Puka Nacua serving suspension while on IR raises important question

The news that Rams wide receiver Puka Nacua will serve a three-game suspension while on injured reserve has raised many eyebrows, because on the surface it seems very convenient.

It seems practical because it is practical. More precisely, it is strategic.

The suspension is the result of a negotiation between the league and Nacua. Instead of taking the process to a full hearing before Judge Sue L. Robinson, whose findings of fact (For example“no violation occurred”) cannot be appealed by the NFL to the commissioner, the two sides reached a compromise. They made a deal.

This happens daily in civil and criminal courts across the country. Controversies are resolved through negotiation. Mutual uncertainty – one party will win, the other will lose – becomes an outcome that both parties ideally don’t like, but will accept.

The league, perhaps fearing that Nacua would not be suspended at all, therefore agreed to a three-game suspension. Given the timing of the deal, the league necessarily agreed to let Nacua serve his suspension without being able to play otherwise.

The NFL didn’t have to do that. He could have dragged his feet. He could have rolled the dice on what decision Judge Sue L. Robinson had to make. The league ultimately negotiated and agreed to a situation that allows Nacua to organize the process in a way that suspends him at a time when he would not otherwise be playing.

The league is aware that many will disagree with the outcome. This is why the initial statement regarding the suspension was followed by an email saying this:

“Designating a player as injury does not delay discipline or prevent a suspension.

“As per previous cases, the suspension begins as soon as it is imposed.

“There is precedent for players serving suspensions while on reserve/injured or otherwise unavailable due to injury. This is not a new rule or exception created for Nacua.

“• Daniel Ekuale, Pittsburgh, 2025 season, was suspended five games for violating the performance-enhancing substances policy following a season-ending injury.

“• Sam Williams, Dallas, 2024 season, was suspended three games for violating the personal conduct policy while already out for the season.

“• Mike Woods, Cleveland, 2023, was suspended six games for violating the personal conduct policy while on NFI.

“• David Parry, New Orleans, 2018, was suspended four games for violations of personal conduct and substance abuse policies while on injured reserve.”

Indeed, Chiefs wide receiver Rashee Rice had hoped to serve his suspension under his personal conduct policy for a street racing incident during the 2024 season, while he was on injured reserve due to a serious knee injury suffered in Week 4. (This did not happen, as Rice’s lawyers failed to convince prosecutors to finalize the plea deal before the end of the season 2024.) Likewise, kicker Justin Tucker served his full 10-game suspension in 2025 despite not being employed by any. NFL team.

Here’s the philosophical question the NFL could conceivably revisit: Should certain suspensions be served only by a player healthy enough to play?

The current system allows players to go through the process so that suspensions are served while the player is injured. And, once again, the league chose to resolve the Nacua case at a time when he was injured. The league could have insisted on a suspension that would begin once he was healthy, as part of the negotiations. Ultimately, the league exercised the discretion inherent in negotiations that ended the matter in a way that allowed him to be suspended while injured.

The league could have refused to settle the matter in a way that would allow Nacua to serve a suspension while he was injured. Some would argue that the league was doing Nacua (and, in turn, the Rams) a favor. Perhaps the truth is that the league truly feared losing the case before Judge Sue L. Robinson, and taking a harder line might not have resulted in any suspension.

Regardless, the current system allows it. Going forward, the league should consider whether — specifically regarding the personal conduct policy — it will allow a player to serve a suspension that (while costly in terms of forfeiting his salary) costs him no playing time.

Gn sports

Logo