandino, a Fox rules analyst and former NFL senior vice president of officiating, called assigning officials to two games a “last resort.”

“(It) would be like playing two football games in a row,” Blandino told Kahler. “There’s the physical aspect of running and the mental exhaustion after a game because you’re doing a pre-snap routine for every snap, then the eight-second play, and then a post-snap routine.

“The officials look like they don’t train the same way the players do, but they don’t get a break. They don’t play on one side of the ball. They’re there for every snap and every kick. So to say now I have to reset with no recovery time? That’s a challenge.”

The league could have met the challenge (and expense) of getting all the officials where they needed to be. That surely would have been easier than completely disrupting existing assignments, forcing officials to work games they weren’t prepared to handle, and requiring NFL Director Ramon George (whom the league declined to make available for an interview with Kahler) to move the various pieces around so that everything would work, even if the “last resort” of using four officials for two games had to be used.

Given the NFL’s wealth and power (most, if not all, owners own a private jet, or jets), the league could have gotten everyone where they needed to be. Either he wanted the risk of a single incident to be as low as possible (even if it meant blowing up existing missions), or he hoped to make the expense as low as possible.

It’s hard not to think that cost was a factor. And the NFL is very fortunate that Sunday’s games went smoothly, after the major disruption to officials’ routes.

Yet these games are too important to roll dice or win money, relatively speaking. It would have been, in our opinion, much more prudent to open the checkbook and spend whatever was necessary to get the civil servants to the locations where they were originally assigned.

Gn sports

Logo