Is there any reason to feel bad for Lane Kiffin as a freshman at LSU?

For someone who cares about his Q rating down to the decimal, this is going to be a brutal offseason for Lane Kiffin.

He didn’t deliver on what LSU fans thought he promised in year one. His painful sideline reactions will be social media fodder for months. Its struggles to beat ranked teams will be the focus of every LSU conversation during next year’s SEC media days and beyond.

Advertisement

And after giving up the opportunity to coach Ole Miss in last year’s playoffs, only to oversee a $100 million first-year flop in Baton Rouge, the toll on the sport will be unforgiving. Nearly a year after being the epicenter of college football, Lane Kiffin, The Brand, was defeated.

“This season has been so rich,” Kiffin said during his Monday press conference. “Just a lot.”

With LSU’s loss to Texas last Saturday, Kiffin’s first year is officially a bust. During Kiffin’s high-intensity courtship last year, no one in Louisiana considered spending all that money and wasting an immeasurable amount of goodwill around the SEC just to be 6-4 and eliminated from the College Football Playoff before the final two weeks.

Kiffin has spent much of his career at the bottom of one pile-on or another, but this is going to be taken to the next level.

Advertisement

And maybe for the first time in his career, it’s going to be unfair.

Will Kiffin have to endure losses in every game against playoff-contending opponents, awaiting a result this weekend in Tennessee where LSU can only play the role of spoiler? Of course. That’s how it happens.

BATON ROUGE, LA - NOVEMBER 14: Head coach Lane Kiffin of the LSU Tigers reacts during a college football game against the Texas Longhorns on November 14, 2026 at Tiger Stadium in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

LSU coach Lane Kiffin reacts during a college football game against Texas on Nov. 14.

(Sportswire Icon via Getty Images)

But strangely, despite the urge to throw grenades at Kiffin and LSU for underperforming every time the spotlight got big in games against similarly talented teams, they might deserve a little grace.

Despite the record, Kiffin isn’t that far from a totally different narrative surrounding his first year in Baton Rouge.

Advertisement

“Obviously it’s really important for the moment and the feeling right now and what we want to give our fans and what we want our older players to experience, we’re not winning enough,” Kiffin said. “But other than that, which is a major (problem), I’m not worried about anything. Things are going very well.”

Coaches are often great at presenting a series of facts in the rosiest possible picture of their professional performance, but Kiffin is right if you dissect LSU’s four losses.

In a 32–24 loss to Ole Miss on September 19, LSU scored first-and-goal with 1:49 remaining before quarterback Sam Leavitt threw an interception in the end zone with a chance to tie the game.

Advertisement

LSU lost to Kentucky, 35-34, on October 10, when the Wildcats ended the first overtime with a 2-point conversion.

In LSU’s lone loss to Alabama two Saturdays ago, the Tigers led 13-10 late in the third quarter before falling apart in the fourth. They still dominated Alabama 457-285 despite losing 31-13.

And against Texas, LSU was one stop away from celebrating but gave up the game-winning touchdown to Arch Manning and Raleek Brown with three seconds left, losing 22-21.

“LSU football wins and losses mean so much to everyone in the state, so you feel it,” Kiffin said. “And I had like a moment where this ball went in and it was just like, my God, my immediate thing was for our players and they put in all this work and did all this and all the offseason and all these guys that came here and it’s going to come down to this and we’re not going to (expletive) cover the guy and he’s going to walk into the (expletive) end zone?”

Advertisement

If you know how to interpret Kiffin language, you can easily read this comment as criticism of defensive coordinator Blake Baker, who, sources tell Yahoo Sports, has struggled to get on the same page with the head coach all season. But this rocky relationship perhaps illustrates why LSU has struggled on the sidelines.

When Kiffin took the job at LSU, sources say, there was pressure internally to retain Baker, who had become the star assistant on Brian Kelly’s staff. Baker had gained significant credibility within the athletic department and was immersed in seeking head coaching positions at Memphis and Tulane.

For Kiffin, retaining Baker on a three-year contract worth $9.3 million — making him one of the highest-paid coordinators in college football — was a big political victory with fans and policymakers. But Kiffin’s disgust with LSU’s defense is written all over his face every time something bad happens, and it’s remarkable how his Monday news conference at times turned into a therapy session to talk about Texas’ final touchdown.

“I literally wake up every hour the last two nights and have a nightmare about the last play of the game where we didn’t cover someone to lose the game and then we lost to Texas and then I wake up and it’s real and I go back to sleep for an hour,” he said, later adding, “I keep getting called a timeout.”

Advertisement

No coach publicly says these things when he is happy with his defensive coordinator. It’s also worth noting that Dave Aranda, who was LSU’s defensive coordinator from 2016-19, has been hanging around the building quite a bit since he was fired from Baylor a few weeks ago. Watch this space, as they say.

There will be changes at LSU next year, not just because the record demands it, but because Kiffin’s only chance to fulfill the promise of this marriage is to build a team and roster that suits him.

This one doesn’t do it, at least not perfectly.

It will be interesting to see in a few weeks if quarterback Sam Leavitt intends to stay another year, enters the NFL draft or transfers again. It’s no secret that Kiffin wanted to bring Trinidad Chambliss with him from Ole Miss, and when that didn’t work out, he first targeted Cincinnati’s Brendan Sorsby and Washington’s Demond Williams in the transfer portal. When asked if Leavitt was his top quarterback target in July, Kiffin told ESPN, “Thank God for unanswered prayers,” referencing a line from the famous Garth Brooks song.

Advertisement

Maybe he doesn’t feel that way anymore. Leavitt, whose running instincts and grit helped win big games at Arizona State, proved not to be the classic Kiffin-style quarterback who can stand in the pocket and make good decisions under pressure despite obvious arm talent. His 12 interceptions this season, including three against Texas, have been tough to stomach.

Then there is the question of luck and variance. Sports are fascinating to analyze because we can look at a set of facts, like Kiffin’s career record of 6-19 against teams ranked in the top 10 in the AP poll, and say, “He can’t win big games.” But in three of LSU’s four losses this year, they are literally a few plays away from a completely different outcome. If the Tigers simply stop a 2-point conversion against Kentucky or make an extra defensive play against Texas (or, heck, kick a 38-yard field goal late in the first half), they’re 8-2 and ranked somewhere around No. 8.

Offensive coordinator Charlie Weis Jr. “and I’ve talked about it, it seems like we haven’t gotten any relief,” Kiffin said. “Every break seems to go the other way in critical situations. But it’s like gambling, it’s like rolling dice, it eventually happens and that’s how it works. Last year, every game with a score at Ole Miss, we won. The year before that, we lost every game with a score. You unfortunately have years like that and combined with unfortunate bad luck, with games going (the wrong way) at the end.”

Coaches generally can’t talk about the sport in those terms, or it would greatly diminish the reason so many of them make more than $10 million a year at the highest levels. If so much depends on luck, what’s the point?

Advertisement

This may be Kiffin’s way of publicly dealing with his disappointment, but he’s not wrong. In an alternate reality, he could be just as good a coach, make all the same decisions, hire all the same people and be sitting here with a chance to win the national title if the ball had bounced differently a few times over nearly 1,400 plays this season.

Especially in the era of college football, where no one has much margin for error, every program will be subject to variation.

“I don’t overreact when we win a really close game and I don’t overreact when we don’t win it,” Kiffin said. “Does that mean they’re a much better team and we need to change the way we run the program? That’s why I’m not worried at all outside of it, I hate that our fans aren’t winning more. But I’m not worried at all about the future.”

This time, at least Kiffin isn’t blowing smoke. There will be some personnel adjustments, coaching staff changes and a slew of highly touted rookies coming next year, and you can bet he’ll be in many more of those defining moments where one play changes the tenor of an entire season.

Advertisement

We may find out later that the LSU job was too big and too stressful for Kiffin or that his record in big games is rampant.

But while it’s a big disappointment, the first year under Kiffin hasn’t proven he’s going to crash and burn in Baton Rouge. Yes, he’ll have to walk around with a target on his shirt all offseason and accept the slings and arrows that come his way after such a costly mishap. But writing the obituary of his LSU career so quickly could prove to be a major misreading of what happened over the past three months.

Gn sports

Logo