The recent “Sister” sketch from “Saturday Night Live” struck a chord with millions of women across the country.
In the November 14 sketch, a fake advertisement for elderly care services, comedian John Mulaney plays a man announcing an ingenious and cost-effective solution to the problem of caring for his aging father. Nursing homes are expensive, and home health aides can cost thousands of dollars per week. But there is a completely free alternative, without insurance and available 24 hours a day: your sister.
Mulaney says happily, “Now I don’t have to worry about Dad getting the care and attention he needs, because my sister will. And I can go back to My life and all that I I like to do.”
“This is how it works”: A doctor identified as the author of “Not that!” A Son’s Guide to Elderly Care explains, “Years of internalized sexism tricks Sister’s brain into thinking that caring for him is her responsibility and, somehow, not yours. Then your message comes in (“Daddy fell”), instantly activating it. And that’s it. You’re done for life. See you at the funeral!” The accompanying graphic shows a man speeding along on a jet ski.
The “Sister” skit went viral, with more than 5 million views on SNL’s YouTube site as of Wednesday. It’s shared everywhere – in Facebook groups for girls who have lost their mothers and on Reddits about caring for aging parents. It also makes the rounds in group texts and family discussions.
A friend told me: “My brother sent me this this morning with a laughing emoji – he knows I do everything. At least he’s self-aware.
Another friend responded: “My brother would be furious if he knew I talked about him that way. He takes himself very seriously. »
And indeed, the sketch goes further than humorously noting the unfair and gendered division of labor in so many families. It also exposes the way in which even the sister’s selfless care can be used against her, as the brother and father sit at the kitchen table during one of the brother’s infrequent visits, bonding over the sister’s supposedly controlling ways.
What’s fascinating about this viral moment is that liberals and conservatives, religious women and women who have no use for religion, women of different races and ethnicities, even women who love their brothers and women who can barely stand them, all acknowledge their own lived experiences in the skit.
Mulaney grew up in a large Irish Catholic family in Chicago, attended Catholic schools, served as an altar boy, and studied theology at Georgetown University. Although he no longer identifies as Catholic, his upbringing provided him with a seemingly endless supply of comedic material. He knows the particularities and rhythms of Catholic family life, the expectations, the guilt, the rituals. And he may know that the Catholic Church has a lot to say about the obligations of adult children to their aging parents.
Paragraph 2218 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church reminds adult children of their responsibility to provide material and moral support to their parents in old age, illness, loneliness and distress. Paragraph 2219 explicitly extends the discussion to relationships between brothers and sisters, emphasizing that family life requires mutual charity, patience and humility.
In fact, the catechism goes as far as paragraph 2231 saying, “Some (adult children) forgo marriage to care for their parents or siblings, to devote themselves more fully to a profession, or to serve other honorable ends. They can contribute greatly to the good of the human family. » Note that the catechism does not attribute any of these family responsibilities to daughters, but equally to daughters and sons.
Yet men’s responsibility to their sisters and parents is virtually absent from the rhetoric of the contemporary Christian and Catholic men’s movement, which has devoted enormous energy to teaching men the virtues of being good husbands and fathers, and almost none to being good brothers and sons.
Consider The Catholic Gentleman, a popular Catholic male apostolate whose motto is “Be a Man.” Be a saint.” His website offers detailed instructions on “authentic Catholic masculinity” with almost exclusive attention to marriage and fatherhood. In articles such as “Biblical Masculinity: Why a Husband Must Protect His Wife and Family,” men are told:
A husband is like the center of the offensive line of a football team. More than just passing the ball to the quarterback, his duty is to sacrifice his body to protect the quarterback from defensive linemen. … As the offensive center, the husband defends his wife and children.
Fraternus is a Catholic mentoring organization for men that seeks to train boys and young men in Catholic virtue through relationships with adult male mentors. Their stated goal is to “present themselves as a firm and unrelenting voice defending the dignity of fatherhood, the need for fatherly leadership, and the hope of restoring stable homes.” Although Fraternus is an organization formed around the concept of brotherhood, it understands brotherhood solely as a relationship between and among men – a brotherhood without sisters.
In fact, in a search of leading Catholic men’s blogs, podcasts, websites and social media, instructions on husbands and fathers were abundant, while instructions on men’s responsibilities to their aging parents and sisters were almost entirely absent.
And yet, Christian tradition is replete with examples of men whose holiness was expressed through mutual responsibility, respect, and concern for women. Francis of Assisi was neither a husband nor a father, but his relationship with Clare of Assisi was one of the defining relationships of his life. Claire was not a woman over whom he exercised any domestic authority. Rather, she was his spiritual sister, a woman whose vocation he supported and whose dignity he recognized.
John of the Cross was neither a husband nor a father. But his collaboration with Teresa of Avila helped transform the Carmelite order. Teresa was older, more experienced, and a formidable religious leader herself. And she teased him like a big sister would, calling him a “stepbrother” because of his short stature.
These relationships suggest that men, and their sisters, would be well served by a broader model of Christian manhood than that currently promoted by Catholic influencers and advocates of “traditional masculinity.”
Imagine if the Christian or Catholic masculinity movement told men that being a good brother matters just as much as being a good husband or father. Or what if it reminded them that their obligations to their parents are not fulfilled by the women of the family once they have their own wives and children. So-called authentic Catholic masculinity might insist that the responsibility for caring for aging parents falls equally on sons and daughters, even when the daughter seems more competent, more available, or simply more accustomed to doing this work.
Of course, there’s no obvious male glory in handling doctor’s appointments and prescriptions, spending an afternoon on the phone with an insurance company, or helping an elderly person to the toilet – as the sketch shows. Contemporary rhetoric of Christian masculinity favors sacrifice when it attaches to a vision of masculine identity that involves imagining the man as a powerful protector and head of the family.
Being a good brother to your sister often does not involve force or domination. In fact, sisters often put their brothers in their place. An alternative model would instead require humility and a man recognizing that his sister’s time is as valuable as his own – and that her career, hobbies and priorities in life deserve respect.
Of course, there are countless men who devotedly care for their aging parents, just as there are families in which brothers bear the greatest share of responsibility. The problem is not that every brother is selfish and disengaged, or that every sister is a selfless martyr. Yet the hope that girls will naturally take on the physical and emotional responsibility of aging parents remains deeply rooted in American family life, which is why the sketch has become such a phenomenon.
The Christian and Catholic masculinity movements have a lot to say about what it means to be a man. These movements should consider reminding men that they were brothers and sons before becoming husbands and fathers, and that honoring their obligations to their family of origin is also essential to being a good man and a good Catholic.
Otherwise, as the sketch clearly shows, we are left with the alternative.
See you at the funeral!
Gn entert
