The NFL’s sudden decision to suspend wide receiver Puka Nacua for three games raises many pertinent questions. On Friday, a technically irrelevant question was answered.
After Rams coach Sean McVay revealed to reporters that Nacua was operated on to repair a torn MCL suffered in a Week 9 win over the Commanders, NFL Network’s Judy Battista reported this: “The The NFL didn’t know Puka Nacua underwent knee surgery on Tuesday when he was suspended yesterday.
This is surely correct; Judy is a solid journalist. But that additional fact doesn’t matter to the NFL’s ultimate handling of Nacua.
The report leaves the impression that, during negotiations that resulted in the three-game suspension under the Personal Conduct Policy, Nacua and/or his representatives withheld material information. That, on some level, the league was misled by the lack of knowledge that Nacua had undergone surgery that would sideline him for “a few months.”
First, the suspension (like the league explained in the affirmative Thursday) is distinct from the injury. The NFL has listed several examples of players serving suspensions while injured.
Second, Nacua (who had already missed one of the minimum four games he must miss while on IR) was already going to serve the entire suspension while on injured reserve with or without surgery.
Third, the surgery and extended absence actually avoids the possibility that Nacua would have returned to action exactly one game after completing his suspension, which would have resulted in no net games missed due to the suspension.
The mere existence of the report represents an implicit acknowledgment by the league that the negotiated suspension, intended to allow Nacua to double his time on injured reserve and suspension, underscores the broader question whether players should be allowed to serve a suspension under the personal conduct policy when they are otherwise unable to play. This is a separate issue that the NFL will need to revisit, if it chooses, through a possible revision of the terms of the policy.
As explained on Friday, the league could have refused the agreement. He could have insisted on pushing the case through to the end of the process, with Judge Sue L. Robinson conducting a hearing and the outcome being appealable (by Nacua and/or the league) to the commissioner. But that would have implied a non-zero chance that Nacua wouldn’t be suspended at all.
For Nacua, the goal was to get the suspension while he was injured. The fact that he underwent surgery before the deal was finalized gave him more buffer than the NFL knew, expanding the window in which the suspension could be fully served before the end of the 2026 season without Nacua missing time due to the suspension. Which would still allow Nacua to have this problem behind him before the 2027 offseason, when he signs a new contract with the Rams, gets the franchise tag applied or becomes a free agent.
Of course, Nacua must now tread lightly. The league made it clear that “any further violations of the Personal Conduct Policy, including failure to comply with the terms of its diversion program, will subject him to additional and more significant disciplinary action, including banishment from the League.” To the extent that the league is not happy with the perception/reality that it allowed Nacua to serve his suspension at a time when he would not otherwise be able to play, the league may be willing to take any opportunity to impose a longer suspension that would apply when Nacua is healthy again.
Gn headline
