Fears are growing that the United States could impose sanctions on judges at the International Court of Justice, including this year’s Nobel Peace Prize winner, Navi Pillay, if the court rules on Thursday that the Myanmar government committed genocide against the Rohingya.
The ICJ has never found a state responsible for committing genocide, and an important factor in previous cases has been how to prove “intent” for a crime defined as acts committed with “the intent to destroy, in whole or in part” a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.
Lawyers representing Rohingya survivors say the Myanmar military’s behavior, including killing people as they fled, shows clear attempts to destroy the group during assaults on Rakhine state in 2016 and 2017.
It is the role of independent judges to interpret the Genocide Convention. However, the court’s judges followed advice on how to protect their assets from possible U.S. sanctions, as a ruling on genocide could be interpreted by Washington as lowering the “legal threshold” for the crime.
The Foundation for Defense of Democracies, an influential think tank close to the White House, predicted that a ruling on the genocide would lead the United States to impose sanctions on the ICJ.
The United States and Israel fear that the final ruling will clarify how to establish a government’s intent to commit genocide, and thus set a precedent that makes it more likely that the court will later rule that Israel committed genocide in Gaza.
Myanmar, which has denied committing genocide, says its actions were aimed at a military uprising by insurgents.
The ICJ, sometimes described as the UN’s highest court, is responsible for resolving interstate disputes, unlike the International Criminal Court (ICC), which prosecutes individuals accused of war crimes and other international crimes.
The United States has already imposed crippling sanctions on ICC judges after the court issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The United States also announced sanctions against the ICC as a whole as an institution, which it called a “rogue court.” Washington fears that the ICC will attack American troops.
Gambia, as a party to the dispute, had the right to appoint an ad hoc judge in the case against Myanmar and chose South African lawyer Pillay, who in October was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize. She must act as a lawyer and not as a defender of the Gambia.
Mike Waltz, the US ambassador to the UN, sent a warning shot to Pillay and the ICJ’s 15 judges, saying Washington “will not allow fake globalist judges to use the law as a weapon against our troops.”
Waltz asserted last month: “ICJ ad hoc judge Navi Pillay is tipping the scales in the current ICJ proceedings on Myanmar, intending to lower the legal threshold for proving genocide so that a weakened and false standard can then be weaponized against American and allied soldiers every time they raise a finger against terrorists hiding behind civilians.”
In remarks to Pillay, he said: “We are aware of your agenda and we will monitor very closely how the ICJ handles these proceedings. »
In a speech last Friday, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said: “For this global elite, international law…is an instrument to promote their interests under the pretext of universal principles. »
after newsletter promotion
He warned the ICC against citing laws to “men with swords”.
Israel has previously criticized unfavorable advisory opinions issued by the ICJ and refused to implement 2024 orders requiring Israel to admit more aid to Gaza and cooperate with UNRWA, the United Nations relief and works agency.
In the Myanmar case, a 24-page submission filed jointly by the United Kingdom and five other, mainly European, states argued that the ICJ, in judging intent to commit genocide, should consider a series of “facts and circumstances” assessed “in a comprehensive and holistic manner.”
He also stressed that genocide was not defined only by killings and that the treatment of children, gender-based violence and forced displacement were also relevant.
Until recently, the United States had taken a relatively more lenient view of the Hague-based ICJ and, under Antony Blinken’s leadership as US secretary of state, determined that Myanmar had committed genocide.
The 15 judges of the ICJ are elected for a nine-year term by the UN Security Council and the UN General Assembly.
Rubio gave the ICC until April to respond to his criticism before imposing sanctions.
On Friday, the ICC officially decided to abandon plans to prosecute U.S. soldiers and intelligence agents for potentially illegal acts in Afghanistan. The abandonment of the mostly inactive investigation came after it was agreed that evidence would be difficult to obtain, but one side effect could be a greater willingness on the part of the United States to abandon plans to impose sanctions on the ICC.
Gn world
