Puerto Rico has many virtues—friendly people, world-class music, a vibrant food scene—and mainland residents can get there without a passport, to boot.
What it lacks is a good government reputation for managing its own finances.
So if you’re the mayor of Chicago and what’s left of his finance team, you don’t want your city to be compared to Puerto Rico in terms of municipal finances. After all, Puerto Rico continues to be under the financial control of the federal government in Washington, a situation that has lasted for more than a decade, including many years under the equivalent of bankruptcy protection.
But it was Puerto Rico that Municipal Market Analytics (MMA), a Concord, Mass.-based muni bond research firm, referenced Monday in its report on the sudden resignation of Chicago CFO Ashlee Gabrysch amid her accusations that top Johnson administration officials pressured her not to be honest with the public and investors about the city’s finances and the mayor’s proposed 2027 budget.
Upon announcing Gabrysch’s departure, the firm wrote: “Chicago’s credit situation continues to become increasingly negative, further jeopardizing the city’s (investment grade) ratings while drawing more parallels with Puerto Rico.” »
Puerto Rico’s debt crisis reached its peak in the mid-2010s when it became clear that the U.S. territory could no longer service its tens of billions in bonds and several rating agencies downgraded Puerto Rico’s credit to junk status.
To some observers, Chicago is perched precariously close to where Puerto Rico was just before a collapse in investor confidence rocked the territory. Gabrysch’s departure, the reasons for which she explained Sunday in our Opinion section in a scathing and eloquent article that resonated throughout City Hall and beyond, was a big and unwelcome surprise to the market, MMA President Matt Fabian told us.
And that puts the city clearly one step closer to losing its investment-grade rating, he said.
“It’s one thing to have financial difficulties,” he said. “But if you start questioning the capacity of management, that’s how credits get degraded.”
The good news, and we use the term in a relative sense, for Chicago versus Puerto Rico, is that Chicago has the state of Illinois as a potential financial backer. Puerto Rico’s ultimate “parent” was the U.S. government, which has less of a vested interest in the territory’s health than Illinois does with Chicago, the state’s financial engine. At least that’s what we hope.

But still… The comparison is invigorating to say the least.
And Chicago is already paying the price. Its general bonds trade at yields about 1.8 percentage points higher than AAA-rated municipal bonds. That’s about half a percentage point more than it would be if the city were seen as competently run, Fabian said.
Half a point is a lot of money when you’re talking about interest on hundreds of millions. Chicago’s poor governance is costing taxpayers dearly.
Johnson would undoubtedly like the Ashlee Gabrysch problem to go away, but he shows no signs of doing so. As is often the case with this group, the Johnson administration’s callous attempt to sully their reputation after leaving office simply blew up in their face.
The Johnson team accused Gabrysch of being “largely absent during critical periods of the city’s budget preparation process.” The administration also claimed it too quickly approved paying $75 million to the city’s pension funds after the City Council voted overwhelmingly for its administration to do just that.
Gabrysch responded that the only meetings she missed were approved in advance by Johnson’s chief of staff, Cristina Pacione-Zayas, so Gabrysch could attend conferences, the Sun-Times reported. More than 20 people in the mayor’s administration knew about the $75 million plan before it happened, she said, and had no objection.
Gabrysch told the Sun-Times she was consulting with lawyers about a possible defamation lawsuit.
Let that sink in, Chicago.
A woman with a stellar reputation as a municipal credit analyst who left her top job at Fitch Ratings to help restore this administration’s credibility with investors is stepping down three months later, saying her reputation would be in danger if she stayed, only to suffer attempts by Chicago’s mayor to tarnish her as she re-entered the workforce.
Who would want to play such a role for this group? For now, City Comptroller Michael Belsky, who is the last man on Johnson’s finance team that saw three finance directors and a budget director leave again this year, will wear two hats and also serve as interim finance director. We wish him good luck.
But it would be more than ironic if the City Council ended up having to vote on a settlement with Gabrysch after an internal dispute over how to categorize Johnson’s plan to issue high-cost bonds to cover $480 million in — wait for it — legal settlements was the cause of his departure.
Such is the chaotic way of this administration.
Gabrysch revealed more about what appears to have been a truly miserable time at City Hall. She reported directly to the mayor, but she says she never (never?) met him face to face. Other senior administration officials have barred her from saying things, including that selling high-cost debt to finance operational costs does not count as a structural solution to the budget deficit, something she has disputed to her credit. She was excluded from meetings.
In other words, it seems to us that she was supposed to serve as a figurehead, someone to repair the image of this discredited administration in the eyes of Wall Street and follow orders. If this is the case, the mayor and his collaborators have seriously underestimated Ashlee Gabrysch.
We were happy to help him give his voice and we are sure we have not finished hearing him. And if ultimately her candor and refusal to be intimidated helps restore the city of Chicago’s credibility in the eyes of the investment community, she will deserve this city’s thanks.
Submit a letter of no more than 400 words to the editor here or by email to letter@chicagotribune.com.
Gn headline
