‘Unprecedented’: Beat Writer Questions Mike McCarthy’s Bye Week Decisions

Mike McCarthy and his Pittsburgh Steelers worked every way possible on Sunday. There really were no winners on the Pittsburgh side, which is strange to see on a bye week. Especially since the Bengals weren’t coming off their bye and had actually returned from Europe before the game.

The Steelers got plenty of rest during their bye week, with McCarthy giving his players an extended leave. Beat writer Mark Kaboly might help explain why the Steelers were so slow out of the gate on Sunday.

“I wonder if the seven or eight days off had something to do with it. Probably. Maybe offensively, maybe not defensively because they weren’t going to stop them,” Kaboly said Monday on his Kaboly + Mack show. “But he felt like they needed this time off, he gave them this time off that was unprecedented in my eyes. To give them basically Monday through Wednesday. Then he comes out and says, ‘Oh yeah, in my history, teams struggle like that.’ I’m like, ‘So why did you do that?'”

On the one hand, even though the Steelers don’t have a roster ready for a senior home, they have aging players. With a nine-game stretch to end the season after the bye, including several weeks with shorter rest than usual, it makes sense that Mike McCarthy wants his players to take a few days off when they can.

However, some might argue that this speaks to a broader sense of complacency on the part of the franchise in recent weeks. They have a quarterback in his senior year, a defense that has excelled at keeping teams out of the end zone, and a real identity in the running game on both sides of the ball. All of this has led to a 6-2 record and a serious shot to make the playoffs before their competitive window closes. Pittsburgh had an opportunity to build some momentum at the trade deadline and hit hard on the bye week before a massive game.

Neither happened. Now the Steelers are 6-3, and it’s hard to feel good about their prospects after Sunday night’s loss. Games like this happen sometimes, and it only counts as one loss. But it was a statement game in which the Steelers never seemed to have a chance. They were clearly not on the same level as the Bengals.

With that in mind, the extra rest during the bye week potentially didn’t change anything anyway. But it certainly didn’t seem to help as the Steelers came out very flat in Cincinnati.

Gn sports

Logo