SAG-AFTRA forfeits thousands of dollars for non-payment of dues, fueling discontent

Colton Little had recurring roles on “Days of Our Lives” and “General Hospital” and guest-starred on “NCIS Origins.” This month, he became one of thousands of SAG-AFTRA members who were fired by the union for failing to pay his dues.

“I fell behind on my contributions more than a year ago,” he says. Varietysaying he owes about $2,000. “I was going through a lot. It got to the point where I had to prioritize paying my dues or paying my rent.”

He is far from alone. For the past six years, SAG-AFTRA has refrained from expelling members who failed to meet their dues, given the difficulties actors faced finding work during a pandemic, multiple strikes and a severe slowdown in production.

But on November 1, the union reimposed its pre-COVID policy that anyone who was 18 months or more behind schedule would be fired. This decision, made by the board of directors more than a year ago, contributed to an atmosphere of discontent among some members. Another factor is the board’s decision last month to extend the contract of Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, the union’s national executive director, by four years and give him a 15 percent raise.

Crabtree-Ireland was already the highest-paid union official in Hollywood, with a salary of $1.1 million. For some, the timing of the extension – just days before thousands of members were to be kicked out – was a bad idea.

“It’s like, OK, he’s getting a boost while we’re being kicked out,” says Taji Coleman, who was threatened with layoff but has since resolved her dues issue.

Crabtree-Ireland’s contract was not due to expire until June 2028. Sean Astin, the union’s president, defended the decision to act now as a “bold move”.

“Negotiating Duncan’s contract early and securing his services for an extended period of time is a sign of strength and stability,” Astin said, adding that the deal was approved by the union’s finance and executive committees before being submitted to the full board in an in-person meeting. “The fact that the union is not in the middle of a major negotiation or internal election cycle has created a healthy space to evaluate such a far-reaching decision.

The only “no” to the contract, Peter Antico, ran unsuccessfully for secretary-treasurer in 2025 and has long been a critic of union leadership.

“I wanted to fire him,” says Antico Variety. “I’m not in favor of giving this guy money.”

Chuck Slavin, who ran unsuccessfully for president last year, argued that the union needed “change at the top.”

“SAG-AFTRA is experiencing a true crisis of confidence, brought on by the withdrawal of thousands of members, a concerning lack of financial transparency, disastrous contracting decisions, growing threats to retirement and health care security, inadequate AI protections, and leadership increasingly disconnected from the very members it is meant to serve,” Slavin said.

Crabtree-Ireland has sought to stay out of the internal political fray, which will become more intense as the union heads into its election season next spring. The extension of his contract now gives him the assurance that his mandate will not depend on the result of this vote.

In an interview, Crabtree-Ireland declined to comment on his contract, preferring to leave that to others. But he addressed concerns about member layoffs, health care and other issues facing the union.

“The industry is in a period right now where people are very anxious because of the slowdown in production and what happened with Warner Bros. and Paramount,” Crabtree-Ireland said. “People are feeling a lot of general anxiety about it, which makes (the layoffs) even more distressing.”

SAG-AFTRA members pay 1.575% of their covered income in dues. The union is unusual in that members who are not working can remain active, as long as they pay $246 a year in “base dues.” Some members may not have worked in decades. But Crabtree-Ireland argues it’s important to the union’s finances that members pay something.

“I think the members who pay dues want it to be fair,” he says.

The slowdown also caused many actors to lose their union health insurance. In recent months, Drake Bell and Heather Matarazzo have posted about their inability to qualify, while Cheyenne Jackson has launched a campaign to help actors who are “one job away” from reaching the threshold.

The earnings threshold is expected to increase to $28,933 in January. The vast majority of SAG-AFTRA members do not make enough money to qualify for coverage. As members lose insurance, many are forced to turn to the individual market, where premiums are much more expensive and rising quickly, in part because of reductions in federal support.

This led to frustration with the union.

“I think the main reason this is happening now is due to the slowdown in work, not changes to the health plan or eligibility,” Crabtree-Ireland says, noting that the income threshold is increasing by 3%.

Little, who was among those fired from the union this month, says he ended up working several side jobs to make ends meet. When he realized he was about to lose his membership, he contacted the union several times to try to find a dues arrangement.

“I was once treated with almost indifference when I called,” he says. “It was so frustrating.”

He has no ill will towards the union, he says.

“I understand the need to pay dues,” he said. “There is also a reality. They must take into account the struggles that their members face.”

On October 31, he posted a video on Instagram in the style of a “Get Ready With Me” makeup tutorial.

“Prepare with me to be kicked out of SAG-AFTRA,” he said in the video, going on to explain the dire circumstances facing the Los Angeles cast. “There are no auditions. There are no roles. There is nothing to shoot in Los Angeles. It’s really bleak… After a lot of soul-searching, I’ve decided to step down. I’ve decided not to pay my dues.”

The video was meant to be an update for her friends, but it resonated with a broader group of actors facing the same crossroads.

“It’s not that I’m done with acting,” he says Variety. “I’m an artist and an actor. I love the whole process. At the same time, I think I just need to breathe.”

Gn entert

Logo