Donald van der Vaart, then secretary of the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality, speaks at the Environmental Health Summit in Durham on October 26, 2015.
News and the observer
Donald Van der Vaart, one of five members of the NC Utilities Commission, is resigning from his role on the commission effective January 1.
Van der Vaart, a conservative and former secretary of the state Department of Environmental Quality, was appointed to the Public Utilities Commission by state Treasurer Brad Briner, a Republican, and has served there since April 2025.
His resignation comes just days after he failed to vote on a key Public Utilities Commission decision that allowed Duke Energy to raise residential customer bills by more than 9 percent over the next two years.
He disagreed with the commission’s decision, saying he agreed with most of it, but ultimately it “does not reflect the risk that this order passes from Duke to its customers.”
A set of key data center rules adopted as part of the rate increase could force everyday customers to pay nearly half of data center electricity costs if one of those developers terminates its contract prematurely, Van der Vaart argued.
It is very rare not to vote on such important decisions and the committee did not explain why Van der Vaart did not participate.
Van der Vaart was barred by his colleagues from voting on another key decision this week, on Duke’s two-year carbon plan, because he missed more than two weeks of hearings related to the case.
“I appreciate Don’s willingness to serve on the Public Utilities Commission and wish him the best,” Briner said in a news release Wednesday.
The Public Utilities Commission oversees major decisions regarding public utilities in North Carolina. Perhaps its biggest responsibility is regulating Duke Energy, which provides electricity to most of the state. Two of its members are appointed by the governor, one by the state treasurer, and two by the state legislature.
Currently, the commission is made up of three Republicans – Van der Vaart, William Brawley and Tommy Tucker – and two Democrats, Floyd McKissick and John Gajda.
The other four members of the commission all voted in favor of the rate increase for Duke. McKissick and Gajda expressed concurring opinions. Van der Vaart was the only one to disagree.
In his dissent, Van der Vaart wrote that he wanted the utility to have a lower return on equity and expressed concerns that customers might have to pay data center electricity costs if a tech giant broke its contract early.
As an example, the commission calculated that a hypothetical 500-megawatt data center could require Duke to build new electrical infrastructure worth about $674 million. But if that data center were to disappear after 15 years, it would only pay $338 million of those electricity costs, Van der Vaart wrote in his dissent; the remaining $335 million would go to ordinary customers.
“Ultimately, it is up to this Commission to provide a counterbalance, to ensure that the utility’s legitimate duty to its shareholders and the legitimate interest of data centers in reducing costs do not become an obligation of the families, small businesses, and manufacturers who remain on the system,” he wrote.
Van der Vaart, a chemical engineer and attorney, worked for DEQ’s Air Quality Division as a scientist for more than 20 years. In state and federal leadership positions, his conservative views on environmental regulation made him a controversial figure.
He served as DEQ secretary under former Gov. Pat McCrory until 2016, and “demoted” to a mid-level position in the department when former Gov. Roy Cooper took office, thus avoiding being fired as a political appointee.
He was placed on administrative leave from that job in 2017, shortly after co-authoring an opinion piece calling for the elimination of a key federal air quality rule, and subsequently resigned from the DEQ.
“This leave of absence is initiated in order to investigate concerns regarding your recent conduct and actions that may have compromised the Division of Air Quality and the Department of Environmental Quality,” read a 2017 letter from DEQ’s human resources director.
During President Donald Trump’s first term, Van der Vaart was tapped for several positions within the federal EPA and then was appointed to the EPA’s Science Advisory Board.
Van der Vaart has also been a vocal opponent of EPA regulation, calling for Trump to reign at the EPA after the 2016 election, and has sowed doubt about climate science in public interviews.
“I certainly think humanity is contributing” to climate change, he told E&E News in 2018. “How and to what extent is something I would like to have more answers on and more clarity on.” »
Briner will appoint a replacement to the Public Utilities Commission in the coming weeks.
This story is available free to all readers thanks to financial support from the Hartfield Foundation and the Green South Foundation, in partnership with Journalism Funding Partners, as part of an independent journalism fellowship program. The N&O retains full editorial control of the work. If you would like to help support local journalism, consider a digital subscription, which you can get here.
This story was originally published November 18, 2026 at 4:54 p.m..
Gn bussni


