Rights groups call for sanctions after ICJ finds Myanmar guilty of genocide against Rohingya

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — Rights groups are calling for military and economic sanctions against Myanmar after the United Nations’ highest court, in the first ruling of its kind, determined that its government committed genocide against the Rohingya minority during a brutal 2017 military operation.

WATCH: International Court of Justice finds Myanmar guilty of genocide against the Rohingya

The International Court of Justice lacks the power to enforce Thursday’s ruling, which orders Myanmar’s military-backed government to allow those who fled the violence to return home safely, pay reparations to Rohingya Muslims and prosecute those suspected of committing genocide.

Myanmar’s government has denied committing genocide, saying it acted against insurgents, and it is seen as unlikely to meet the court’s demands. President Min Aung Hlaing, a former military leader, was responsible for the 2017 operation. The court said evidence showed Myanmar forces killed around 100,000 Rohingya.

Khine Khine Soe, a presidential spokesperson, stressed that the International Court of Justice’s decision on Thursday was the result of a nine-to-six vote by the judges.

“Not all 15 judges agreed with the decision,” she told reporters in Naypyitaw, the capital. “So it’s not a unanimous decision. I would say it was unfair.”

Although the World Court’s decisions are final and legally binding, it has no recourse other than to report non-compliance to the UN Security Council.

The UN Security Council has the power to impose sanctions

The Security Council has scheduled closed-door consultations on the decision next Wednesday and a private meeting on Dec. 7 at the request of the United Kingdom, which expelled Myanmar’s defense attaché after Thursday’s decision.

But Daniel Forti, head of U.N. affairs at the International Crisis Group, said there was unlikely to be immediate action by the 15-member Security Council that could impose sanctions on Myanmar. He said any action would likely be blocked by China and Russia, both permanent members with veto power.

“China has discouraged the Security Council from acting on the Myanmar file since 2021 because it is reluctant to cede any influence in its own backyard,” Forti told the Associated Press. “The ICJ’s decision will not change China’s calculations, and it is difficult to imagine that Beijing or Moscow would support a possible Security Council resolution attempting to enforce the Court’s recommendations.”

LEARN MORE: Myanmar is the first state found responsible for the genocide. This is how the ICJ has ruled in other cases

Forti said The Gambia, which initiated the legal proceedings, could eventually pass a resolution in the 193-member General Assembly calling on Myanmar to comply with the ICJ’s demands, even though its actions are not legally binding, unlike those of the Security Council.

General Assembly President Khalilur Rahman plans to hold “an informal dialogue” with the 193 UN member countries on the ICJ decision and remains open to further discussions, said Assembly spokesperson Melissa Summers. Rahman, who is also Bangladesh’s foreign minister, visited Cox’s Bazaar on Friday and told a crowd of Rohingya “at this historic moment” that action was needed and pledged to be their voice in New York, she said.

Justice for All, a U.S. human rights organization that advocates for the rights of Muslim minorities, called on the Trump administration to support a General Assembly resolution demanding that Myanmar comply with the ruling and establish international monitoring and monitoring.

Rights groups call for targeting Myanmar’s economy and military

Justice for All, which has a working group of 38 American and Canadian Muslim organizations that have advocated for Rohingya rights since 2017, argued that sanctions should target Myanmar’s oil and gas sector and the networks that provide weapons and other support to its military.

Amnesty International Secretary General Agnès Callamard urged governments not to host the president “on the international stage, especially as serious violations continue unchecked in Myanmar.”

“Instead, they should stop all transfers of weapons, security and surveillance equipment, and military and security assistance to Myanmar,” she said. “The UN Security Council should impose a global arms embargo and refer the entire situation in Myanmar to the International Criminal Court.”

That court, however, is under U.S. sanctions, as are many of its judges and staff, so any Security Council action would face an almost certain U.S. veto.

ICC prosecutors have requested an arrest warrant for Min Aung Hlaing in late 2024, alleging he is responsible for crimes against humanity against the Rohingya. There has been no public announcement about a decision by court judges who should issue a warrant.

The court’s Office of the Prosecutor said in an emailed response to questions from The Associated Press that the ICJ ruling “will have no bearing on cases currently before ICC judges,” and noted that the ICC deals with allegations of individual criminal responsibility of individuals, as opposed to state responsibility.

No clear path to reparations for the Rohingya

Human Rights Watch urged governments to intervene to help the Rohingya.

“Relevant governments should strongly support the Rohingya and promote justice for the atrocities, pressure the Myanmar junta to comply with the ruling, and ensure the safe and voluntary return of Rohingya refugees to Myanmar,” Maria Elena Vignoli, the group’s senior legal advisor, said in a statement.

Justice for All called for global support for a reparations fund for the Rohingya and measures to promote their education, protection, pursuit of citizenship and safe voluntary return from Bangladesh, where some 1.2 million Rohingya now live in overcrowded camps.

Buddhist-majority Myanmar has long claimed that the Rohingya are “Bengali” migrants from Bangladesh, even though their families have lived in the country for generations. Nearly all Rohingya have been denied citizenship since 1982, rendering them stateless, and they are denied freedom of movement and other basic rights.

Yasmin Ullah, a Rohingya rights activist who listened to the court’s ruling in The Hague, Netherlands, said the ruling “will only make sense if governments act on it.”

“I therefore say to all UN member states to take strong action to implement the ICJ ruling,” she said, starting with sanctions against the president.

“Make Myanmar pay reparations to the people it destroyed,” she said. “Give us back our lives. Give us a future. We want to be part of a stable, prosperous and prosperous Myanmar.”

Associated Press writer Mike Corder in The Hague, Netherlands, contributed.

A free press is the cornerstone of a healthy democracy.

Support trusted journalism and civil dialogue.





Gn headline

Logo