Photo-illustration: by The Cut; Photos: Getty Images, Emily Gould
I spent $33 on a ticket to see Passionate rivalry episodes five and six in 4DX at Regal Times Square, and then, because that wasn’t crazy enough on its own, I bought an extra ticket for a complete stranger known only to me as “americanxgirl.”
In case you didn’t already know, americnxgirl is the author of one of the funniest fanfics ever. Passionate rivalry fandom, “Your Flight Has Been Delayed,” which is about what happens when the author’s characters Rachel Reid, Ilya Rozanov and Shane Hollander, are kicked off the same flight and end up hanging out in an airport Chili’s, a setting that americanxgirl somehow manages to make hot. Since I knew from While it’s not exactly an airport Chili’s, I figured the Times Square Margaritaville would set the appropriate tone for the evening.
Americnxgirl was at the bar wearing a Raiders hat. It was her second time seeing the show in theaters but her first time in 4DX. Over drinks, we bonded in a way that’s only possible when two strangers know they’ve both spent time seriously imagining what it means to have a prostate. I learned that she had started writing Dusk fic as a teenager in the 2000s and returned to AO3 after a long hiatus when Passionate rivalry reactivated her like a sleeper agent. She works in book publishing and does improv comedy, which is basically what I assumed because her writing is effortlessly hilarious and her use of the semicolon is on point.
We braved the hellhole that is 42nd Street, climbed the maze of escalators and made our way to Theater 12, which seated 296 people and was sold out. Looking around, I saw the exact mix of girls, gays and them – some young, some old – that I expected. The only real surprise was that we were greeted at the door by a sign stating that our image could be used for promotional purposes. This gave a momentary pause to the moviegoers in line behind us (“I don’t want anyone to know I was here,” one of them grumbled), but we all went in anyway.
This mixture of humiliation and acquiescence is probably familiar to anyone like me who still thinks daily about this television show almost a full calendar year after its initial broadcast. I understand that an exciting romantic comedy about closeted gay men finding love despite being rivals in major league hockey exists in a total fantasy universe. So what gives this series such enduring appeal that its screenings can sell out a multiplex? I would like to offer an explanation: Passionate rivalry features two of the sexiest people in the world, who also have insane chemistry with each other, giving it their all to say “Will you come for me, Rozanov?” “Fuck, do me.” If you are a woman over 40 and are watching this show without feeling any excitement, it may be time to ask your doctor about HRT.
But while HOURThe obvious appeal of – taking nothing away from its excellent cinematography, deliberate and thoughtful editing and stellar acting – is that it is thrilling, the experience of watching HOUR in 4DX, it’s not exciting at all. It’s very funny though. When you’re strapped into a seat that moves and vibrates to the rhythm of the on-screen action, and the on-screen action includes a sneaky, cheeky blowjob, and your seat bangs to the rhythm of Ilya’s head movements… how can you not laugh uncontrollably? Other notable uses of 4DX technology include being fanned by cool Moscow breezes during Ilya’s famous tunnel monologue, as well as being fogged with water during the scene in All Stars where Ilya splashes in a swimming pool. Unfortunately, we weren’t fogged up to the exact moment he shakes his hair at Shane, who is lying on a lounge chair and trying not to look like he’s in it.
Overall, I would give the experience of seeing my favorite show in a movie theater 1,000 stars out of 10. It was worth $33 just to see Hudson Williams’ nipple in close-up on a 60-foot screen. But the 4DX experience itself was mostly strange and shocking. It took me a while to get jostled when, for example, Ilya sat down heavily on a bed. I wouldn’t recommend using this technology to watch this or anything. But if the clarion call of the big screen proves overwhelming, a word of advice: If you’re going to see it, note that the credits sequence after episode five, as well as Scott Hunter’s acceptance speech that opens episode six, is the perfect time for a bathroom break.
After the screening, americanxgirl and I caught our breath on the sidewalk outside and shared our thoughts, remembering how much fun we had. Passionate rivalry fandom had made our 2026. I told her I hoped she would write more soon, now that AO3 is back, but she told me she had other plans for 2027: she’s going to finish a draft of her novel, a romance with original characters. I can’t wait for us all to learn his real name when it’s released!
Gn entert
