So you say that you want autonomous governance of the conference. College sports have gotten so out of control under the NCAA banner that the only way forward is to make the rules and enforce them, all on your own.
Sounds simple, right?
Advertisement
Welcome to the Thunderdome, SEC. When you walk in, here you find LSU, once again playing by its own rules created by its own Louisiana judges, mocking you to your face and challenging you to prove that you have the courage to enforce the rules that the rest of the conference wants.
What are you going to do?
At the most fundamental level, what happened Wednesday night when the LSU men’s basketball team put former NBA G League signee RJ Luis on the court is the first big test of whether conference autonomy even has a chance of working now that the powerhouse leagues have tried and failed (so far) to bring the College Sports Protection Act across the finish line in Congress.
Barring a surprising shift in the direction of the wind on Capitol Hill, the SEC and Big Ten have determined that this is the likely future of their business in the near term. In order to take back some control over eligibility rules from lawyers and judges, they have largely decided they have to do it themselves.
Advertisement
The problem is that this requires good faith and cooperation among many schools that operate mostly as independent entities and answer primarily to their fans and donors, not to a conference office or a higher ethical standard for what is appropriate in college sports.
So all it takes is one actor in bad faith to ruin everything. And LSU is, more often than not, ready to push the envelope with Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry at the helm, a figurehead athletic director in Verge Ausberry and a head coach in Will Wade who thinks he’s bulletproof after being fired from LSU in 2022 for major NCAA rule violations only to get the job back four years later.
LSU coach Will Wade laughs and waves to Louisiana-Monroe coach Ryan Cross before the Tigers’ win Wednesday. (AP Photo/Ella Hall)
(AP Photo/Ella Hall)
“It’s like a scene from ‘Dumb and Dumber,’” one longtime SEC administrator told Yahoo Sports.
Advertisement
The restrained and conservative way of phrasing the reaction when Luis arrived about eight minutes into LSU’s 79-67 victory over Louisiana-Monroe is that people in the SEC were furious and in some cases baffled by the audacity of it all.
If you haven’t been following this closely enough to understand why, don’t worry. It’s complicated and mentally exhausting to keep up with every college eligibility mess that ends up in court these days.
But particularly in the case of college basketball, some schools and coaches decided last season that they could add players who had left college years earlier and make them eligible via a temporary restraining order even if they had been drafted by NBA teams, signed two-way contracts or played in the G League. As you can imagine, the NCAA disagreed.
It also caused a backlash, particularly within the SEC, where former Alabama player Charles Bediako came back three years after turning pro, got a TRO, played five games, then became ineligible again after another judge denied his request for a preliminary injunction.
Advertisement
In August, the SEC passed new rules that would allow the conference to suspend coaches who bring back former professionals and fine schools 50 percent of their athletic budgets, with Commissioner Greg Sankey given wide latitude to impose more sanctions. The motivation for adopting this rule was – you guessed it – LSU football coach Lane Kiffin was trying to bring back players who had left NFL training camps.
Ultimately, after a series of strong statements and threats to kick LSU out of the league, LSU backed down and decided not to sign the former pros because they would be crazy to do anything else. RIGHT? RIGHT?
Well, the madman is apparently back in town in the form of Wade, one of sports’ classic scoundrels (although he probably wouldn’t mind that label) who cares little for the affection of his colleagues and even less for the rules, you know. Remember, this is the same guy who was wiretapped by the FBI detailing how he tried to buy a player before it was allowed, missed the 2019 NCAA tournament because he refused to cooperate with the school’s investigation that followed, and then kept his job three more years until the NCAA allegations were finally dismissed.
After firing Wade, LSU became very bad at basketball for four years. Buoyed by Landry and his chosen president, Wade Rousse, LSU decided the only way to solve this problem was to bring back Wade, whose reputation had been cleaned up by two years at McNeese State (where Rousse had previously been president) and one at NC State. With NCAA rules and judges across the country ushering in the pay-for-play era, Wade’s past transgressions no longer mattered. What could go wrong?
Advertisement
Well, since LSU had no players when Wade returned, he mobilized his team around the world to offer huge sums of money to a variety of players in Europe and former college players who would be willing to learn what the Louisiana legal system could do for them. Enter Luis, who left St. John’s in 2025 after being named Big East Player of the Year, went undrafted, signed a two-way contract with the Utah Jazz and was even part of a trade before his 2025-26 season was cut short due to injury.
LSU signed him, sparking multiple lawsuits in multiple locations. The argument for Luis is that, from a fair perspective, college basketball is filled with European players who signed with club teams as young teenagers, making them technically just as professional. The argument against it is that you have to draw the line somewhere, and if the college part of college basketball is important, you can’t give eligibility to someone who voluntarily left college early to pursue a professional career and then wants to come back because things didn’t really work out.
Both perspectives have some validity. But in general, almost everyone in college sports — and especially in the SEC — supports the idea that adding G League players is ridiculous, even if there is a loophole or TRO that allows it. Everyone except LSU.
Advertisement
This is where the concept of self-government meets the reality of what it will actually look like. In playing Luis – going two steps further than Kiffin – a line in the sand was drawn.
LSU challenges the SEC to go beyond strong statements and take drastic action. Suspensions? Fines? A vote to kick them out of the league? But there are also the legal implications, which are unclear and potentially unpredictable. In another win for billable hours, everyone puts their general advice to good use.
The news Thursday morning, ahead of a meeting of SEC presidents, potentially centered on schools boycotting games against LSU. Particularly in states other than Louisiana, it is believed that this could hold up legally.
“I’m ready to take action,” a league athletic director told Yahoo Sports. “But try to cover all the bases. These next 36 hours will be interesting.”
Indeed, they will – with the concept of conference autonomy proving to be either a potential path to the sanity of college sports, or an idea that will be declared dead on arrival.
Gn headline
