Prosecutors and relatives of murder victims asked California’s high court Monday to take action against Gov. Gavin Newsom, saying he exceeded his authority by seeking to commute the death sentences of more than 500 convicted killers.
Only the state Supreme Court can end Newsom’s “disregard for the law – abuse of power,” according to a lawsuit filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation (CJLF).
The victims’ rights group filed the lawsuit on behalf of 30 county prosecutors and more than two dozen family members of those killed by the killers who are now on California’s death row.
Newsom failed to properly inform “the victims of these heinous crimes,” thereby denying grieving loved ones the “opportunity to be heard before a commutation decision,” according to the plaintiffs.
The mass switches were also carried out without “individualized consideration of the intended recipients,” the plaintiffs said.
“Thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges have put aside their personal opinions on the merits of the death penalty to make judgments based on the evidence and the law,” according to the brief filed by CJLF President and CEO Anne Marie Schubert, a former Sacramento County prosecutor.
“Governor Newsom decided that his personal opinions should prevail over anyone who actually participated in the process, followed and enforced the law,” Schubert added.
A representative for Newsom did not immediately respond to a request for comment from NBC News on Tuesday.
Earlier this month, Newsom announced plans to commute all death sentences in California, declaring that “state-sanctioned murder is inconsistent with” the values of America’s most populous state.
The governor, in an open letter to voters, said the decision was “among the most difficult of my career.”
Newsom decided to grant clemency to 548 people, 529 men and 19 women, currently sentenced to death in California. The state constitution requires the California High Court to approve the governor’s pardon for anyone convicted of more than one crime, meaning it would have to approve 382 of these proposed commutations, according to Newsom.
Whether Newsom can issue a blanket order on the fate of these convicted inmates is uncharted territory.
“This is all new and we don’t really have any answers,” said Michael Vitiello, a professor at the University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. “There’s no record (of a prior mass switch). It’s not something we have a lot of precedent for.”
But if there is no detailed mandate for judicial review, the University of California at San Francisco Professor Hadar Aviram said the governor’s action was not subject to further scrutiny by the court.
“This is an executive decision, it is not a judicial decision,” Aviram said Tuesday. “It doesn’t require any sort of legal process with respect to each person individually. There’s nothing stopping the governor from using that authority.”
A 2018 procedural order from the High Court could have signaled its desire to avoid expressing “a substantial opinion on the merits of an application”.
“The California Supreme Court has recognized that the power to opt for clemency is solely in the hands of the governor and that the court’s role in this process is extremely limited,” said University of California, Berkeley law professor Ty Alper, co-director of the school’s Death Penalty Clinic.
The Golden State has not put a prisoner to death since January 17, 2006, when Clarence Ray Allen was executed by lethal injection.
Although the plaintiffs appear to have general support from California law enforcement, at least a handful of prosecutors are supporting Newsom’s action.
“As a prosecutor, I believe we will remain safer from crime and injustice as long as we believe we can and must change outdated and ineffective practices like the death penalty,” five-term Santa Clara County District Attorney Jeff Rosen said in a statement released by Smart Justice California, a criminal justice reform advocacy group.
Rosen added: “We must always work toward a better criminal justice system. We will be a safer community if we never lose faith in human dignity, including our own.”
Gn usa
