
The Riemann hypothesis has been a reference for generations of mathematicians. Credit: James Brittain/Getty
In a year that has seen artificial intelligence make one spectacular mathematical breakthrough after another, Anthropic now claims the top prize of all: a complete proof of the Riemann Hypothesis, the claim that many mathematicians consider the most important open problem in the field.
The announcement came from Levent Alpöge, a mathematician at the company in San Francisco, California. “I believe I, working with Claude, discovered proof of the Riemann Hypothesis,” Alpöge wrote, referring to Anthropic’s Large Language Model (LLM).
“If this is fully verified, this will clearly be a historic milestone in mathematics,” says number theorist James Maynard, a Fields Medal winner at the University of Oxford, UK.
It would also be a spectacular gift for the bicentennial of Bernhard Riemann, the German mathematician born 200 years ago last September who formulated the problem of the distribution of prime numbers in the mid-1800s.
Main problem
The problem concerns the “Riemann function ζ” (ζ is the Greek letter zeta), which encodes the random properties of prime numbers. Riemann discovered that the distribution of prime numbers is encoded in the “zeroes” of the function ζ. These are points on a plane denoted z satisfying the equation ζ(z) = 0.
Riemann assumed that apart from a few obvious but uninteresting cases, all these solutions must lie on a certain vertical line in the plane. If this were true, he showed, it would imply that prime numbers are scattered among all integers in a manner essentially as random as could be.
Alpöge’s 4-page document includes an overview of the evidence. But Andrew Granville, a number theorist at the University of Montreal in Canada, says Alpöge should have taken the time to prepare a clearer paper before making the announcement, which came just days after Anthropic’s IPO. The IPO initially valued the company at US$1.5 trillion, but the company’s valuation fell on November 19.
“What he published is truncated,” Granville says of Alpöge’s document. Granville cites the company’s declining stock market value as the reason for the timing of the release of the evidence.
“There is an obvious cynical view related to timing, but it is false,” Alpöge writes in the document.
Anthropic did not immediately respond to Naturerequest for comment.
A dawn of science?
Gn headline
