Climate negotiations stalled Saturday night in Turkey as some countries debate whether to force a confrontation with Saudi Arabia and its allies over the global need to phase out fossil fuels.
The co-organizers of the UN Cop31 climate summit, Australia’s Chris Bowen and Turkey’s Murat Kurum, held meetings with numerous countries throughout Saturday into the late evening as the fortnight’s negotiations ended without a resolution, with countries and campaigners growing frustrated by the lack of progress.
The main sticking points included the insistence of a loose coalition of around 130 countries to include a reference to the “transition away from fossil fuels” in the final outcome of the negotiations, as well as demands from developing countries to strengthen their rights to financing from the rich world to help them adapt to the growing impacts of the climate crisis. Saudi Arabia and some other oil-rich countries have historically opposed an explicit statement on the use of fossil fuels.
A third draft of a potential deal, released early Sunday, attempts to break the impasse by saying the countries are recalling a deal reached in Dubai three years ago – the only summit at which countries reached consensus on the need to move away from burning coal, oil and gas.
Maina Talia, climate minister of Tuvalu, a low-lying Pacific island, said: “This (the inclusion of a reference to fossil fuels) is a red line for us. We are talking about the root cause of all this. (Without this) we are wasting our time here.”
Mohamed Adow, director of the think tank Power Shift Africa, said: “We came to Antalya with the need to make progress on public climate finance, adaptation and fossil fuels. Instead, we are fighting to stop governments from going back on the promises they have already made. Rich countries have spent two weeks finding reasons not to provide the (financial) support they promised. It feels like this meeting is falling apart.”
There have also been strong disagreements over the controversial “carbon capture and storage” (CCS) technology and the goal of deriving 35% of the world’s energy from electricity by 2035. Saudi Arabia wants firm recommendations on CCS in the final outcome of the negotiations, known as the “hedging decision”, but other countries are opposed because the technology is seen by some as a way to perpetuate the fossil fuel industry.
The third version of the coverage decision attempted to address this problem by removing a strict target for CCS and recognizing that the greatest possible electrification must be powered by clean energy. It was to be debated in a formal session in the plenary hall scheduled for 9 a.m. local time.
Activists have blamed the lack of progress on the fossil fuel industry and the countries that depend on it, as well as the failure of rich countries to keep their funding promises for poorer countries. “This must be the last time we allow the fossil fuel interests, who profit so handsomely from the climate crisis, to hold us to ransom,” said Nick Dearden, director of campaign group Global Justice Now. “It is now abundantly clear that we cannot fight climate change as long as those who control the global economy can profit from coal, oil and gas. »
Harjeet Singh, global organizer of the Fill the Fund campaign, said: “You cannot ask developing countries to transform their economies while they are drowning in disasters and debt. Whatever deal emerges in Antalya, the world should know why this Cop failed. It was not a lack of solutions, it was a lack of money and a lack of will on the part of those who caused this crisis.”
It is unclear when the talks, which were expected to end Friday evening, will end. Many delegates were rescheduling their flights home. If enough delegates leave, the “Conference of the Parties” (COP) may no longer meet the quorum required by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
The “transition away from fossil fuels” was agreed at Cop28 in Dubai in 2023, but Saudi Arabia and its allies have prevented further progress in its implementation. At last year’s Cop30, hosts Brazil got around this problem by pledging to draft a global roadmap on phasing out fossil fuels.
This year, the resolution was included in an initial draft of the agreed outcome of those negotiations, but was removed from a revised draft released Thursday. This was recognized indirectly in the third draft, through a reference recalling the entire “UAE consensus” reached in Dubai three years ago.
The inclusion came after the EU, the UK, many African countries and the world’s least developed countries, the small island states that are among the most vulnerable to the climate crisis, came together on Saturday evening to march to the presidency office and demand the benchmark be restored.
This is the first Cop with a dual presidency, thanks to a compromise forged last year after the candidacy of Australia and Turkey. Claudio Angelo of Observatorio do Clima said that was part of the problem. “This shows how detrimental a weak presidency, shared between two countries with little tradition in climate diplomacy, can be to a process already victim of geopolitics,” he said.
A possible next step – which the Guardian reported was being actively considered on Saturday evening – could be to impose a public meeting at which Saudi Arabia and its allies would be forced to publicly declare their opposition to a stronger outcome than most other countries want.
This would be risky, as it could mean the failure of the negotiations. But Bill Hare, chief executive of the think tank Climate Analytics and a Cop veteran, told the Guardian: “If an overwhelming number of countries here want a strong text referring to the transition away from fossil fuels and so on, that’s not the case. and Saudi Arabia goes it alone, I think Saudi Arabia is unlikely to oppose the global consensus. »
The Guardian also understands that China and India, although not allied with the “progressive coalition” of around 130 countries, are unlikely to oppose a deal.
Miatta Fahnbulleh, the UK’s Energy Minister, said: “We are working closely with our partners to find a solution and reach an agreement that will take us forward. These are difficult negotiations, but the discussions remain productive and there is a deal to be reached.”
Gn headline
