In 53 BC, ten thousand Roman legionaries disappeared in the eastern deserts following the catastrophic Battle of Carrhae. Decades later, Chinese chroniclers recorded a mysterious foreign force fighting in a tight fish-scale formation thousands of miles away on the Silk Road. Did the survivors of Rome’s worst defeat cross Asia to found an isolated village in Han dynasty China? What evidence supports this popular but unproven theory?
Disaster at the Battle of Carrhae and the Forced March to the East

In 1957, American academic Homer Dubs published a paper theorizing the presence of a Roman legion in ancient China. The story begins in 53 BC when Marcus Licinius Crassus launched an invasion of Parthia to enhance his military reputation. He was killed and his army was crushed at the Battle of Carrhae, where thousands were killed and thousands more were taken prisoner.
The Parthians, not wanting to waste their labor, found a use for the prisoners. The captured Romans were given their weapons and equipment and put into service. It may seem strange to rely on an enemy for national security, but this practice was very common throughout history, especially in the ancient world. This is something the Parthians were known for.
It was obviously out of the question to station these troops on the western border of Roman territory. The legionaries were dispatched eastwards, to the borders of the Parthian empire. They would end up in Central Asia, protecting themselves against bandits and other threats in what is now Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. Any direct mention of these soldiers ends there, but that is only the first part of the story.
Seventeen years later, the Romans may reappear in the historical record. Far to the east, Han China expanded, expanding further and further west, creating the Western Protectorate, areas under Chinese influence, if not total control. The Chinese clashed with the Parthians at Zhizhi, present-day Kazakhstan, and won a decisive victory. This secured Han China’s western flank, thus establishing Chinese presence in the region.
The Battle of Zhizhi and the Fish Scale Shield Formation

Chinese records of the battle mention something interesting. Some of the soldiers they fought against used what was described as fish scale formation. Some researchers believe it is the famous Roman novel testudo formation, in which Legionnaires lock their shields together to protect against missile attacks, resembling the overlapping scales of a fish.
The Chinese were impressed by these soldiers, and once again the Romans were employed by their captors. They were moved even further east, along the Sino-Tibetan border, to guard against raids. Specifically, they were moved to a place called Liqian, which shares the name the Chinese gave to Rome, roughly translated as “people of the West.”
Many Liqian residents today have Caucasian DNA and traditionally European characteristics, such as lighter skin, lighter eyes, and prominent noses. They are also generally much taller than their compatriots of Chinese descent. So, is this proof that the Romans reached China and fought for the Han dynasty?
While all of this evidence may seem compelling, the theory falls apart when examined more closely. The name Liqian was the Han Chinese name for Rome, but the same name was used for the Greek kingdoms of Central Asia founded by Alexander the Great and his successors. It is more than likely that with such limited contact between them, the name was more of a generic term for those of European origin, without any regard for ethnic subdivisions. Fish scale formation looks a lot like testudobut it is circumstantial. While it may be that it was Romans that the Chinese fought at Zhizhi, it may be that it was soldiers who copied Roman methods, or it may be something else entirely. A simple sentence is hardly conclusive evidence.
Modern genetic science and archaeological evidence

A significant portion of Liqian’s inhabitants do indeed possess Caucasian genes, but do they come from the Romans or the Greek kingdoms of Central Asia, whose inhabitants might have migrated along well-established trade routes to Liqian? The nomadic peoples of the Eurasian steppe, stretching from Hungary to Korea, are also a mixture of ethnic groups. It is therefore not excluded that Caucasian genes come from this source.
Truly, the absence of evidence is evidence of absence. To date, no archaeological findings have supported the idea of a Roman legion in central China, along the Tibetan border. There have been no finds of Roman weapons, armor or other military equipment, no coins, no votive religious offerings or anything else associated with a significant Roman population.
Over the past few decades, Homer Dub’s theory linking different lines of evidence has sparked much debate among academics and history buffs, but for now the evidence is circumstantial. The idea of the presence of the Romans in China is more fiction than reality.

