How did Republicans lose so much in North Carolina? | North Carolina

Republicans suffered considerable losses across the country in the midterm elections, but perhaps nowhere as large as in North Carolina.

Democrats flipped a U.S. Senate seat for the first time since 2008, as well as five House seats, including one that Cook Political Report had rated as “solid” Republican, and four others considered “likely” Republican. Democrats also held power in the state’s 1st District, which Republicans had targeted in a redistricting effort.

One of the seats Democrats flipped belonged to Richard Hudson, a representative who led House Republicans’ re-election efforts as head of the National Republican Congressional Committee. It was the first time an NRC president lost a general election.

As of Monday, the Associated Press had not called four of the House elections, but two were leaning in favor of Democrats.

North Carolina’s statewide seat has been flipped to Democrats for the first time in more than a decade and Republicans retain the state Senate by a one-seat margin — which is currently heading toward a recount.

All this was happening in a state that had voted for only one Democratic presidential candidate since 1980 and hadn’t elected a Democrat to the Senate in nearly 20 years. So how did Republicans lose so much in North Carolina?

North Carolina Republican U.S. Representative Richard Hudson speaks at the midterm Republican convention in Dallas, Texas, U.S., September 10. Photograph: Al Drago/Bloomberg via Getty Images

“They took the voters for granted,” said Anderson Clayton, 28, chairman of the North Carolina Democratic Party.

“They thought they could manage to get a seat without having to fight for it, and I think the voters looked at them and said, ‘That’s not how we roll. That’s not how it works in North Carolina.'”

Clayton, who has been working to turn North Carolina blue since he was elected in 2023, points to several factors this election cycle: Trump’s unpopularity fueling North Carolinians’ frustrations with the current status quo and a fleet of young candidates running for office.

But she pointed out that one of the main reasons was Republicans’ inability to address issues affecting voters, particularly in North Carolina’s rural districts.

As an example, she cited a recent quote from Donny Lambeth, a seven-term Republican state representative who lost by eight percentage points.

Lambeth told the New York Times that he mistakenly listened to members of his caucus who told him he was in a “safe district” and didn’t need to spend “any money.” By 2024, Lambeth had won by around 14 percentage points.

“I thought, ‘Well, have you gone out and talked to any of your constituents?'” Clayton said in response to Lambeth’s admission. “‘Like, have you actually talked to anyone on the ground in your district?’ »

Felice Pete, a North Carolina RNC committee member and longtime Republican activist, acknowledged Republicans’ shortcomings.

“There are places we didn’t think we would lose, like Virginia Foxx, and looking back, people took that for granted. They were red, safe counties. And it’s just about getting the effort out the vote,” Pete said.

North Carolina Democratic Party Chairman Anderson Clayton at a campaign event for Roy Cooper in Raleigh, North Carolina, on November 3. Photograph: Matt Ramey/AP

The Associated Press has not announced Foxx’s candidacy in North Carolina’s Fifth Congressional District because of an ongoing recount, but his Democratic opponent, Chuck Hubbard, is ahead by a slim but likely insurmountable margin.

“The Republican victory in 2024 was not achieved with traditional Republicans,” Pete said. “They were voting for the first time, they were independent, there were a lot of young minority men, a lot of college-aged young men.”

“I just think with redistricting, we just haven’t focused on getting out the votes,” Pete said.

Republicans have invested time, money and energy to maintain their majority through redistricting, under pressure from the US president. They redrew the lines to try to flip the first congressional district, but it didn’t work; incumbent Democrat Don Davis retained his seat.

Clayton accused Republicans of becoming “elitist” in the midterms and relying too much on consultants — a criticism Democrats often face.

“Instead, you had real grassroots energy from Democrats winning seats that honestly, they shouldn’t have, in some ways, on Tuesday night,” Clayton said.

In some comfortably red parts of the state, like central North Carolina’s Davidson County, the electorate is up 16 percentage points in favor of Democrats compared to 2024, according to NBC’s decision desk.

Christopher Jessup, chairman of the Davidson County Republican Party and a longtime Republican supporter, said he wasn’t sure why that happened, but he attributed it to “probably some voter turnout.”

Jessup noted that his county still voted overwhelmingly for Republican candidates in the midterms and praised the work accomplished by his colleagues and teams. Despite this, the Sixth Congressional District, where Davidson County is located, shifted in favor of the Democrats.

When asked what the biggest issue was for voters in the county, Jessup said “a very negative view of Roy Cooper.”

Cooper, the former governor of North Carolina, beat Michael Whatley, the former head of the Republican National Committee and Trump’s direct pick, by nearly 20 percentage points.

The Republicans had anticipated Cooper’s victory. In October, the main Super Pac for Senate Republicans canceled the remaining ads it had booked in the state.

North Carolina Republican Senate candidate Michael Whatley at an election night event in Gastonia, North Carolina, on November 3. Photograph: Chris Carlson/AP

Like many Republicans, Pete continues to analyze why the messages that won over North Carolinians in 2024 haven’t resonated in 2026. But she has a few theories, starting with whether 2024 Trump voters felt “betrayed.”

“The word I keep hearing is betrayal,” Pete said. “A lot of these people felt like voting didn’t matter because they felt like 2024 was their last hope of getting this fix, and then they leave, and here we are.”

Pete highlighted Trump’s campaign promise not to start new wars, which he failed to keep when he started a conflict with Iran in February. This conflict, which Congress never officially approved, drove up the prices of gasoline and diesel, setting off a chain reaction that affected other daily costs, like groceries.

She added that the messages that appealed to voters in 2024 “started to change” or were not being communicated well by “some senior officials, or even our administration.” This includes mass deportations; During his campaign, Trump promised to target all undocumented immigrants, but administration officials now say they are targeting undocumented immigrants with violent criminal histories.

Citing a personal example, Pete said the young men she gathered to knock on doors in 2024 didn’t want to work for the 2026 midterm elections; she called the experience “a microcosm of what happened.”

“We need to have an honest assessment of this and fair to the detriment of not keeping, or seemingly not keeping, the promises that you make,” Pete said.

Gn headline

Logo