Washington- Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas blocked President Trump’s nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser, a top Justice Department official, for a seat on the Dallas-area federal district court.
Cornyn told CBS News on Capitol Hill that he refused to return a so-called blue slip to Gaiser, derailing his nomination to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
“I think his nomination is no longer viable,” the senator said. Asked why he opposes Gaiser’s candidacy for the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas, Cornyn said: “He’s not a Texan, has no trial experience, and the White House tried to stall the Senate and didn’t allow us to do due diligence, as we must do for lifetime appointments.”
Gaiser was originally scheduled to appear before the Judiciary Committee for a confirmation hearing on Wednesday. But he was ultimately not one of the seven candidates for federal judgeships to testify before the commission.
Asked about Gaiser during an appearance at the Atlantic Summit on Tuesday, Cornyn responded, “He’s not from Texas.”
“It’s a fundamental problem,” he said. “The Constitution provides for advice and consent, but there has been no consultation, no attempt to work with the Senate. I have proposed an alternative, but we will see if they accept it. But I think the Senate is not supposed to be a buffer and…we have been that too many times.”
The Judiciary Committee selection process is designed to generate consultation between the White House and two senators who represent the nominee’s home state, which for the Dallas-area district court vacancy would be Cornyn and Republican Sen. Ted Cruz. Once the president selects a nominee, home state senators are given a blue slip of paper to indicate their approval or opposition of the nominee. A senator can also refuse the blue slip, as Cornyn did, which is considered a sign of disapproval of the nominee.
A district court nominee can only proceed and be heard before the Judiciary Committee if both home state senators return positive blue slips.
Mr. Trump pushed Sen. Chuck Grassley, the panel’s current chairman, to abandon the blue slip policy, but the Iowa Republican maintained the long-standing tradition of appointing district courts and U.S. attorneys.
As Congress now convenes for the lame duck session following the Nov. 3 midterm elections, the Judiciary Committee is racing to confirm the rest of Mr. Trump’s nominees to the federal bench before the new Congress begins in January and the Senate changes control. The Democrats are on track to hold 56 seats in the Senate, so few – if any – presidential nominees for federal appeals and district courts should get confirmation.
Mr. Trump announced last week that he would nominate Gaiser to the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. His candidacy was officially sent to the Senate on Monday.
As Cornyn pointed out, Gaiser does not live in Texas and his only connection to the state appears to be a year-long internship in Houston for a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit. An Ohio native and former solicitor general, he lived in the Buckeye State before joining the Trump administration last year as head of the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel.
Gaiser said in a questionnaire to the Judiciary Committee that he was first contacted about the district court vacancy by Cruz’s staff on Nov. 4, a day after Democrats’ resounding victory over Republicans in the midterm elections. He said he discussed a possible nomination with Cornyn’s office on Nov. 6 and was informed the same day by the White House counsel’s office that the president was considering nominating him for the position.
Gaiser’s questionnaire to the committee is dated Nov. 7, but it wasn’t until Nov. 10 that Mr. Trump announced he would nominate him to serve on the district court.
As associate attorney general in the Office of Legal Counsel, Gaiser was criticized for several opinion memorandums he issued, which provide the president and federal agencies with advice on legal issues and are considered binding on the executive branch.
Gaiser is the author of the controversial opinion provide justification for US military strikes on suspected drug trafficking boats in the eastern Pacific Ocean and the Caribbean Sea. He also said in an April notice that the Presidential Records Act, which requires the president to retain certain documents and turn them over to the National Archives at the end of his term, is unconstitutional.
A August Gaiser Review concluded that Mr. Trump’s outside advisers, who are not employed by the federal government, are protected from future investigations by Congress and the courts. Gaiser found that presidential communications with private foreigners are generally covered by executive privilege.
Gn usa

