A federal appeals court ruled Friday that a massive pandemic spending law passed during President Joe Biden’s administration was unconstitutional because many lawmakers delegated other members to vote for them in their absence.
Members of Congress were allowed to vote by proxy for the 2022 measure because of accommodations in place while the risk of a potentially deadly coronavirus infection was still high.
But by a 9-8 vote, the majority said proxy votes did not count toward quorum under a clause in the U.S. Constitution governing meetings of Congress, making passage of the law unconstitutional. A U.S. district court judge issued the same ruling in 2022.
The $1.7 trillion omnibus bill passed the House that year by a vote of 225 to 201, with one voting member present. According to the appeals court opinion, 226 lawmakers voted by proxy.
Additionally, the appeals judges said in the majority opinion written by Justice Cory Wilson, a Trump appointee, that the government failed to establish that there was “the existence of an emergency” when it adopted proxy voting.
Legal experts have expressed concerns that a ruling against passing the law would have broad ramifications, affecting other bills passed by proxy. However, the opinion emphasizes that the decision is “narrow in scope,” applying only to the application of a provision in Texas that applies to the working conditions of pregnant women.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who recently lost his bid for U.S. Senate, filed suit in 2023 to block the Pregnant Workers’ Fairness Act — which requires certain employers to provide certain accommodations to pregnant workers — from being enforced in Texas. Friday’s decision grants his request.
Meanwhile, Justice James Graves Jr., appointed by former President Barack Obama, argued in his dissenting opinion: “Even though less than a majority was physically present at the time of the vote, no lawmaker objected that there was no quorum.” ” He also challenged the majority’s interpretation of the Constitution’s “quorum clause,” saying that requiring lawmakers to be physically present “is a much greater requirement in the Constitution.”
In addition to establishing a Texas jobs law, the 2022 spending bill funded critical government operations at federal agencies and provided about $45 billion in emergency aid to Ukraine and its NATO allies, as well as about $40 billion for natural disaster relief.
