Judge extends order blocking Trump’s Washington Arch for 14 days

WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal judge on Wednesday temporarily extended an order prevent the Trump administration from breaking ground on a massive memorial arch in the nation’s capital.

The temporary restraining order was set to expire Thursday, but U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan extended it for 14 days. That would keep President Donald Trump’s construction project on hold until Dec. 3 or until Chutkan rules on a pending request for a more permanent preliminary injunction.

The decision followed a November 5 order issued by Chutkan Shortly after a National Capital Planning Commission hearing concluded, the Trump-heavy commission gave the arch final approval in an 8-4 vote, despite dozens of witnesses opposing construction.

The administration declared that the works could start upon approval, the Department of the Interior issued a final decision authorizing construction and appropriate notification was issued by the National Park Service.

In announcing the latest deadline, Chutkan granted the request of plaintiffs in lawsuits challenging the construction of the arch. The case has become more complicated as separate groups have filed lawsuits demanding that the project not be allowed to move forward.

Nicolas Sansone, an attorney with the Public Citizen Litigation Group who represents the plaintiffs in the original lawsuit, said they were “pleased to see that the judge recognized that the circumstances that required emergency assistance two weeks ago have not changed. We hope the additional two-week break will give the court an opportunity to evaluate our arguments for a longer-term preliminary injunction that will block construction of the arch while the trial continues.”

“An activist district court has once again blocked construction of the long-awaited military Arch of Triumph. The judiciary should not be abused to politicize a structure designed to unite our nation,” White House spokesman Davis Ingle said in an emailed statement. “We will continue to defend this magnificent and appropriate monument and are confident that we will be fully vindicated as this litigation progresses.”

The District of Columbia and Virginia filed a complaint on October 31. Chutkan consolidated this complaint with the original, filed by a group of Vietnam veterans and an architectural historian. Members of the Kennedy family filed a separate lawsuit on Nov. 10, citing the impact the 250-foot structure would have on family members buried at Arlington National Cemetery. Arlington County Council filed a complaint on October 8 in federal court in the Eastern District of Virginia, challenging the speed with which the project was being undertaken and the damage it would cause to the county, which is immediately adjacent to the proposed site.

Chutkan said the 14-day extension of the order was justified because nothing had changed significantly in the litigation in the two weeks since it was issued. It decided to maintain the status quo while waiting to rule on the request for an injunction.

The arch is one of several projects around Washington that Trump has undertaken as he remakes the city, from renovate one of its famous public golf courses threaten to demolish the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts. These plans could soon face greater scrutiny after Democrats take control of Congress.

Many of these projects are being challenged in court. The federal government on Thursday filed a notice of appeal against a 14-day temporary restraining order issued on November 14. in the case of the golf course.

The original plaintiffs in the District of Columbia case — three veterans and a retired architectural historian — had asked Chutkan to enjoin the administration and the National Park Service “from taking any action to construct, or to direct or facilitate the construction of, any structure at Memorial Circle, without congressional authorization, during the pendency of this litigation.”

Critics, including the plaintiffs, say the administration must seek congressional approval for the arch and argue that once built, it will disrupt sightlines connecting historic landmarks in the nation’s capital. The administration argued that Congress cleared the way for a monument at Memorial Circle decades ago.

Gn usa

Logo