Judge will soon rule that Essayli is serving illegally in Los Angeles

A federal judge refused Monday to overturn a recent ruling he made that Los Angeles’ top federal prosecutor is carrying out his duties illegally, clearing the way for Bill Essayli to be removed from his role overseeing two criminal cases next week.

U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright’s previous order, issued in October, found that Essayli was acting improperly as the “de facto” attorney for the United States. The order — which is expected to take effect next Monday unless a higher court intervenes — says Essayli, who serves under the title “first assistant United States attorney,” can no longer participate in or supervise two criminal prosecutions that led to the challenge against him, even though it could affect many other cases.

In his ruling, Seabright said the government had not “identified any specific harm it is likely to suffer” once the order takes effect. He also said the government’s appeal to the 9th Circuit had “a slim chance of success.”

In a court filing last week, the Justice Department said the legal issue “potentially affects 5,000 cases in the nation’s largest district.” Seabright said a “bald assertion” was made “in the absence of any support or explanation”.

Laurie Levenson, a law professor at Loyola Law School and a former federal prosecutor, said Seabright’s decision could open the door to other challenges to Essayli’s authority.

“There is no harm in every attorney saying that Essayli was not properly appointed and therefore should not be able to sign or supervise my case,” Levenson said. “The question is, what risk does the Justice Department want to take by leaving in place someone who the court has already ruled was not properly appointed and therefore should not be overseeing the cases?”

The U.S. Attorney’s Office in Los Angeles did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Essayli previously said the case “will be decided by the Supreme Court.”

Seabright, of Hawaii, was tasked with overseeing motions to disqualify Essayli after federal judges in Los Angeles recused him. His decision follows a series of nationwide challenges to President Trump’s tactics to install loyalists who hold the power to bring criminal charges and prosecute on behalf of the government.

A former Republican California Assembly member from Riverside, Essayli used his position to pursue criminal charges against protesters, activists and immigrants, while dropping cases involving administration allies and supporting lawsuits challenging transgender and environmental policies in California. Recently, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Los Angeles went after California officials for alleged voter fraud, seeking to have thousands of ballots voided ahead of the Nov. 3 election.

Top prosecutors in charge of U.S. attorney’s offices are supposed to be confirmed by the U.S. Senate, but the Trump administration circumvented the normal process in order to allow Essayli and others to remain in office without ever being put to a vote.

Essayli was sworn in as acting U.S. attorney in April 2025. By the time he reached the 120-day limit on that role, he resigned, then-Atty. Gen. Pam Bondi named him special counsel and designated him as first assistant.

Seabright ruled last year that Essayli was not lawfully acting as acting U.S. attorney. But the judge allowed him to continue overseeing the prosecution in his other capacity. A subsequent ruling by the 9th Circuit, which arose from a challenge over the leadership of the U.S. attorney’s office in Nevada, prompted Seabright to reconsider his decision.

The appeals court ruling rejected a similar arrangement for Sigal Chattah, Trump’s pick to lead the U.S. attorney’s office in Nevada. The 9th Circuit panel of judges ruled that the Justice Department cannot keep an official who has not been confirmed by the Senate as head of a U.S. attorney’s office simply by giving him a different title and full powers of that office.

The Trump administration has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review the Nevada decision, arguing that federal law allows the attorney general to delegate the powers of a vacant position and appoint a new first assistant as acting chief. The Supreme Court has not said whether it will take up the case.

Gn headline

Logo