When Clemson’s dismal spectacle ended Tuesday, with Dabo Swinney once again going into full lockdown mode to protect a track record that no longer seems particularly relevant, the keypad on the press conference room door no longer accepted his code.
“Well, maybe I won’t be there,” he joked to reporters, lighting up the room with dark humor after being peppered with tough but fair questions about the program’s problems. “Some of you might get your wish.”
Advertisement
Although Swinney was wrong about one thing — the majority at Clemson wants him to move on, not leave — the symbolism of his failed escape was hard to miss.
However, the current impasse at Clemson is resolved – Will the school be Really fire the guy who won two national championships? Will Dabo be willing to consider a holistic reset of his program that would take away some of his autonomy? – it must be clear in the coming weeks whether he is leaving the building or entering a new phase of his career.
In the midst of a nightmare season at Clemson that brought to the surface all of the long-simmering issues surrounding Swinney, a fault line has emerged: You can’t have a football coach who refuses to accept that major changes are necessary while the Clemson administration sets up a centralized front office for roster spending across all sports that would be overseen by athletic director Graham Neff, depriving the coach of some authority over personnel decisions.
But the discrepancy between Swinney’s position (things are going well, just a rough patch, etc.) and what Clemson is seeing (it’s not working and a course correction is needed) is an old story that has led a number of legendary coaches into retirements they weren’t ready to accept.
Advertisement
This may also be one of the last times it plays out like this in college sports.
“People want to get angry because they only want to see two years, and that’s a good thing,” Swinney told reporters. “But I’ve also coached 250 games, and that’s fair game too. I lost my first game and I lost my 250th game, but I would go from Game 2 to Game 249.”
Clemson coach Dabo Swinney went 193-57 in 19 seasons with the Tigers.
(AP Photo/Jacob Kupferman)
What we’re seeing with Swinney isn’t just about the end of an era at Clemson. It’s the whole concept of the god-level, statue-worthy coach crumbling as the sport becomes professionalized.
Although Swinney is still relatively young – he turns 57 on Friday – he is one of four current coaches who, because of their longevity and accomplishments, will one day get a statue at their school. They are Swinney, Kirby Smart in Georgia, Kirk Ferentz in Iowa and Curt Cignetti in Indiana. Maybe Mario Cristobal in Miami will get there if he wins a few national titles.
Advertisement
But that’s the list. There’s really no one else on the horizon who tends toward that kind of resume or is likely to build the kind of sprawling legacy like Nick Saban, Bobby Bowden, Tom Osborne and Joe Paterno, where their image is forever tied to where they coached.
We can go through all the reasons why this model is on its way out. It is money that becomes so important that few will remain hungry to maintain excellence for decades. This is the pressure of work in the Internet age. It is the parity ushered in by NIL, which makes long-term domination almost impossible. For some, it may even be that the NFL offers a situation where you don’t have to spend time wooing donors and kissing babies.
But ultimately, Swinney’s dynamic is about power. And when you win like Swinney, you get it almost without strings attached. If you wanted a raise for yourself and the staff, the athletic director and president practically gave you a blank check. If you needed to build a facility, donors opened their wallets. If a player got into trouble off the field, the coach had the last laugh while university officials swallowed the embarrassment.
Technically, presidents may have held the power and final authority over athletics, but everyone knew that when push came to shove, no one really had the power to say “no.”
Advertisement
Swinney was one of the few to retain this kind of juice. No matter how the problem is resolved, you’ll never see him at Clemson — or maybe anywhere else — again.
Because what’s happening in college sports right now is akin to the revolution in professional sports a decade ago, when the NFL and NBA franchises realized that having the same person as coach and general manager was a recipe for disaster.
The work is too big. Contracts and salary caps are too complex. It is healthier in most cases if the person holding players accountable is not the same person responsible for negotiating their salaries.
This fundamentally goes against the tradition of college sports, where recruits choose a school based on a variety of factors, but none more important than who will coach them. This is how the cult of the coach was built, how power was accumulated. Unlike the pros, where coaches are also highly paid but viewed as expendable, the coach was at the heart of everything that happened in a college program.
Advertisement
This distinction still exists, to some extent. That’s why the coaching carousel is the hottest topic in college football almost from the first week of the season to the last. Coaching decisions are the basis for the success or failure of a program.
But coaches are also now cogs in a much bigger machine. While the general manager/personnel department/athletic director/recall collective structure is a little different everywhere, with head coaches having varying degrees of power when it comes to player selection and contract value, the front office needs to be more collaborative in nature.
For someone like Swinney, it’s a big change – and he has yet to show the willingness to accept. But he may not have much of a choice at this point. The fans are angry. Administrators are frustrated. His $57 million buyout appears to be leverage, but college sports has changed. No one 13-10 over the last two seasons can credibly tell a fan base or the people responsible for funding a sports budget that their power and authority over major decisions cannot be questioned or even removed.
It doesn’t work like that anymore. If you’re Swinney, other than a temporary injury to his ego, why would you want help?
Advertisement
We’ve seen ugly endings to legendary careers before. Bowden was forced to retire before he was ready to give it up. TCU had already built the Gary Patterson statue before firing him midway through his 21st season. Last year, Mike Gundy was as defiant and irritable as one would expect the greatest coach in Oklahoma State history to be after two decades, but that didn’t stop the end.
The more college sports begin to imitate the professionals, the more these types of careers will become impossible or extremely rare. Once the current generation of statue trainers are gone, we may not see them again, replaced by a more transactional relationship that will have its own set of pros and cons.
Advertisement
Swinney is one of the few who has won long enough to enjoy the kind of power that a Bowden or a Paterno had in their prime. But the championships he thought would buy him enough goodwill and time to get through a few bad seasons instead led Swinney into a public relations debacle, with fans wanting evidence of a new strategy rather than a recitation of his accolades every time he was asked why Clemson wasn’t winning anymore.
Swinney has a few weeks to accept a new coaching reality or face the possibility that his employer will resolve the situation with drastic measures. And if there comes a time when he’s truly out, it won’t just be a coach walking through the door for the last time, but the entire coaching model that the previous era of college sports once aspired to.
Gn sports
