DOJ seeks dismissal of its lawsuit in Alaska Senate race

The Trump administration on Thursday asked an appeals court to dismiss a civil suit filed last month in Alaska that sought to take the extraordinary step of blocking certification of a state-run election unless the incumbent Senate Republican emerges victorious.

Democratic candidate Mary Peltola ended up winning the race this week.

The lawsuit, filed by the Justice Department in October, followed President Donald Trump’s repeated claims that the inclusion of candidate Dan J. Sullivan on the ballot, alongside Senator Dan S. Sullivan, was a scheme to “defraud” voters.

Dan J. Sullivan and Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, R-Alaska.
Dan J. Sullivan and Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, R-Alaska.AP; Getty

In its filing Thursday, the Justice Department asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to declare the lawsuit moot, citing Peltola’s victory.

“The United States brought this lawsuit to ensure that the State and its agents fulfill Alaska’s obligation to protect the integrity of its elections,” Assistant Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward wrote in the filing.

He added that the government therefore “reluctantly recognizes that there is no longer any way” to examine whether the votes cast for Dan J. Sullivan were intended to be cast for the outgoing president.

The ability to prove that voters voted incorrectly was seen by many as an insurmountable obstacle when the suit was initially filed.

Before the Trump administration filed its suit, the Alaska Supreme Court ruled in June that Dan J. Sullivan was eligible to remain on the ballot.

On November 1, a federal judge in Alaska rejected the administration’s request to segregate and preserve some ballots in the Senate election, following a request from the Republican-led state government that the judge permanently dismiss the “meritless lawsuit.”

Trump insisted in the weeks before the election that Sullivan’s two nominees would create confusion among voters and said he was the one who encouraged the lawsuit.

“I’m the one who said do it,” he told reporters during his midterm blitz in October.

Days after the administration filed the lawsuit, The New York Times reported that Peltola’s campaign was involved in recruiting Dan J. Sullivan to enter the race. Peltola has denied any wrongdoing.

Trump has argued that Peltola should be prosecuted for these allegations, saying on October 28, “This is voter fraud at the highest level” and that Peltola “should be removed from the ballot and prosecuted, just like fake Dan Sullivan.”

Peltola won the Alaska Senate race with an outright majority, meaning the state did not have to use its ranked-choice tabulation process to determine a winner. As a result, votes cast for either Sullivan did not affect the outcome.

Alaska is not the only place where the Trump administration has attempted to interfere in the election process, which is conducted by state officials under U.S. law.

In California, the Justice Department asked state officials to set aside about 20,000 ballots that it said were sent to noncitizens. California officials argued that the list of suspected noncitizens provided by the DOJ was outdated and included legitimate voters.

The Supreme Court rejected the Trump administration’s efforts a day before the election, and the Justice Department moved to dismiss its suit later in the week.

Gn headline

Logo