The new film about the founder of the Hershey Company begins with an affectionate, beautifully lit close-up of one of the company’s flagship products, a Hershey’s Kiss. That pretty much tells you everything you need to know about this effort produced in part by Hershey Entities and distributed by Angel Studios. With Finn Wittrock (American Horror Story) in the title role, Hershey is a bland, sanitized biopic that’s as sweet as the candy the company sells. Released on Thanksgiving, it essentially serves as feature film product placement.
The film, which an opening title card informs us is “based on an improbable true story,” begins in 1870 with a young Milton (James Kelly) growing up in a Mennonite community in rural Pennsylvania. After the tragic death of his younger sister and the abandonment of the family by his dreamy father (Alan Ruck), he begins working for a kind pastry chef, Joseph Royer (Richard Kind, at his most brilliant), who teaches him the methods of making candy.
Hershey
The essentials
Will give you cavities.
Release date: Wednesday November 25
Cast: Finn Wittrock, Alexandra Daddario, Alan Ruck, Richard Kind, David Costabile, James Kelly, Michael Moreland Milligan, Daniel David Stewart, Joel Brady, Francesca Faridany, Dina Spybey-Waters, John Hans Tester, Heléne Yorke, Mark Ashworth, Isabel Van Natta
Director:Mark Waters
Screenwriters: Sharon Paul, Timothy Michael Hayes
Rated PG, 1 hour 50 minutes
Milton soon invents original candies and eventually opens his own store specializing in (oh, the irony) caramels. The store failed, but the young entrepreneur was undeterred and tried again with a store in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, which took off after a bulk order from a visiting Englishman.
Sharon Paul and Timothy Michael Hayes’ episodic screenplay chronicles Hershey’s rise to prominence in a respectful manner, including its eventual transition to producing chocolates. This followed a visit from a salesman representing a German chocolate company who, after being rejected by Hershey because the product tasted bitter, warned: “I think you’re missing the rest.” Sure enough, Hershey changes his mind, realizing that all chocolate needs is a little milk to make it taste better. The rest, as they say, is history.
“Caramel is in, but chocolate is permanent,” Hershey confidently tells his associates.
On his way to becoming a chocolate titan, Hershey meets the adorable Kitty (Alexandra Daddario), whose love story fuels much of the film’s second half. He transformed the village where he grew up into the industrial town that still bears his name, treating his employees kindly (violent labor conflicts that arose in later years were ignored) and, at his wife’s urging, opening a school for poor youth that still exists today. (What is not mentioned is the fact that admission was limited to whites; black students were not admitted until 1968.)
Another major plot element is Kitty’s serious illness, which prevents her from having children and gives rise to numerous scenes that see her almost collapse under Milton’s worried gaze.
Tasteless directed by Mark Waters (well after his Weird Friday And mean girls glory days), Hershey never manages to come to life, playing out like the kind of candy-coated dramatized film that would find its most receptive audience at the Hershey Story Museum in Pennsylvania. Every scene plays out exactly as you’d expect, with conflicts resolved by chance and Hershey benefiting from strokes of luck, including a malfunctioning machine producing what became known as Hershey’s Kiss and the couple miraculously avoiding a planned trip on the Titanic (they dance to their good fortune, which, considering what happened to the poor souls on board, seems a bit cheesy).
Wittrock, finally blessed with a period-perfect mustache, does a reasonably good job but is ultimately unable to overcome the script’s shortcomings. Daddario fares better, conveying a tender warmth and playfulness that imbues the film with much of its heart. (Strangely, Wittrock eventually gets an old-age makeup treatment while Daddario looks virtually the same everywhere). Supporting players including David Costabile (Billions) as a composite business competitor, do exactly what is expected of them.
The film ends predictably, with period photographs of real-life figures and present-day images of the school and its grateful students. This is followed by one of those annoying “Pay It Forward” speeches, delivered with gusto by Wittrock and Daddario, urging us to pour more money into the studio coffers under the guise of philanthropy.
Gn entert
