The world is “held hostage by the oil mafia”: how a small country is getting involved at COP31

The time has come as COP31 enters its final day of discussions, following a lackluster draft agreement that sparked strong reactions.


ADVERTISEMENT


ADVERTISEMENT

The annual United Nations climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, could extend into the weekend amid growing divisions.

Yesterday (November 19), co-host Australia unveiled a slimmed-down draft deal that removed all mention of fossil fuels – the main driver of climate change – despite growing push to publish an exit strategy.

This marks a repeat of last year’s COP30 summit in Belém, where the transition away from fossil fuels (TAFF) was erased from the final agreement following resistance from fossil fuel exporting countries.

Panama threatens to block COP31 final agreement

COP agreements require consensus from all parties – almost 200 countries – meaning progress is often slow and incremental.

However, Panama appears to be putting its foot down, threatening to block any final agreement that does not respect the oil production cap, while vehemently defending science.

In a letter to COP31 hosts, Panamanian Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro said his country “will not join any consensus and will formally oppose during the closing plenaries the adoption of any decision that does not lead to an outcome satisfactory” to its principles and values.

Navarro added that Panama would “not lend its name” to “complacent or ineffective language” in the final agreement.

Earlier this week, the politician claimed the world was being “held hostage by the oil mafia” and nations were “in love with its captors.”

“They torture us for our own good, they destroy our planet for our own good. They destroy nature to help us, and they demand our unrequited, endless, unlimited, limitless love. And we are so stupid that we fall into the trap.”

TAFF roadmaps gain popularity outside UN mandate

Nations agreed at COP28 in Dubai in 2023 to move away from fossil fuels, but the language around energy sources is hotly contested at the annual negotiations.

However, following the first TAFF conference in Santa Marta, Colombia, which took place in April, several countries established their own exit strategies – with Europe leading the way.

Before COP31, France, Germany and the Netherlands published national roadmaps to exit coal, oil and gas.

On November 11, after two days of negotiations, Finland affirmed its commitment to TAFF.

Almost a week later (November 17), Denmark, Portugal, Luxembourg and Spain announced their own national plans.

Although “one can always wish and fight” for TAFF to be anchored in the coverage decision, “this is not for us the ultimate benchmark for success,” State Secretary of the German Environment Ministry Heike Henn told reporters on Monday (November 16), before the draft was published. “Success lies in action, in a growing coalition,” she said.

What will COP31 actually decide?

Experts have criticized the deletion of fossil fuels from the latest draft deal, warning that the negotiations risk becoming a “shadow COP”.

“The summit will have nothing to show for what happened here,” Mohamed Adow, founder and director of the climate think tank Power Shift Africa, said Thursday, November 19.

“After the progress made in 2023 at COP28 in Dubai, where fossil fuels were mentioned for the first time, there is now no mention of the f-word.

“COP31 was silenced in the face of the most significant threat causing the climate crisis. »

Inga Fritzen Buan of environmental group WWF told the AFP news agency that some large fossil fuel producers are trying to “undermine” everything related to reducing emissions and the energy transition.

“With this draft, they are successful,” Buan added. “This is not a simple disagreement over the placement of a comma.”

Electrification in the spotlight

The latest text included a call to increase the global share of final energy demand met by electricity to 35 percent by 2035 – a key initiative by Turkey.

However, concern remains that the draft agreement does not explicitly require that additional electricity be generated from clean energy rather than coal or gas.

“We are going to fight for clean electrification” ensured by renewable energies and nuclear power, French Minister of Ecological Transition, Monique Barbut, told the press.

Some countries have rejected calls to scale up carbon capture, utilization and storage technologies, which critics see as a costly distraction from reducing pollution.

The draft also proposes new discussions with a view to “tripling” funding for climate adaptation measures by 2035, but abandons the target of 120 billion dollars (around 109 billion euros) sought by developing countries.

Rich countries have long resisted calls to increase support for countries struggling to adapt to climate change, citing budgetary constraints and insisting that large emerging economies such as China also contribute.

The draft agreement also contains a recognition of the “best available science” and a reference to the work of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), a key battleground at COP31.

Gn headline

Logo