Mixed-Status California Families Will Lose Their Housing Under New Trump HUD Rule

In summary

A new rule barring families with mixed immigration status from federally funded housing will hit California harder than any other state.

Housing authorities across the state are scrambling to keep their clients from becoming homeless as they prepare for a new Trump administration rule that could strip federal subsidies from 7,000 California households.

Starting next month, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development plans to bar all families with “mixed” immigration status from federally funded housing. The upheaval is expected to hit California, with its large immigrant population, harder than any other state.

“It’s a very big deal,” said Sanford Riggs, director of operations for the Santa Barbara County Housing Authority. “It’s a huge change.”

Agencies that administer housing vouchers attempt to develop contingency plans for their mixed-status families, trying to transition them from federally funded programs to programs funded by city, county, state or philanthropic funds. But the success of this effort will vary greatly from county to county, depending on the resources each has available.

The Trump administration presented this as a way to eliminate subsidies for undocumented immigrants and give them to homeless veterans and disabled or elderly citizens. “President Trump warned that the days of illegal aliens and ineligible noncitizens exploiting government-funded social programs would be over,” HUD Secretary Scott Turner said in a statement.

But this change could harm even U.S. citizens who don’t live in mixed-status households. Indeed, in some counties, for technical reasons, vouchers released when mixed-status families leave for whatever reason disappear entirely rather than being reissued to other applicants.

Other counties say they will be able to serve fewer people overall because mixed-status families pay higher rent and receive a lower subsidy than U.S. citizens. If HUD evicts them and replaces them with citizen households, there will be less funding and fewer families will be housed.

How does the new HUD rule change things?

Federal housing funds have historically been reserved only for U.S. citizens or people with eligible immigration status, such as a green card. But historically, mixed-status families could receive prorated aid — meaning a family of four made up of two eligible citizen members and two undocumented immigrant members would receive the same rate as a family of two.

Under the new rule, which is set to come into effect on December 14, these families will receive nothing. U.S. citizens living with undocumented family members would also have to separate from those family members or lose their housing.

An analysis of 2024 data by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities found that 7,190 mixed-status households received federal housing assistance in California. The only other state that comes close is Texas, with 4,500 residents.

HUD previously proposed this rule change once during President Donald Trump’s first term in 2019, but rescinded it after public outcry. This time, lawsuits aimed at stopping the rule from taking effect have already begun, including from a group of Los Angeles-based families and tenant rights advocates.

The Santa Clara County Housing Authority has 157 mixed-status households in its program, including 290 children, who will be affected by the new rule. In many cases, children are the only members of a family eligible for federal aid — so the family doesn’t have the option to separate to keep eligible members housed, said Angie Garcia-Nguyen, deputy executive director of the county housing authority.

The county saw this change coming and prepared for the shutdown. The community has an emergency plan to help families at risk of being displaced, Garcia-Nguyen said. She did not want to reveal how much money was raised, or where the funds came from, to avoid putting “a target on anyone’s back”. But, she added, any non-federal help they can provide is only temporary, meaning these families still need a long-term plan.

“I think families are going to have to make some pretty tough choices,” Garcia-Nguyen said. “Santa Clara County is not the most affordable place to live without a subsidy. Some households will have to decide whether or not they will stay.”

Once the rule takes effect, it could be more than a year before people are deported. Housing authorities have the option to grant deferrals of up to 18 months.

Seniors urged to check their immigration status

In Santa Clara County, the ripple effect of the new rule could even extend beyond the 157 mixed-status families.

HUD will also require certain individuals who were previously exempt to submit documentation proving their citizenship or immigration status. The housing authority helps 12,000 seniors and nearly 9,000 children who have not verified their immigration status. Now these people will be forced to do so or lose their housing subsidies. It’s unclear how many of them will be able to, Garcia-Nguyen said.

In Santa Barbara County, Riggs said he is not aware of any city, county or state funds that can help the 131 mixed-status families who receive federal grants through his agency.

“There is a strong possibility that some will end up homeless,” he said. “There’s no doubt about it.”

Many vouchers released when mixed-status families move will not be reissued to U.S. citizens, or anyone else, Riggs said. The cost of housing in Santa Barbara County, for example, is so high that HUD provides additional funding, on top of regular housing vouchers, to cover the cost of rent. But there is a catch. In exchange, once someone abandons a voucher (whether they die, are evicted, or otherwise), HUD does not allow the housing authority to reissue it to someone else.

The City of Los Angeles Housing Authority serves 1,709 mixed-status families who would be affected by the new rule. These families pay more out of pocket and receive smaller subsidies than households where each member has eligible immigration status.

The housing authority said removing all mixed-status families from the program would require it to eliminate at least 800 Section 8 housing vouchers to cover increased costs — meaning 800 fewer families would benefit.

Gn headline

Logo