Judge to order release of certain documents relating to federal search of Ilhan Omar’s home

A federal judge said Tuesday that he agreed with the Justice Department that the “vast majority” of the search warrant affidavit related to an investigation into Rep. Ilhan Omar should remain sealed.

But Chief Justice James E. Boasberg said he thought an exchange between lawyers and a federal magistrate judge over measures to protect the lawmaker’s “speech and debate” rights should be released.

“I agree that the vast majority of the search warrant affidavit should remain sealed,” Boasberg said during a court hearing Tuesday, adding that it was “premature” to unseal the entire search warrant affidavit. He later added that he believed information should be released about Omar’s “speech and debate” rights.

“The whole legal debate about speech and debate, I don’t think that should be redacted,” Boasberg said.

The Constitution’s Speech and Debate Clause is designed to protect the independence of the legislative branch and states that federal lawmakers “shall not be questioned elsewhere” about their speech.

Omar’s Washington home was raided in early October, an unusual investigative move against a sitting congressman just weeks after the election. As NBC News reported, Omar’s phone was seized as part of the search. The search was authorized by federal Judge Matthew Sharbaugh, who put protocols in place to protect Omar’s rights as a member of Congress, but those protocols were not made public.

Homeland Security Investigations police search Rep. Ilhan Omar's home
Homeland Security Investigations police search the home of Rep. Ilhan Omar, Democrat of Minnesota, October 12 in Washington.Andrew Leyden/Getty

Omar, who was re-elected earlier this month, said after the raid that it was “an attempt to target political enemies and weaponize federal law enforcement,” saying Trump had targeted her for 10 years with “baseless lies and smear campaigns.”

NBCUniversal News Group is part of a media coalition seeking access to sealed search warrants related to the Omar investigation.

Alessandra Serano, a Justice Department lawyer who works in the assistant attorney general’s office, acknowledged during the hearing that they were still reviewing documents seized from Omar’s home.

“Why can’t we reveal a lot of it now? » Boasberg asked Serano. “I’m not talking about the warrant affidavit, but the litigation that’s going on on the docket, I’ve gone through all of these documents and there are very few that say anything about the facts of the investigation or identify any witnesses…Why can’t they be unsealed now?”

Serano said there were elements that could be unsealed about the speech and debate discussion.

“None of this, you will agree, requires the mention of witnesses, of the government’s potential accusations, of the evidence that the government has developed, does it? » asked Boasberg.

But the Justice Department has sought to keep the nature of the potential charges against Omar secret.

People familiar with the investigation have told media outlets, including NBC News, that it focuses on potential immigration-related crimes. Omar is a naturalized U.S. citizen who came to America as a child.

Boasberg pointed out that Vice President JD Vance and President Donald Trump have spoken publicly about the investigation and even acknowledged the specific type of investigation. Vance said earlier this year that he believed Omar had “definitely committed immigration fraud” and clarified after the search that it was related to immigration fraud.

“Your superiors tell us what the government is investigating,” Boasberg said.

“I had no control over what was said,” Serano said.

“That seems to be a common refrain,” Boasberg said with a laugh.

Gn headline

Logo