Retrial ends with conviction of man accused of starting Palisades fire

Following a mistrial over the summer, a federal jury convicted a 30-year-old former Uber driver Friday of intentionally starting a fire that later became the most destructive wildfire in Los Angeles history.

Federal prosecutors have accused Jonathan Rinderknecht of using a lighter to start the Lachman Fire on Jan. 1, 2025 — a fire they say burned underground for days and reignited as the deadly Palisades Fire. Rinderknecht’s lawyer argued there was no evidence proving his client set the fire and offered fireworks as an alternative cause.

The jury deliberated for just over two days before returning its guilty verdict on both counts against him. Rinderknecht’s eyebrows rose at the guilty verdict.

Rinderknecht hugged his defense team after the verdict was read and the judge set sentencing for March 17. His father sat in the stand, leaning forward with his hands clasped, another of his sons consoling him with a hand on his back.

Prosecutors said Rinderknecht would face a minimum prison term of five years and a maximum of 40 years.

Rinderknecht was on trial for the second time, after a deadlocked federal jury in June ruled 10-2 in favor of acquittal. U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang ordered that there be no reference to the first trial and asked the second jury to disregard the mention made by a defense witness during his testimony.

Steve Haney, Rinderknecht’s defense attorney for both trials, said they plan to appeal Friday’s verdict.

“We are disappointed with the verdict, but respect the jury process,” Haney said. “After much deliberation, they clearly gave this matter a lot of attention. »

Despite the jury’s trend toward acquittal over the summer, prosecutors vowed to retry Rinderknecht, who has remained in custody since his arrest in October 2025. Earlier this year, prosecutors obtained a revised indictment that narrowed the scope of one charge to focus only on damage caused by the initial Lachman fire, while a second count still sought to hold him responsible for the Lachman fires and Palisades.

The secondary inferno broke out on January 7, 2025, killed 12 people, destroyed 6,500 structures across the Palisades and Malibu and caused billions of dollars in damages and insurance claims.

Drummond St near Sunset Boulevard in Pacific Palisades.

The aftermath of the Palisades Fire on Drummond Street near Sunset Boulevard in Pacific Palisades.

(Myung J. Chun / Los Angeles Times)

The top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, first assistant U.S. attorney. Bill Essayli said the indictment was narrowed for the second trial to convince jurors who might have been torn about holding Rinderknecht responsible for the Palisades fire.

Essayli said he believed the jury in the first trial “considered things that were not in the record,” leading to a mistrial.

“We had to try this again, because of the weight of the evidence,” Essayli said. “We’re not going to let this guy walk out of the courtroom knowing he started the Palisades fire.”

A juror who spoke to reporters after the verdict Friday said the strongest evidence was Rinderknecht’s interview with federal investigators, when he said he “did not smell a fire, nor saw any fireworks” on the hill before the Lachman Fire broke out.

“Everything started to point to one conclusion,” said the juror, who asked to be identified only by his first name, Cameron.

Cameron, a 30-year-old student, said that without evidence proving another cause of the fire, “logically, things started pointing towards (Rinderknecht),” he said.

Cameron said after the case went to the jury, it took a vote to gauge everyone’s position. Ten jurors voted guilty, one was unsure, and Cameron was the only one to vote not guilty.

“We went on and on and asked all the questions: Are we going to be right about this because it’s a person’s life,” he said.

Ultimately, Cameron said, the evidence persuaded him to vote guilty: “We decided he was the one who should be the one on that hill, he was the one who should start the fire.” »

Rinderknecht’s second trial was controversial, with prosecutors accusing a defense witness of perjury, the defense attempting to introduce a new witness at the eleventh hour to bolster its fireworks theory, and constant sniping between the two sides.

In closing arguments Wednesday, Assistant U.S. Attorney. Mark Williams told jurors that Rinderknecht was “angry about everything and frustrated” when he went to a clearing overlooking Pacific Palisades and lit the fire on New Year’s Eve 2024. Williams said investigators ruled out fireworks as the cause “because there was no evidence to prove it.”

“This fire was an incendiary fire started by an open flame,” he said. “The accused is the only one who could have started the fire. (…) He was angry that night, he started the fire and watched it burn.”

Jonathan Rinderknecht

Jonathan Rinderknecht was arrested on October 7, 2025 in Florida on suspicion of starting the deadly Palisades fire that killed 12 people and destroyed much of the community.

(U.S. Attorney’s Office)

Williams also reminded the jury that the adequacy of the Los Angeles Fire Department’s firefighting efforts should not be considered, something jurors raised after the June mistrial. In a civil lawsuit against the city and state, Los Angeles firefighters testified about a series of communication problems and questionable decisions by their superiors that led crews to prematurely leave the area of ​​the New Year’s Eve fire.

“This case involves arson, the fire that the defendant started — not the first responders who responded to it,” Williams said.

In his closing argument, Haney said jurors must “decide the case based on the evidence,” not what his client did “outside of arson.” He argued that no one saw his client start the fire and that the lighting was not captured in the thousands of photos and videos reviewed by investigators.

Haney said investigators concluded in August 2025 that an open flame started the fire. Rinderknecht was charged in October, but Haney said authorities didn’t request lab tests to prove a lighter could have started the fire until the following year.

“The decision came first, the test came 11 months later,” Haney said. “Decided, loaded and tested. It’s backwards.”

Mayor Karen Bass released a statement in response to the sentencing that said, “No verdict can bring back the lives lost or erase the pain endured by the families. »

“Many are still struggling to rebuild,” Bass said. “For those still displaced, devastation remains a daily reality. »

Essayli said the verdict against Rinderknecht “does not exonerate the city or any other party for the manner in which they responded to the fire,” noting that the Los Angeles Fire Department faces civil litigation over its handling of the 2025 wildfires.

The question of whether the city and its agencies can be held legally liable “will be decided in other places and other venues,” Essayli said. “Both things can be true: You can have an arsonist and you can have a less than adequate response from the fire department.”

Gn usa

Logo