If RJ Luis Jr.’s career at LSU is over, he will be remembered for one of the biggest fumbles of the NIL era.

In the spring of 2025, RJ Luis Jr. was considered a hot commodity. He was the 2024-25 Big East Player of the Year, helped St. John’s to a No. 2 seed in the NCAA Tournament and was poised for a huge payday — whether in the transfer portal or at St. John’s.

In fact, sources told CBS Sports’ Matt Norlander that Luis’ market was comfortably around $2 million when he entered the transfer portal days after his team’s season ended with a loss to Arkansas in the second round of the NCAA Tournament. That number would have placed him at the upper end of the salary scale among all college basketball players.

Instead, Luis bet on himself and entered the 2025 NBA Draft, where, predictably, he went undrafted. His chances of being drafted to a place where he would have made more money in his rookie season in the NBA than he could have made in his senior season in college were slim to none. Luis needed a first-round guarantee to break even in the first year, which was never going to happen.

LSU president asks Will Wade not to play RJ Luis amid potential SEC threat to kick Tigers out of league

Matt Norlander

LSU president asks Will Wade not to play RJ Luis amid potential SEC threat to kick Tigers out of league

By leaving college early and letting millions of dollars go to college, Luis’ story will be seen as a cautionary tale and one of the biggest failures of the NIL era. Luis’ attempt to return to college appears to be over – for now – after LSU President Wade Rousse “asked” coach Will Wade not to play him less than 24 hours after Luis made his Tigers debut in a 79-76 win over UL Monroe on Wednesday.

Luis played 15 minutes this game off the bench in what will likely be his first and last game with LSU. Not only was it, at best, a bold move on Wade’s part to play Luis in a buying match against an inferior opponent, but it could also have serious ramifications. Sources told Norlander that Rousse’s decision to take action against Luis on Thursday stemmed from the SEC’s “imminent and increasingly real threat” to expel LSU from the conference.

Why Luis’ situation was different from every other fifth-year player

The irony of Luis’s situation is that if he had stayed in college last season, there’s a good chance he could have played a fifth season like many other high school graduates in the class of 2022. His situation is different than every other fifth-year player due to the simple fact that he declared for the draft, signed a professional contract, and participated in NBA preseason games.

Luis should never have had the option to return to college in the first place. After he declared himself a candidate for the draft and was not recruited – while he still had college eligibility requirements and millions on the table – the ship should have sailed for any type of return.

Had Luis remained in the transfer portal during the 2025 offseason, he would have been one of the highest-paid players in college basketball. Additionally, an extra year of development at the college level would have done wonders for his overall game and could have made him a legitimate draft prospect.

There are some similarities between Luis’ case and what Alabama did last season with Charles Bediako. The former Crimson Tide big man returned to college (years later) after going undrafted and playing in the G League.

Bediako’s second act in Tuscaloosa lasted five games before he was declared ineligible. And this should never have happened in the first place. SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey has been extremely outspoken about this situation as well as Luis’s, which makes his appearance in an LSU uniform even more puzzling.

Wade did something Kiffin wouldn’t even do

The SEC took a very strong stance against returning professionals to college earlier this year when LSU football coach Lane Kiffin attempted to add Dae’Quan Wright and Zxavian Harris to the roster just before the start of the season. After numerous legal battles, Kiffin decided it wasn’t worth recruiting these players. It turned out to be the right decision.

However, when faced with a similar situation, Wade stepped in and when asked if Luis was playing Wednesday, he said everyone who played against UL Monroe was “eligible.”

“I’ll be happy to answer any questions you have about how he played,” Wade said. “But I’m going to refer everything regarding his eligibility and his roster to yesterday’s university press release. But everyone we played tonight is eligible.”

Wade put together a team in his first season in Baton Rouge that could be considered the most unconventional in college basketball history. For several months, LSU had only four players listed on its official team website. Wade and LSU were able to make most of the players they recruited eligible. That includes Luis, whose final act as a college player will likely be playing against the No. 307-ranked team in KenPom.

RJ Luis Jr. makes LSU debut as Will Wade defies SEC rules under cover of preliminary injunction

David Cobb

RJ Luis Jr. makes LSU debut as Will Wade defies SEC rules under cover of preliminary injunction

The irony of Luis being magically eligible nearly three weeks into the season is that LSU doesn’t even need him to be competitive this season. The Tigers were coming off an upset win over ranked Gonzaga on the road, which helped Wade’s team make an appearance in this week’s AP Top 25 poll.

LSU was picked to finish 14th in the SEC and appears on track to surpass that preseason billing, with or without Luis on the roster.

It never had to be like this for Luis. His legacy as a college basketball player will be tied to his brief time at LSU rather than remembered as the Big East Player of the Year and someone who could have had a seismic impact on the sport last season — and even this year if he ends up getting a fifth season.

After months of chaos off the field, this saga appears to be over. This will go down as one of the biggest sack fumbles of the NIL era.

Gn sports

Logo