Amazon launches integrated campaign against New York delivery bill

An Amazon driver loads packages into a delivery van at an Amazon delivery station in Alpharetta, Georgia, November 28, 2022.

Justin Sullivan | Getty Images

Amazon is taking its fight against a New York City delivery bill, backed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani, to its business website and app.

Some users who open the company’s shopping app or website report receiving pop-ups and banners warning that the New York City Council “could add up to $5 per order” if it passes Intro 518, or the Delivery Protection Act.

The bill would force Amazon to directly employ its army of third-party delivery companies, disrupting the contractor model it has relied on since 2018. Amazon uses a network of thousands of small businesses, which often work solely for Amazon, to handle the last-mile portion of shipments, in an effort to speed up deliveries and gain more control over its logistics operations.

“If this legislation passes, we will no longer be able to do business with them and would be forced to consider moving our operations outside of the city,” Amazon’s in-app message reads. “This would likely mean slower and more costly delivery for millions of customers in New York, while threatening small businesses and their thousands of employees.”

The bill was introduced in February and is awaiting review by City Council President Julie Menin.

Amazon also released a statement on its company website, where it often posts its policy positions. But the company has rarely used its valuable e-commerce site and real estate apps to promote its prospects. Other tech companies, including Uber And Lyft have also used their apps to advocate for or against legislation in the past.

Amazon’s pop-up notifications and a stationary banner on its store’s home page direct users to a form where they can “contact a member of your council to oppose Intro 518.”

According to Amazon, 20,000 customers sent emails to city council members in the first six hours after the pop-up appeared.

Menin told CNBC in a statement that Amazon’s claim that it will have to raise prices because of the proposed legislation “defies logic.”

“We are crafting legislation that regulates Amazon and protects workers, without impacting prices or employment,” Menin said. “If Amazon thinks this misleading campaign will actually threaten New Yorkers and intimidate this City Council, they are dead wrong.”

Amazon spokeswoman Kelly Nantel said in a statement that the company issued notices to be “transparent with our customers” about what the bill “would cause them if passed as written.”

“If customers are concerned, one of the most effective things they can do is contact their city councilor and ask them to oppose this bill,” Nantel said.

The Delivery Protection Act has received strong support from labor groups, including the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, which has sought to unionize Amazon’s delivery workers and warehouse workers.

Mamdani endorsed the bill in August, saying Amazon’s subcontracting model “leaves workers vulnerable and leaves companies free to avoid accountability for reckless conditions on city streets.” He argued the bill would result in safer working conditions for drivers and allow the city to “regulate last-mile operations.”

Amazon disputed Mamdani’s claims, saying the bill would jeopardize the jobs of delivery service partners “without improving safety.” He also argued that other companies and governments use contractors in their operations, and said the DSP model has allowed him to meet growing customer demand.

“It works because local entrepreneurs – people rooted in their communities – provide a better experience,” Amazon said. “They invest in their teams, their routes and their neighborhoods. It’s not a blame game.”

Amazon lobbied hard against the bill, while logistics and business groups launched local ad campaigns and warned they could sue the city if the bill passed.

Gn bussni

Logo