A botched execution in Texas Thursday night that lasted more than an hour and left the prisoner screaming, begging the Lord to end his suffering, led to new calls for a national moratorium that would suspend all lethal injections.
It took 63 minutes for Reinaldo Dennes, 70, to be pronounced dead at Huntsville Penitentiary. The execution team had struggled to find a vein through which a lethal dose of the sedative pentobarbital could be administered.
Descriptions of the botched lethal injection bear chilling similarities to the recent botched execution in Tennessee of Christa Pike, who in September became the only person to survive a full dose of execution drugs. Both Dennes and Pike were subjected to lethal injection protocols using pentobarbital. In both cases, staff had difficulty establishing intravenous lines, and in both cases the prisoner expressed excruciating pain and burning sensations.
“The world has seen what happened to Christa Pike, and now to Mr. Dennes,” said Robin Maher, executive director of the authoritative Death Penalty Information Center. “The question now is, how many more botched executions will the American people tolerate?
A poignant eyewitness account of the night’s events was given by the prisoner’s spiritual advisor, the Rev. Jeff Hood, who stood next to the gurney with his hand on Dennes’ shoulder. Hood describes how Dennes struggled with pain for five minutes.
“Pain!” » Dennes shouted, according to Hood’s account.
“My leg, my leg, my leg,” he shouted, adding that his leg was “on fire.”
Hood writes in his account that Dennes “moved on the gurney, back and forth, back and forth. He writhed. He grabbed the leather straps and pulled on them until his body rose. His shoulder dug into my palm. Then it fell. Then it rose again. Twice he shouted, ‘It’s not working the way it’s supposed to. Damn. Damn. Damn. What is happening? Damn. Damn. Fuck.’”
Throughout the ordeal, Hood reports, the prisoner continued to pray, begging for an end to it.
“Take me home, Father. I don’t think this is right. Take me, Father. Don’t let me suffer like this. Come on.”
Dennes was convicted of capital murder in the 1996 death of Janos Szucs, a diamond merchant who was shot and killed in Houston.
Maya Foa, executive director of the human rights group Reprieve, called for a moratorium on lethal injections. She said: “Lethal injection is torture – and Reinaldo Dennes was not sentenced to torture. Even the most ardent supporters of capital punishment must recognize that the dominant method of execution in the United States is broken and cannot continue.”
The Texas Department of Criminal Justice insisted the execution went as planned. His spokeswoman, Amanda Hernandez, told the New York Times that “as far as this agency is concerned, this is 100 percent not a botched execution. This execution was successful, and we followed all the proper protocols to do it properly.”
But such a blanket dismissal of any concerns failed to quell a chorus of criticism. “Americans are now aware of the harsh reality of the death penalty, and I just don’t know how much longer state officials think they can double down on a false story,” Maher said.
Texas has been in the spotlight for many years for how it obtains and stores its stockpile of deadly drugs, a maneuver it is careful to keep secret in an attempt to escape public scrutiny. Following an international boycott, state prison departments began purchasing pentobarbital from pharmacies that make the chemicals to order.
Lawyers for convicted prisoners have long argued that supplies can be of varying quality and are often kept by the state beyond their expiration date, risking horrific deaths.
How Texas carries out executions will likely come under renewed scrutiny given the political upheaval the state experienced during the midterm elections. Not only did the governor’s mansion fall to Democrat Gina Hinojosa, but Democrats flipped 20 seats in the House of Representatives and won every seat up for election to the Texas Supreme Court and Court of Criminal Appeals, which have enormous power over capital cases.
Jonathan Groner, an expert on execution methods and professor emeritus of clinical surgery at Ohio State University, said Dennes’ execution illustrated why lethal injections were a “medical charade.” He said: “They mimic general anesthesia which is carried out in hospitals across the country thousands of times a day, by competent people, but when it is carried out in the death chamber without the necessary equipment or skills, people suffer. »
Groner said the location of the two intravenous lines placed in Dennes’ body — in one foot and in his shoulder — indicated the execution team was in trouble. “Putting an IV into the neck is very painful and difficult, and is a last resort; and the foot is not a first choice because it takes a long way to the heart for the medication to circulate.”
He added: “It’s time for the medical profession to take a stand on executions. People are being tortured. We need to stop and take a hard look at why we continue to do this.”
Gn headline
