Judge suspends Army plan to detonate 5 tons of bomb-making material as Iowans worry about lead exposure

A federal judge on Monday ordered the U.S. military to halt plans to detonate five tons of lead azide after environmental activists filed a lawsuit expressing concerns about the blast’s potential impacts.

Officials at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant, in coordination with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, planned to destroy 68 drums of lead azide, a material used to detonate munitions, the Army said.

The detonation in the southeastern town of Middletown was initially scheduled for Friday, but was postponed until Monday after backlash from the public and elected officials.

“I have heard from many Iowans who are concerned about their health and safety due to the potential risk of lead exposure from the detonation,” Sen.-elect Josh Turek said Thursday in calling for a delay.

But the three-day delay didn’t calm the nerves of Lucy Giehl, who lives just four miles north of the munitions plant.

“What are they going to do over these three days to help people be better prepared? Giehl openly asked the Associated Press. “There are so many details that I feel like haven’t been covered with the public.”

The military, in a joint statement with the Department of Health and Human Services and the EPA, said Friday afternoon: “All agencies are working together to ensure that the controlled detonation in Middletown, Iowa, occurs as safely as possible.” »

“Officials have meticulously planned for this event since March, and all agencies involved are prepared to take the most extreme mitigation measures available to ensure there is no risk to the public and any disruption is minimized,” the statement said, adding that they will keep local officials and the public informed.

The judge’s order does not specify when the court will take further action in the case, but the EPA said in a court filing that it plans to file a response by November 22.

At a news conference Friday, environmental advocates called on state leaders, including Gov. Kim Reynolds, to take control of communication about the possible detonation.

The federal government, including the military and the EPA, could not be trusted to adequately inform Iowans about the risks of the planned detonation, Michael Schmidt, general counsel for the Environmental Council of Iowa, told reporters.

“Iowans deserve a transparent, coordinated and effective response to this unprecedented event,” Schmidt said.

CNN has reached out to Reynolds’ office for comment.

Possible lead exposure and broken windows

Lead azide is a volatile lead compound that can “explode upon shock, heat, flame, or friction when dry,” according to a federal hazardous materials database.

“Extensive modeling efforts predict that the potential level of lead particles in the air could be elevated,” the Army said. “The detonation will result in the formation of an air plume containing lead-containing particles which will disperse into the air and settle on the ground.”

Lead is toxic to the brain and no exposure is considered safe. But it’s unclear how much lead might be released into the environment after the detonation.

Lead is heavier than air, so its distance will be limited, said Patrick O’Shaughnessy, a University of Iowa professor and environmental health expert.

Any large particles would likely land within 20 miles of the detonation – “and then it will be just the smaller particles that get lifted by the wind and move downwind … towards Iowa City,” he told CNN.

O’Shaughnessy said he and his colleagues plan to test and monitor the air and soil to see the extent of the fallout.

In addition to possible lead exposure, loud noises and ground vibrations caused by the detonation could cause “localized window damage,” the Army said.

Daren Paul Morris, who walks his dog daily near the Army munitions plant, told CNN affiliate KCRG that he planned to evacuate. But he worries about the consequences he will face – both seen and unseen.

“I hope I don’t have any broken windows. I just had the roof replaced,” Morris said.

“I don’t know if I would mow the grass for the first time until it rains well. You know, you don’t want to kick up all that dust,” he added. “They didn’t really tell us how toxic it was… well, lead is obviously toxic.”

Jen Rowray, who lives in rural eastern Iowa, also worries about the long-term effects of lead.

“We’re very aware of the impact that a heavy metal like lead can have on the soil that doesn’t really go away,” she told CNN. “I mean, it can disperse. It can go a little bit lower…we’re very aware of how it can literally get into the vegetables that we eat, the root vegetables suck up the nutrients, and that’s going to bring them up.”

Iowa also has the second highest cancer rate of any U.S. state, CNN previously reported. It’s just one of three states where the rate is increasing.

Schmidt said Iowa’s demographics and resident behavioral factors do not fully explain the state’s high cancer rates. Instead, he cited the Iowa Environmental Council’s March report that suggested residents face additional environmental risk factors that contribute to increased cancer prevalence in the population. He pointed to Muscatine County, about 30 miles north of the Middletown military plant, which already has higher lead emissions.

“This just adds another layer of environmental pollution, endangering people’s health,” he said.

Rowray said there is a need for an outside expert who can come in and give a second opinion.

While she understands it’s an urgent issue that needs to be addressed, she doesn’t trust the military’s opinion, given the lack of communication, and would like more information, she said.

“I think we also have a right to be concerned about this drift, this panache,” Rowray said. “But sooner rather than later doesn’t mean rushing to where the public loses confidence because they’re not getting the right information and not getting the advice that seems logical.”

Conservationists said residents had received little information from the military about the potential detonation.

Schmidt wondered whether lead azide instability was a new problem requiring immediate detonation.

“The military found out about it several months ago and then gave residents five days’ notice,” he said. “I think there could have been a lot of different decisions and steps to get to this.”

In March, the Army discovered the degrading lead azide “housed in bunkers at the installation” and immediately began communicating with stakeholders and residents “about the danger it posed,” Acting U.S. Army Secretary Adam Telle said.

In the months that followed, the Army worked to develop “a scientifically validated and fully coordinated security plan before involving the public,” officials said.

After coordinating with the EPA, experts and the community, officials determined that a controlled detonation “presented the lowest risk to the public in the immediate area,” Telle said.

That’s because lead azide’s degraded status makes it “extremely unstable and sensitive to the slightest friction or movement,” meaning moving the material could be more dangerous, the Army said in a flyer distributed to the community last month.

“Packaging and transportation present an unacceptable risk of accidental detonation to handling and transportation personnel and the public,” the leaflet states.

But waiting too long to detonate the lead azide could present more dangers later, Telle said. He previously said Monday would be “the last possible moment before a predicted drop in temperature, which could further destabilize the material.”

The EPA emergency permit, which took effect on November 13, 2026 and will continue until February 11, 2027, authorizes the military to conduct detonation during this period.

Cleanup requirements under the current permit are insufficient to properly address the scope and degree of potential impacts, said Thien Chau, senior attorney at the environmental advocacy nonprofit Earthjustice.

He added that there does not appear to be sufficient understanding of the extent of the plume’s spread, nor which bodies of water, such as the Mississippi River, and land would be covered in lead dust, including where people live.

CNN’s Kara Devlin and Eduardo Cuevas contributed to this report.

Gn headline

Logo