Here’s my advice if you’re considering watching “Madden,” the new biopic that debuted Wednesday on Amazon Prime:
Believe all the negative reviews you have read or are going to read. Trust that the film’s current rating on Rotten Tomatoes – 13 percent, and falling – is an accurate reflection of what this film is. Damn, believe all the stupid movie jokes I’m going to subject you to over the next 700 words or so.
Because they are all true.
But it’s also this:
It’s worth the 110 minutes that will take you from start to finish, from the opening notes of the Chambers Brothers’ “Time Has Come Today” to the end credits – to a clip of the real John Madden inducting the real Al Davis into the Hall of Fame in 1992 that actually proves that one of the film’s most absurd storylines is actually rooted in real life.
If you were a Madden fan of any iteration – football coach, broadcaster, namesake of one of the most successful and famous video games ever invented – that’s less than two hours of investment in your life. Think of all the other ways you can waste two hours of your life — in a saloon, in traffic, watching the first two and a half quarters of the Jets-Chargers game on Sunday — and understand: This is bad. But it’s not that level of bad.
But make no mistake:
” Mad ” East a bad movie. It’s ridiculously bad. It’s absurdly bad. It’s so bad that it feels like a two-hour “Saturday Night Live” sketch gone off the rails, which is appropriate since two of the main supporting players are Shane Gillis and John Mulaney, who in recent weeks have taken turns hosting the show to wildly divergent reviews (and probably won’t be sweating the Academy results in a few months).
We’ll start with the elephant in the room – Nicolas Cage. If you’ve been a Cage fan as long as I have – and I’m going back to “Racing With the Moon” – then you know that his very first film was a bit player, portraying a stoner dude in “Fast Times at Ridgemont High” (when he was still called “Nicolas Coppola”) – one of the trio (along with Anthony Edwards and Eric Stoltz) who are the wingmen on Jeff Spicoli’s VW Bus.
And it’s important to remember that when you hear, uh, Cage’s “interpretation” of John Madden. Because the whole movie feels like a cross between Spicoli (who was played by his old friend Sean Penn) and Charlie Bodell, the character Cage himself played in “Peggy Sue Got Married.”
Now, I’m really not a particularly picky critic of actors pretending to be real people. There’s the gold standard — Jim Carrey as Andy Kaufman in “Man on the Moon,” George C. Scott as George S. Patton — and then there are everyone’s versions. Gary Cooper looked nothing like Lou Gehrig, for example. The only thing Robert Redford and Bob Woodward share in common is a first name. We can go on and on. So normally this wouldn’t bother me.
The problem is that Christian Bale’s Al Davis is SO quite – close your eyes and I defy you to tell the difference between Fake Al and Real Al – it makes you wonder if David O. Russell – who produced, directed and co-wrote the film – simply told Cage, “You can’t do your guy as good as him, so do your own thing,” and Cage happily complied.
And now, a word about Russell, who showed a true understanding of how to use sports as a wonderful storytelling tool in “The Fighter” and “Silver Linings Playbook.” I admire creative people who take risks, and he certainly took risks with “Madden”, took big changes and spent almost every second of the production thinking outside the box. It’s just that none of it works in the sense of a classic film. The whole movie feels like a satire, and that might be a good thing, except it’s also a pretty lousy satire.
And all that said?
Look, not every sports movie can be “Hoosiers,” “The Natural” or “Bull Durham.” In fact, most sports films are flawed from the start. We could go on and on about “Field of Dreams,” for example, except once you get to the end, when Ray Kinsella has that take with his father, none of that matters, and so you leave a 2 1/2 star movie crying and declaring it a four star gem.
Sometimes it’s about getting it right: “Sixty-One” is perennially great because of Billy Crystal’s loving attention to detail, getting things right, casting actors (Barry Pepper and Thomas Jane) who look good. Exactly like Roger Maris and Mickey Mantle. And sometimes it’s about doing nothing: I’ve probably watched “Draft Day” 50 times even though there’s almost nothing connecting Kevin Costner GM’s fever dream to real life.
I don’t think I’ll ever watch “Madden” 50 times. In fact, I doubt I’ll ever see him again. But I also can’t say I watched it so you don’t have to; I still encourage you to watch it. Don’t expect “Citizen Kane” (or even “Rollerball,” for that matter.) Don’t expect to learn any dark secrets about Madden’s soul. Come for the awkwardness. Come listen to the original soundtrack from the 70s. Come enjoy hilarious and pointless visits from Connor Price as Bob Costas and Rick Hoffman as Howard Cosell.
Come on. Roll your eyes. Laugh at the parts that aren’t supposed to be funny and groan at the parts that are. That’s two hours of your life. What else were you going to do, watch the Nets?
Gn headline

