A man who defended himself in his capital murder case and refused a jury trial will be executed in Florida, a judge ruled Friday.
In a rare and largely unprecedented move in a death penalty case, Tomasz Kosowski represented himself and waived his right to a jury trial, letting a judge in Pinellas County, Florida, decide his fate.
Prosecutors presented the state’s case over six days in September, telling the judge how the former plastic surgeon approached an attorney, Steven Cozzi, in the restroom of his office building on a Tuesday morning in 2023. Cozzi, whose law firm was then embroiled in a contentious civil dispute with Kosowski, was never seen again.
At a brief sentencing hearing Friday, the judge handed the parties a pre-written sentencing ruling and then announced his decision to order Kosowski dead.
“The court finds that the defendant, under the laws of the State of Florida, has forfeited his right to life,” Judge Joseph Bulone said in court Friday afternoon. “Accordingly, it is ordered and adjudicated that the defendant Tomasz Kosowski is sentenced to death for the murder of Steven Cozzi.”
Kosowski, who fired his court-appointed criminal his lawyers a few weeks before the trial, did not present a case for his defense.
He made a closing argument, addressing the judge directly to suggest that prosecutors had failed to prove the statutory elements of first-degree murder. In a soft voice, leaning toward the microphone, Kosowski spoke for about 20 minutes about Cozzi’s lack of body or death certificate.
Kosowski, 47, also refused to present a case during the penalty phase and offered no mitigation documents or statements to justify sparing his life.
The judge appointed an independent special counsel to present mitigating evidence regarding Kosowski to support a life sentence rather than the death penalty.
The attorney spoke in court about Kosowski’s upbringing as a Polish immigrant who moved with his parents to Kansas as a youth and how the Ivy League-educated doctor could help other inmates in prison. No witnesses took the stand in support of Kosowski.
Bulone acknowledged some mitigating circumstances in Kosowski’s favor, but said they were particularly outweighed by the “cold and calculated” manner in which Kosowski murdered Cozzi.
“The court placed great weight on the aggravating circumstance that the homicide was committed in a cold, calculated and premeditated manner, without any pretense of moral or legal justification,” Bulone said during sentencing.
As sentencing began, Kosowski made a motion to recuse the judge, leading Bulone to briefly adjourn the hearing to review it. The judge returned to the bench a few minutes later without responding to the motion.
Prosecutors had highlighted the premeditation of Cozzi’s murder as an aggravating circumstance to justify Kosowski’s death.
In 2019, Kosowski sued former colleagues over a billing dispute, and in 2022 he began representing himself, connecting him directly with attorneys for other doctors, including Cozzi.
Kosowski expressed animosity toward Cozzi as the civil proceedings stretched on for years, prosecutors said at trial.
The plastic surgeon researched Cozzi online, drove to his home and staked out the law firm’s office several times in the months before Cozzi’s murder, according to trial evidence.
Cozzi became an “obsession” for Kosowski, Assistant Prosecutor Nathan Vonderheide said during closing arguments.
On March 21, 2023, Cozzi went to the bathroom down the hall from his office, leaving a draft email open and music playing on his phone.
He never returned to his office.
Prosecutors say Kosowski waited for the lawyer in the bathroom and killed him there before dragging Cozzi’s body out of the building in a cart.
Surveillance footage shows a man entering the building and hours later – wearing different clothes – dragging a shopping cart toward the parking lot.
Kosowski joined a 10:30 a.m. virtual hearing for their joint case from the law office parking lot, minutes after carrying Cozzi’s body out of the building, according to prosecutors.
The doctor sought sanctions against Cozzi, seeking to remove the attorney from the case, but Cozzi was not on the call, prompting other members of the firm to search for him and report him missing.
After a stop at his waterfront home, Kosowski took Cozzi’s body to a dumpster on a remote road nearly four hours away, trial evidence showed, then continued to Miami where he performed scheduled surgeries the next day.
Investigators arrived too late to find evidence of Cozzi – the contents of the dumpster had already been sent to a landfill.
Kosowski was the only person known to have a problem with Cozzi, the attorney’s husband and colleagues told law enforcement at the time, quickly establishing the surgeon as a person of interest in Cozzi’s disappearance.
Kosowski was arrested four days after the killing with nearly $300,000 in cash, two passports and a “crime bag” in his trunk, prosecutors said at the trial.
Video of the arrest shown in court shows the doctor in the back of a police car meticulously sucking each of his fingers after twisting his handcuffed wrists behind his body, under his feet and on his knees.. He also had several bruises and scratches all over his body, photos shown in court showed.
Cozzi’s blood was found in the bed of Kosowski’s pickup truck and on a ballistic vest in the trunk of Kosowski’s second car, DNA results submitted at trial confirmed.
