White Sox trade Davis Martin, Luis Castillo to Rockies

The White Sox and Rockies announced a surprise trade Thursday. Colorado acquires two veteran starters, David Martin And Luis Castilloin exchange for a starting lefty Sean Sullivan and minor league catcher Douglas Veliz. The Rockies are taking on Castillo’s $22.75 million salary to entice Chicago into parting ways with Martin.

It’s a big investment for a Colorado team that’s lacking in shooting. Martin is the centerpiece of the deal from their perspective. The Texas Tech product has had an inconsistent career, but has checked in at about league average over the past two seasons. Martin has made 55 appearances over the past two years, with a 4.02 ERA in 288 2/3 innings.

A 14th round pick in 2018, Martin made his debut four years later. He experienced ups and downs in Triple-A as a rookie, then underwent Tommy John surgery, keeping him out until 2025. Martin played at a back-end level that year, posting a 4.10 ERA with a modest 17.3% strikeout rate through 26 games. He missed a month midseason with a forearm strain.

Martin won a camp battle to secure a spot in Will Venable’s season-opening rotation in 2026. He was one of the biggest early-season stories in the American League, pitching at the ace level through late May. Martin went 67 2/3 innings with a 2.00 ERA while striking out 27% of opponents over his first 11 starts. He seemed to have a ticket to an All-Star berth and was part of some of the early conversations as a dark horse Cy Young candidate.

The wheels fell off once the calendar turned to June. Martin has allowed 5.63 earned runs per nine over his last 78 1/3 innings. His strikeout rate early in the season was cut in half, as he struck out just 14.4% of batters faced the rest of the way. His fastball velocity, which was between 94 and 95 mph in the first two months, has dropped a notch. The swing and miss rates on his curveball, cutter and slider have all dropped.

The truth lies somewhere between the extremes. Martin’s early season dominance was inflated by a soft schedule. He beat the Angels multiple times and had some of his best games against bad offensive teams in Toronto, Seattle and Kansas City. His late season work isn’t exactly representative of his true talent either, as Martin was hampered physically. He missed a few weeks in August with blister issues and suffered a right calf problem in the second half.

Martin finished the season with a 3.95 ERA while setting a new career high with 146 innings. He struck out 19.8% of opponents against a solid 7.5% walk percentage with about average whiff and groundball rates. Martin’s overall performance was that of a league-average starter – with just an up-and-down road to get there.

The 29-year-old right-hander (30 in January) immediately becomes Colorado’s best healthy starting pitcher. He has between two and three years of service and has not yet qualified for arbitration. Martin has been under club control for four seasons under current collective negotiations. (If MLB succeeds in convincing the union to adopt a salary cap, it would likely be accompanied by five-year free agency for players in their 30s, which would reduce Colorado’s control window by one season.) Martin also has one option remaining and can still be sent to the minors if things go off the rails, but the Rockies clearly anticipate him being a key part of the rotation for the next few seasons.

Castillo is also a lock to start the year in Colorado’s rotation. However, his acquisition represents more of the cost of doing business to acquire Martin. Castillo would fall short of a $22.75 million salary if he were a free agent this winter. The Rockies are signing him primarily for financial relief, although they will also rely on him as an innings source.

The White Sox agreed to Castillo’s contract over the summer in a deadline trade with Seattle. It was already a payback flyer at the time, as the three-time All-Star had a 5.06 ERA in 20 appearances. Castillo was sixth on the M’s rotation depth chart, but needed to provide stability for a young pitching staff in Chicago. While there was some logic at the time, this decision blew up on the White Sox.

Castillo’s business fell apart as the season progressed, like a fastball that had been sitting in the 95-96 mph range before the trade dropped two ticks. The results were terrible. Chicago tried to open the score in front of him without more success. They moved him to the bullpen in mid-September and ultimately shut him down due to shoulder impingement.

The veteran right-hander allowed 30 runs in 31 innings in a ChiSox uniform. He was still generally around the strike zone, but didn’t fool anyone, allowing 44 hits and nine home runs in that small sample size. “The quality of the fields has definitely gone in the wrong direction,” general manager Chris Getz said in September (as relayed by Brian Dulik of MLB.com). “We have to solve it. … It’s been surprising.” Castillo finished his career-worst season with a 5.85 ERA over 130 2/3 frames.

Colorado will look to get Castillo on the right track as he enters his age-34 season. He has just one year left after making 32 starts with a 3.54 ERA and solid underlying numbers. It won’t be any easier to throw at Coors Field, but Castillo is far more established than any other pitcher on the roster. He will at least provide some veteran mentorship and be able to eat up some innings for a rotation that sorely needs it.

In an ideal scenario, Castillo would bounce back enough to become a trade chip at deadline. The Rox would likely need to eat some of the money mid-season either way, but they could make some money to land a prospect or two next July if he gets close to the level he showed in Seattle. Castillo’s deal also contains a $25 million vesting option for the 2028 season that would be guaranteed if he pitches 180 innings next year. It’s hard to imagine any team (whether Colorado or a potential deadline trade partner) imposing a heavy enough workload on him to allow him to acquire the option.

It’s a costly trade from a financial standpoint for Colorado, but they need a capable starting pitcher and have a tough job selling free agents to get to Coors Field. Martin should be a multi-year rotation piece who could likely remain under arbitration control as the Rox focus more on competing.

Colorado had a projected payroll of $89 million before the trade, as shown in MLBTR’s Payroll Tracker (courtesy of contributor Ethan Hullihen). Absorbing Castillo’s money takes them to about $112 million, a bit below their $120 million mark for Opening Day in 2026. They need to continue stockpiling weapons for a rotation that had an MLB-worst 6.28 ERA a year ago.

Ryan Feltner, Gabriel Hughes And Tanner Gordon are the only returning starters for the Rox to have pitched at least 50 innings. Feltner had a 5.40 ERA and may not be tendered. Gordon and Hughes each allowed more than six earned runs out of nine. Chase Dollander was the only bright spot in the starting lineup, and he will likely be out beyond the All-Star break after undergoing UCL surgery in June.

By taking advantage of payroll capacity, the rebuilding Rockies haven’t given up on a lot of notable young talent. Sullivan has some draft pedigree as a 2023 second-round pick. However, the Wake Forest product is considered more of a fringe prospect due to his well-below-average speed. He averaged 87.5 mph on his fastball in his first five big league starts this year. That was never going to be easy to get around at altitude, and Sullivan allowed 22 runs in his first 22 1/3 MLB frames.

The 6’4″ lefty generates extreme extension in an attempt to compensate for speed. He averaged more than seven and a half feet of extension, according to Statcast, placing him in the 100th percentile of big league pitchers. He will need deception and command to overcome the lack of raw, overwhelming material. Sullivan also offers a mid-80s cutter, sweeper, and changeup that both land in the mid-70s range.

Sullivan still has a full list of minor league options. He is likely to open the year in Triple-A, where he made 14 starts last season. Sullivan posted a 5.31 ERA with a 21.4% strikeout rate and 8% walk percentage in a hitter-friendly environment in Albuquerque. Veliz, a 17-year-old catcher from Venezuela, is years away from being considered a big league player. He drew a ton of walks in the Dominican Summer League in his first professional action.

This is close to a pure pay cut for Chicago. they just signed Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million contract and are looking for another mid-rotation move. It’s almost guaranteed now that they’ll make another external addition to join May, Sean Burkeand bullpen conversion Grant Taylor as locks for rotation. They parted ways with two pitchers who had clearly fallen out of favor over time, although giving up four years of control over Martin to negate Castillo’s whiff surely stings.

The May signing was expected to bring the projected payroll into the $125 million range. Leaving Castillo puts them back in the $100 million zone for now. They should have enough flexibility to choose from a free agent rotation class that includes Freddy Peralta, Trevor Rogers, Michael King, Shota Imanaga, Foster Griffin, Michael Soroka and the NPB is right Kaima Taira.

ESPN’s Jeff Passan first reported that the Rockies were acquiring Martin and Castillo (and eating Castillo’s contract) for two young players. Mark Feinsand of MLB.com was the first to include Sullivan, while Francys Romero reported that Veliz was the other player involved in the deal. Respective images courtesy of Troy Taormina, Thomas Shea and David Banks — Imagn Images.

Gn sports

Logo