There are many good reasons to cast Robert Pattinson as James Bond.
But following Amazon-MGM Studios’ announcement of the Batman actor as the seventh 007, many fans are complaining online about the choice.
Such complaints are obviously predictable. Any actor cast as Bond will be criticized. Even Daniel Craig was heavily criticized by fans when producers cast the actor as Bond in 2005 (“he’s not handsome enough”, “Bond can’t be blond”, etc.). Our visual concept of Bond is entirely formed by the six other actors who have played the role, so it will be difficult to imagine anyone new – at least, at first.
That said, Pattinson’s complaints are interesting, perhaps even valuable, because they show producers what they’re up against in terms of preconceptions about their casting choices.
The comments section of the British tabloid Daily Mail There has been a hive of Pattinson bashing all morning.
He wrote one: “He lacks the magnetic charm, refined elegance, rugged confidence, seductive sophistication and effortless daring that define James Bond.” » Likewise, he wrote another: “He is not distinguished by the animal masculinity or charisma of a Bond character. Another said: “He doesn’t seem like an Alpha male, ladies’ man, action type.” » Another snarked: “I’ve seen sexier potatoes. »
Others felt that Pattinson had played too many iconic roles and expressed frustration that the same actors seemed to be cast in so many projects.
“You can’t have the same actor playing Batman and James Bond at the same time,” one wrote. “The Broccoli family would never have made this decision.” Or as one fan explained on Amazon’s MGM Studios Instagram post: “If you want to make a James Bond truly immortal, you need to cast someone who isn’t already heavily associated with other iconic characters from the film.” »
Or wrote one Redditor: “I don’t like this choice. I would much rather see him continue his very interesting career as he has been great in so many roles and then have a newly discovered talent or newcomer to play Bond.”
One influencer on
A recurring comment is that Pattinson would have been better as the next film’s villain, although this likely has recency bias coming from his heel turn. The Odyssey and his scary version of Chris Hanson in Prime time. “He doesn’t feel like Bond. He would have made a fantastic Bond villain though,” one fan wrote on Reddit. But as another countered: “The fact that people are saying he would make a good Bond villain is one of the main reasons I’m glad he’s Bond instead.”
Of course, many (if not most) reactions online have been positive, and even some of his detractors begrudgingly admit that Pattinson is a terrific actor who will probably crush the role.
The truth is that there are too many things at stake – and too many talented people behind the scenes of a Bond production – for an actor cast in the role to outright fail. Any of the actors being considered could have been brought in to work, and Pattinson, one suspects, will have less difficulty moving up than others given his star power and franchise experience. A week or two after Bond 26 opens, Pattinson will have evolved from a decision made by producers and a studio to simply being Bond (James Bond).
Gn headline
