CFP ranking overrated, underestimated: Alabama’s influence defies logic, Indiana deserves better

Find someone who loves you as much as this College Football Playoff selection committee loves Alabama.

The logic that seemed to apply to Indiana a week ago did not apply to Alabama this week. The Crimson Tide remained in third place in the CFP standings despite losing all six SEC teams they have beaten this season this weekend. A week ago, Indiana fell five spots in a similar scenario.

There is no doubt that Alabama is a very good football team that is very deserving of a playoff spot at this point. That’s not in question. But if the committee has to rank these teams from 1 to 25 each week, we can quibble over each place.

And as it stands, it’s hard to understand why Alabama is still ranked higher than Texas. The Longhorns have more wins in the top 25 (3-2) and rank above the Crimson Tide in schedule strength, record strength and game control. Alabama’s best wins of the season are against No. 16 Kentucky and South Carolina, which is inexplicably still ranked No. 21 (more on that later). Texas had wins against No. 9 Tennessee (a team Alabama lost to), No. 14 Ohio State and No. 25 Ole Miss. He also knocked LSU out of the standings with its win over the Tigers last Saturday.

Alabama beat Texas in margin of victory, but should that really be enough to trump all other metrics?

Obviously, for the committee, that is the case.

“I think when we look at Alabama and their consistency throughout the conference schedule,” CFP President Hunter Yurachek said Tuesday when I asked what separated Alabama and Texas. “I mentioned that their point differential in their conference games is close to 23 points per game; Texas is not in the same situation. I’m just thinking about consistency from game to game, even consistency within a game. Texas had, after their win against LSU, five wins against teams ranked in our poll last week. That changed a little with this week’s poll, but Texas had some really good wins.

“Texas is a very good football team, but what separates us as a committee between the two is simply Alabama’s consistent play throughout the season.”

Texas certainly fails the “eye test” sometimes. The Longhorns have the best resume but aren’t always the best on the field. Even in Texas’ win over LSU last weekend, it wasn’t pretty. There’s certainly an argument that Alabama has looked better than Texas at times this season. But by focusing more on the eye test rather than a mountain of measurements, the committee can get itself into trouble.

No. 9 Tennessee also has an argument to be ranked above Alabama given its head-to-head win over the Crimson Tide. But it is clear that the committee will continue to keep these two schools far enough apart in the rankings to justify not applying the head-to-head result, since they are not in the same group for a direct comparison. The move means the Volunteers have no margin for error this weekend if they lose to former coach Lane Kiffin’s Tigers. You can only imagine the outrage that would occur in Knoxville if this were to happen.

Alabama is the most overrated team of the week.

College Football Playoff Picture: What a 12-Team Field Would Look Like After 2026 CFP Third Rankings

Shehan Jeyarajah

College Football Playoff Picture: What a 12-Team Field Would Look Like After 2026 CFP Third Rankings

Underrated: Texas

For all the reasons listed above, the Longhorns should be the top-ranked team with two losses. If the committee is comfortable putting a two-loss Alabama team in third place ahead of undefeated UCLA, it should have done so for Texas. Ranked No. 5 in the country with two weeks of the regular season remaining is nothing to sneeze at, but the Longhorns should be the two-loss SEC team in contention for a bye right now.

Overrated: Ohio State

The Buckeyes moved up six spots for… a nine-point victory over an unranked Northwest team. Yes, part of that is due to attrition among teams ranked above Ohio State last week. But it’s hard to argue that the Julian Sayin-less Ohio State team, which lost to USC and Oregon and barely beat Northwestern, is currently one of the top 14 teams in the country. There is some tremendous talent on the roster, including all-star wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, but the Ohio State team I watched in person against Oregon looked broken and deflated. It’s frankly astonishing that this team can sneak into the playoffs if a few more teams ranked above the Buckeyes lose over the next three weeks.

Underrated: Indiana

Curt Cignetti, who used clown emojis to announce his team’s rankings last week, may not have helped his cause with the selection committee. The Hoosiers moved up just one spot this week despite a 27-13 win over No. 18 USC. Indiana’s weak non-conference schedule is rightfully taken into account, but the Hoosiers’ only loss of the season was to a full Ohio State team. Indiana has a dominant defense capable of winning a championship. It seemed like an overcorrection to move Indiana from No. 4 to No. 9 a week ago. Unfortunately for the Hoosiers, there wasn’t enough of a correction in their favor this week.

Overrated: South Carolina

The Gamecocks at No. 21?! After losing to Arkansas 34-6?! I understand that not having LaNorris Sellers against the Razorbacks clearly had an impact. But some results are so bad — like a 34-6 loss to Arkansas — that they should knock you out of the rankings. The fact that a South Carolina team with four losses is still in the rankings gives ammunition to any critics who think the committee continues to overrate the SEC. You could make similar arguments for Oklahoma, Florida and Ole Miss, who are also four-loss teams and have also found a way to stay in the rankings. It must be deeply frustrating not only for Big Ten teams like Illinois and Northwestern that no Big Ten team with four losses can get in, but also for Group of Six teams like Liberty and Memphis who would be thrilled to see themselves in the top 25.

Why is this important? South Carolina remaining in the top 25 gives Alabama another top 25 win, making it easier for the committee to justify keeping the Tide in the top four. Likewise, Texas benefits from Ole Miss at No. 25 instead of Liberty or another school.

Gn sports

Logo