Charges against illegal immigrant dropped in Florida Publix parking lot death

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

The criminal case against an illegal immigrant accused of running over and killing an elderly woman in a grocery store parking lot has been dismissed.

He will not face any charges for the crash, Larry Basford, prosecutor for Florida’s Fourteenth Judicial Circuit, told Fox News Digital.

Several factors prevented prosecutors from pursuing and obtaining charges under Florida law, Basford said.

‘VIBRANT’ GRANDMOTHER FROM FLORIDA WAS KILLED BY ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT OUTSIDE PUBLIX, FAMILY FIGHTS FOR JUSTICE

Deborah Murphy killed in Florida

Deborah Murphy, 82, was killed in Florida on May 17, 2026. (Courtesy of Amy Edge)

“I think everyone would agree that what he did was reckless and negligent,” Basford said.

But “not all tragedies constitute a crime”.

This is heartbreaking news for the family of Deborah Murphy, 82, said Murphy’s daughter, Amy Edge.

Both sets of tires crushed her body before the car stopped, she and her twin sister Beth Schulz told Fox News Digital.

THREE-TIME DEPORTED ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS CHARGED WITH KILLING 6-YEAR-OLD NORTH CAROLINA GIRL AFTER COVERING A STOP SIGN

On May 17, Murphy returned to her car with a bag after a brief stop at Publix in Panama City Beach. Surveillance video shows her crossing the crosswalk toward her car when she was struck by a Toyota 4Runner reversing, according to court records.

She was facing the vehicle as she walked, the video shows. She apparently didn’t see it coming.

Florida DMV employee faces 360 felonies for allegedly helping illegal aliens obtain licenses without driving test

The driver, Carlos Suarez-Contreras, was a 26-year-old Venezuelan who was in the United States illegally, according to arrest reports. He was operating the vehicle with a revoked Georgia license, according to arrest records.

Florida illegal immigrant Carlos Suarez-Contreras charged in death of Deborah Murphy

Carlos Suarez-Contreras was arrested after the death of Deborah Murphy. (Bay County Sheriff’s Office)

Murphy was pushed to the ground by the SUV. But it didn’t stop.

ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT TRUCKER CHARGED IN ACCIDENT THAT KILLED MOM AND 2 YOUNG SONS ON ROUTE TO AIRPORT

The car continued to reverse, “running over Ms. Murphy,” according to an arrest affidavit submitted by the Florida Highway Patrol.

Suarez-Contreras was charged with driving on a revoked license and causing death, a third-degree felony.

HOLDERS ICE LODGES FOR ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT CHARGED IN WRONG-TRACK CRASH IN MARYLAND THAT KILLED MOM, DAUGHTER

He was held without bail because of his immigration status and because he was considered a “potential flight risk,” according to Florida Highway Patrol records.

Murphy was taken to a hospital and died of blunt force injuries less than an hour later, her daughters said.

Prosecutors worked on the case for nearly six months, searching for answers that could lead to a conviction.

“We tried to leave no stone unturned,” Basford said.

ILLEGAL FOREIGNER’S ‘INEXCUSABLE’ CRIME TRIGGES INTERSTATE CLASH BETWEEN GOP SEN AND DEM GOVERNMENT: ‘YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED’

They found that Suarez-Contreras’ driver’s license had been revoked. But he only became disabled a day before the accident.

The Georgia Department of Driver Services confirmed to Fox News Digital that Suarez-Contreras’ license had been revoked.

Citing privacy concerns, an agency spokeswoman would not say when the cancellation was reversed, or when it would have been informed.

A non-U.S. citizen establishing residency in Georgia “must obtain a Georgia driver’s license within 30 days,” according to the Georgia Department of Driver Services website.

A non-U.S. citizen is considered a resident if he or she “accepts employment or engages in commerce in Georgia and enrolls his or her children in a private or public school within ten days of beginning employment,” according to the agency.

A person may also be considered a “resident” of Georgia if he or she is “present in the state for 30 days or more.”

The prosecutor’s dilemma

Whether Suarez-Contreras knew the license had been revoked is what proved problematic for Florida prosecutors.

“Under the law, we have to prove that the individual knew their license was suspended,” Basford said.

Prosecutors considered charging him with vehicular homicide and involuntary manslaughter, Basford said. But they could not establish the culpable negligence necessary for this.

Using surveillance video that captured the fatal accident, investigators reconstructed the scene.

Given that information, they decided the SUV wasn’t reversing fast enough to prove Suarez-Contreras was driving “reckless” when he passed Murphy.

At the scene, the car’s passenger, Luis Sanabria, testified under oath to a law enforcement officer that it was Suarez-Contreras who was “driving the vehicle at the time of the accident.”

Sanabria had an expired visa, according to the incident report. He was released from custody and placed in the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), Jacob Navarro, public affairs specialist with the Bay County Sheriff’s Office, told Fox News Digital.

Illegal Florida Immigrant Luis Sanabria Arrested After Death of Deborah Murphy Outside Publix

Luis Sanabria, an illegal immigrant, was a passenger in the car when Deborah Murphy was killed outside a Publix in Panama City Beach, Florida, police said. (Bay County Sheriff’s Office)

In reviewing the charges against Suarez-Contreras, prosecutors relied on a Florida law passed in 2023. It invalidates the driver’s license issued to an illegal immigrant in certain states, such as California, Connecticut and Delaware.

Unfortunately, the legislation does not designate Georgia as one of “those liberal states that license individuals so freely,” Basford said.

Murphy’s family is devastated that there is no chance of justice being served, Edge said.

“We feel incredibly disappointed in the state of Florida, which is committed to seeking justice on his behalf,” she said. “It’s like reliving a loss.”

Murphy was healthy and likely had many more years with the family, Edge said.
Now she won’t attend her grandchildren’s weddings or meet her great-grandchildren, she said.

“This has been removed.”

Fight for change

Murphy’s two daughters don’t believe Florida won’t pursue a lawsuit. It could have set a new precedent for this type of case, Edge said.

At the start of the investigation, the prosecution team was very optimistic that they would obtain several charges against Suarez-Contreras, she said. The only question on their minds at the time was how long the prison sentence he would receive if convicted, she said.

She and her sister question how their mother’s death was investigated and why so much emphasis was placed on a reconstruction of the incident.

“We know the man killed her,” Edge said. “He never got out of the car. He never ran to help. He never stopped. He didn’t reverse. He reversed.”

The family also questions why Suarez-Contreras was not tested for drugs or alcohol and why his phone records were not reviewed. Still, Murphy’s body was subjected to a toxicology evaluation, his daughters said.

Deborah Murphy and her family in Florida

Deborah Murphy with her husband, retired Air Force Col. George Murphy, and their grandchildren on a Florida beach. (Courtesy of Amy Edge)

The sisters will continue to fight to bring positive change to this tragedy. They can seek changes to Florida law or how law enforcement conducts similar investigations.

SEND US A TIP

“We have a lot of different questions that we will continue to explore, but not in a vengeful way,” Edge said. It’s “more because we don’t want it to happen to anyone else.”

DO YOU HAVE ANY ADVICE?

It’s comforting to know that Suarez-Contreras is in ICE custody awaiting deportation, she said.

“We don’t want him to be able to do this to anyone else in the United States. Our goal now is to ensure that he is deported.”

RECEIVE THE LATEST NEWS BY EMAIL

Suarez-Contreras’ defense attorney, Russell Ramey, told Fox News Digital he was glad the charges were dropped.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

After the case was dropped, Suarez-Contreras was transferred to ICE custody on Nov. 15, according to the Bay County Jail. Fox News Digital was unable to reach him for comment.

Gn usa

Logo