Are scientists discovering the secret language of whales?

On July 8, 2023, in the deep waters off the coast of Dominica, a sperm whale gave birth with a pod of 11 whales gathered around her.

The birth lasted a little over 30 minutes. Other females repeatedly swam under the mother while she gave birth. After the newborn reached the surface for its first breath, several whales gathered around it, lifting and supporting its body as it learned to swim.

A baby humpback whale plays on the water surface in the deep waters of French Polynesia. Subphoto – stock.adobe.com

Researchers captured the event with underwater microphones and aerial drones, recording more than five hours of audio and video. When they studied the images, they found that the whales had changed the way they clicked at several key moments during birth.

“Communication doesn’t happen in isolation,” said David Gruber, founder and CEO of Project CETI, the Cetacean Translation Initiative. “During the birth we observed, the sperm whales’ vocal patterns changed noticeably at different times.”

A group of sperm whales swims on Monday March 9, 2020. Amanda Cotton / CETI Project

But what did they say?

This question gave rise to one of the most important and controversial experiments in marine biology. Researchers have discovered that sperm whales have dialects, transmit their vocal habits between generations, and combine clicks in surprisingly complicated ways. They also detected sound patterns that resemble human vowels and exchanges that sound, at least statistically, somewhat like a conversation.

No one has proven the significance of any of these click patterns. Scientists completely disagree on whether we are getting closer to the language of whales or whether we are simply discovering new patterns of sounds that are still incomprehensible.

Sperm whales make several types of clicks. Hunting thousands of meters deep, they use rapid clicks to find squid in the dark, much like bats use sound to find insects. Near the surface, resting or spending time together, they produce short sequences of clicks called codas. A coda can consist of three, four, or five clicks separated by carefully timed pauses.

Research has already established that sperm whales from different communities click differently, just like people in Chicago and New Orleans speak with different accents.

Three sperm whales swim in an undated photo. Amanda Cotton / CETI Project

A study published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B in June analyzed 5,291 codas recorded in the Mediterranean between 2003 and 2021. Whales in the Western Basin, around the Spanish Balearic Islands, repeatedly used a slow clicking pattern. Whales further east, along the Hellenic Trench off Greece, had a larger collection of patterns and delivered some at a significantly faster rate.

Taylor Hersh, lead author of the study and a researcher at the University of Bristol, told the Post that researchers didn’t need sophisticated computer programs to hear the difference.

“As soon as we started listening to recordings of sperm whales from both regions, the differences between them were actually very stark,” she said. “These differences were quite obvious to the naked ear.”

A CETI project member dives with a whale recording unit on Thursday August 31, 2023. CETI project

Genetic evidence suggests that sperm whales entered the Mediterranean through the Strait of Gibraltar around 20,000 years ago. Some of their descendants eventually traveled east, where the two populations largely separated.

Eastern whales still occasionally performed one of the oldest and slowest western click patterns. Western whales were never recorded using the faster patterns that later developed in the east.

“They literally still have some collective cultural memory of the ‘old ways,'” said Luke Rendell, a whale researcher at the Marine Mammal Research Unit at the University of St Andrews in Scotland, who coordinated the Mediterranean study.

“We know that different groups of sperm whales only associate with each other if they speak the same dialect,” Hersh told the Post.

Newer, more controversial research questions whether individual clicks contain something closer to the building blocks of language.

Shane Gero, right, and Zahrek Gonzalez-Peltier deploy a tagged drone in Dominica on Monday, October 28, 2024. Michael Lee/National Geographic

The CETI Project was established as a nonprofit in 2020 with funding from the TED Audacious Prize, and its researchers study sperm whales off the coast of Dominica in the eastern Caribbean.

In 2024, CETI researchers computer analyzed 8,719 codas recorded on these whales. Sometimes a whale would slightly stretch or compress the pauses between clicks, a variation the researchers called “rubato,” borrowing a term from music. Sometimes he added an extra click at the end, which they called “ornamentation.”

When rhythm, speed and these small variations were counted together, the researchers found at least 143 commonly used combinations. They described the collection as a sperm whale “phonetic alphabet.”

They did not pretend to know what any of these combinations meant.

CETI project members dive with a whale recording unit on Thursday August 31, 2023. CETI project

Gašper Beguš, a linguist at the University of California, Berkeley and CETI’s linguistic lead, sped up the whale recordings until individual clicks could be studied in more detail.

“By speeding up sperm whale vocalizations, we observed patterns that resemble human vowels,” he said.

When people say “ah” or “ee,” they move their tongue and jaws to different positions, changing the frequencies of the sound. Beguš’s team found comparable frequency bands in the whales’ clicks. Researchers classified them into two broad categories that resembled the human vowels “a” and “i.” They also found sounds that seemed to slide from one category to another, resembling a diphthong such as the “oy” in “boy.”

Richard Carey – stock.adobe.com

A follow-up paper published in April found that the two categories behave consistently, with “a” sounds being longer than “i” sounds. Researchers also found that the quality of one coda sometimes carries over to the next, in the same way that the “n” in “input” shifts because of the “p” behind it.

“With work on phonology, we show structural complexity,” Beguš said. “As in Latin, sperm whale vowels can be long or short. As in Mandarin, they have different tonal patterns.”

Dr. Luke Rendell

He compares this work to decoding an ancient language. Researchers must first identify all of its recurring sounds and elements before they can begin to understand what something says.

Some researchers are less keen to compare whale communication to human language.

Rendell believes that comparisons to human language already go far beyond the evidence. He published the first study describing the vocal clans of sperm whales 23 years ago and spent about three decades listening to whales in the wild. He calls CETI’s claims about alphabets, vowels and conversations “massively overrated clickbait.”

For Rendell, language requires more than a vast collection of sounds. These sounds must represent shared ideas and follow rules that allow speakers to create a potentially unlimited number of messages.

“We are very, very, very far from it,” he said.

Elias Carlson / CETI Project

Gruber, who says he has great respect for Rendell and his contributions to the field, drew a line under the word that caused the most problems: conversation. According to Gruber, if the results reflect anything like a conversation, “that’s exactly what our ongoing research is designed to determine, not something we’ve outright asserted.”

Laela Sayigh, a senior research specialist at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution who specializes in communicating with whales and dolphins, worries that exaggerated promises could harm the entire field. In the 1960s and 1970s, neuroscientist John Lilly made sensational claims that dolphins possessed advanced language and could learn to speak with humans. When the evidence failed to support these promises, serious dolphin research lost funding and credibility.

John Lilly poses for a portrait. Corbis/VCG via Getty Images

“So we really don’t want history to repeat itself here,” Sayigh said.

CETI’s next goal is to predict what a whale might do based on its vocalizations alone. Could a computer recognize, through clicks, that a whale is about to dive or fall asleep?

“If the CETI model consistently predicts what the whale does in situations it has never encountered before, that is a strong indication that we are discovering a trend,” Gruber said.

Sperm whales swim off the coast of Dominica on Monday March 18, 2019. Amanda Cotton / CETI Project

But a discovery doesn’t depend on whether sperm whales have words, sentences, or anything resembling human language.

Researcher Roee Diamant and colleagues reported in July in the journal Ecological Informatics that whales off Dominica shorten their codas and tighten the gaps between clicks as ships pass by. The pattern is consistent enough that the team claims to be able to determine, from vocalizations alone, whether a ship is nearby.

Whatever the whales say, the presence of our ships changes the way they say it.

Gn tech

Logo